Subcompact DASA or DAO recommendations/warnings?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have several friends who carry guns they do not shoot. Why? They carry small, light guns that are uncomfortable to shoot much and they are inaccurate with them.

It’s my view, carry what you shoot well. If it’s a heavier gun, like me, get a good holster than spreads the weight.

In my case, I carry a Sig 229 DA/SA double stack or a STI C 2011 single stack with an external ambi safety. The SA is around 4lbs on both guns. Which I like, but don’t think is as difficult to fire inadvertently, without a DA or external safety, as I would like.
 
See the Langdon video at post #40 ;)
I did, I'm saying a Glock isn't a DAO handgun...It's more akin to a SA only with the striker spring compressed some(not enough to fire it tho), like a revolver with the hammer partially back, kinda sorta.

Son has a Beretta 92FS..really nice gun altho a country mile of trigger movement before it fires with hammer back. Short, nice reset but that first pull..He carries his Glock 43 or Glock 45..
 
That's what Langdon said
10-4..I was commenting on the OPs
I've carried double action only or safe action pistols for over 20 years and those that I really liked in terms of double action only are the Kahr, Glock, Smith and Wesson (I'm not talking about striker fired models)

Is all.....:D
 
Some great suggestions. I've enjoyed reading these posts.
Hope the Op finds a good pistol and posts some photos
 
Some great suggestions. I've enjoyed reading these posts.
Hope the Op finds a good pistol and posts some photos

Thank you! Me too. It's going to be a lot of dry fire drills at home for the next couple months, but once this pandemic thing ends, this gives me a lot of useful info to help my shopping. In particular it's gotten me interested in trying to find a used compact that fits me instead of a new subcompact. A $300 police trade-in Smith 6904 or similar is going to be better for my marriage than a $700 new HK...
 
Heckler & Koch P2000SK
Walther P99C AS
SIG-Sauer P239
Grand Power P11
 
Last edited:
Another LEM fan here, with a caveat: it is an acquired taste. You'll have to dry fire quite a bit with it to understand it and shoot it accurately. On the other hand, you don't have to worry about manipulating a safety, and you can keep a thumb on the hammer as you holster. I'm partial to the P30SK myself, but some others have suggested the P2000, and that would be a good option as well (and perhaps a little easier to shoot).

If you go the LEM route, let me know, and I can share some resources that really helped me learn it.
 
I have several of the guns that have been discussed. First the Smith 3rd generation. Out of production, but excellent guns. I have the 6906, compact, stainless with the 12 round magazines. It can also use the 14/15 rounders of the 5906 and I have several with adapter base pads, to allow it to conform to the shorter grip length of the 6906. It is DA/SA. The 6906 in stock configuration has no spur on the hammer, so you can't cock it manually. I changed mine to have a 5906 hammer which has the spur, and I like it a lot that way, as you can cock it for SA if you want, like most revolvers. Or you could just get the 5906. You normally would have the first round DA and then it is SA. Or you can cock it manually. I am fine with that, but it is not like a revolver that way, if you were firing only DA. Although there are DAO versions of the Smiths. You should find one and handle it. You can put your thumb on the hammer when re-holstering. If the hammer is back, like firing in SA, you need to drop the safety before re-holstering. Check them out. There are a gazillion of them out there, and they are generally cheap compared to other guns. And there are dozens of different models/varieties. But they are great guns.

Then I have the Glock 26. I love the gun, but no way is this a revolver. It is the classic striker fired pistol. Ultimate in reliability, and accurate. I have a light trigger on it, so I won't carry it with a round in the chamber. Too many instances of negligent discharges in my view. You can get the heavier "New York" trigger, but I have no experience with it. And you can't put your thumb on the hammer when re-holstering, although there is that extra aftermarket safety you can install which allows you to put your thumb on the back like it was a hammer.

Another gun that I have is the Sig P290RS. Out of production now, definitely DAO like a revolver with an exposed hammer. You can put your thumb on the hammer when re-holstering, and I do that with it. The problem you might have with it is that it is normally 6+1 capacity, although it also has an 8+1, with an extended magazine. But I really like the gun. It is solid, and has been reliable and accurate. And it really works like a revolver. DAO with restrike. It is heavy like a revolver, but feels good. A good pocket gun. And you can get them cheap, as they have been replaced by the Sig P365. Which brings me to my last one.

The Sig P365. I know it doesn't meet your DAO requirements. It is striker fired. And it has a light trigger. But it holds 10+1, and possible 12+1 or 15+1 with larger magazines. I don't like the risk that comes with that light trigger, like on my Glock 26. But I feel I can carry it safely, as I got the manual safety version. I carry it often. I really like it and feel safe with it. I carry it AIWB, but it can be pocket carried. But you would need to adjust to operating the manual safety. That replaces the "having to put your thumb on the hammer" business. I have used safeties often and am comfortable with them. It shoots really well. Feels good in my hand.

So good luck in your search. I also have several revolvers, and my favorite is a DAO. It is actually my favorite gun of all, and I do carry it sometimes. There is just something about a good revolver.
 
I have a CZ PCR that holds 14 rds. I was looking at a 2075D Rami to suggest to the op and noticed it to was listed as holding 14rds. How is that possible?
 
If and when the OP felt comfortable with the Model 81, a Model 84 could be purchased. The Model 84 is not as inexpensive, but it is identical except that it is in 380acp caliber. I think mine cost somewhere in the mid $300's used, though it took some patient haunting of Gunbroker to find it for that price.

There is also the Beretta Model 85, a single stack version of the Model 84.
 
The 6906 in stock configuration has no spur on the hammer, so you can't cock it manually.

This thread is getting elderly but I just wanted to make the point that the spurless hammer on the Model 6906 can be cocked manually by judiciously bring the hammer back a little ways with the da pull and catching the partially retracted hammer with the thumb and bringing it back to a fully cocked, sa configuration. Not that hard to do safely but a spur would admittedly make it a whole lot easier.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top