I'm getting ready to drop a Powder Valley order for myself and a group of 3 others - enough powder in all to eliminate hazmat but I'll leave it at that.
I've been using Win-231 (HP-38) a lot, and in the last 6 months have about toasted my 4-lb jug of W-231 and the 2lbs of HP-38 I had before that. I shoot plated and cast bullets in 9mm and 44mag. I also hunt with the 44mag and XTPs but I'm all set there with a stock of 2400 *and* H-110.
I LOVE Win-231 (again, same as HP-38) in both calibers in "target" level loads in both aforementioned calibers. I'd planned on dropping myself an 8-lb jug of HP-38 because, for reasons unknown, it's cheaper than the "same stuff" 231 by about 10-12 bucks.
ENTER Hodgdon Titewad. I realize it's one of the fastest powders around hands down, but it "appears" that it serves the same reduced cast/plated load realm in both 44/9mm calibers fairly well. And I'll be DARNED if despite loving HP38/231 that I'm not a stubborn, cheap bas-retard.
Am I going to HATE myself for switching off the ol' favorite here to Titewad? Or will I save on cost, charge weight, and keep my general satisfaction?
PLEASE note: I appreciate all the opinions sincerely, but I would ask that we stick to the powders mentioned - I've already 100% narrowed things down to powders mentioned and don't want "better alternates" in this particular case.
Thanks much.
I've been using Win-231 (HP-38) a lot, and in the last 6 months have about toasted my 4-lb jug of W-231 and the 2lbs of HP-38 I had before that. I shoot plated and cast bullets in 9mm and 44mag. I also hunt with the 44mag and XTPs but I'm all set there with a stock of 2400 *and* H-110.
I LOVE Win-231 (again, same as HP-38) in both calibers in "target" level loads in both aforementioned calibers. I'd planned on dropping myself an 8-lb jug of HP-38 because, for reasons unknown, it's cheaper than the "same stuff" 231 by about 10-12 bucks.
ENTER Hodgdon Titewad. I realize it's one of the fastest powders around hands down, but it "appears" that it serves the same reduced cast/plated load realm in both 44/9mm calibers fairly well. And I'll be DARNED if despite loving HP38/231 that I'm not a stubborn, cheap bas-retard.
Am I going to HATE myself for switching off the ol' favorite here to Titewad? Or will I save on cost, charge weight, and keep my general satisfaction?
PLEASE note: I appreciate all the opinions sincerely, but I would ask that we stick to the powders mentioned - I've already 100% narrowed things down to powders mentioned and don't want "better alternates" in this particular case.
Thanks much.
Last edited: