fjolnirsson said:
Just a thought here. There's a reason recruiters tend to chase the high school kids, aside from young boys in need of a career. Youngsters tend to have more, umm, "pliability", a certain tendency to obey orders given by authority. Lots of folks who've already been out in the world, taking care of homes and families are gonna be tough nuts to crack in Basic. How much extra time is it gonna take to try and remold someone who's been his own boss for 20+ years? I'm sure they'll figure it out, but still....
I'm not sure I'd buy that particular pig in a poke.
I think that the young 'uns are the best targets/candidates for recruiters because most are:
1. Healthy & resilient
2. Unencumbered by spouses, children, real estate, etc.
From my experience, yes, the young 'uns right out of high school lack experience. A lot of them also lack discipline, maturity, motivation, and direction, all of which drill instructors work mightliy to instill. Nowadays, a whole lot also have an irrational anti-authoritarian mindset that sees any/all authority as illegitamate.
It is not about being a "tough nut to crack in Basic." It is about instilling discipline, maturity, motivation, martial spirit, morality, and such to those who may lack one or more of the aforementioned traits. If you go to Basic with most or all of those traits, Basic is not a particularly difficult or wrenching experience. It is more of just another challenge to slog through. BTDT. If you go to Basic without them, you will have a bit more trouble and growing up to do...and a short time to do it.
Older recruits with experience usually are inducted at a higher rank than a recent high school graduate, E-2 to E-4, vs E-1. This is to indicate that the service understands that that particular recruit brings more to the table.
When I went through Basic, I wasn't the oldest, but was definitely in the older half. Strangely, none of us "codgers" quit or were found unsuitable for service. We also had fewer problems that required "counseling" and were less likely to freak when under stress. Imagine that.