Discussion in 'Rifle Country' started by AStone, Sep 25, 2015.
This is easy. A Marlin model 60.
Barn, I understand you're reasoning, but respectfully disagree.
But it's almost 10 pm on Sunday night, and I'm tired, so I won't respond tonight, even though I first read your post this afternoon and have given it considerable thought, based on my interaction with some world class scientists and writers, and being a science educator.
But I'm putting this here to remind me to get back to it in the context of gun makers.
My basic argument -- when I get back here -- is that your argument is a logical fallacy called "argument by authority". More asap.
This is a good discussion. Loving it. Thanks to all.
Correct. I bought that book 10 years ago and never finshed it.
Just to keep this from falling off the bottom,
I think the greatest rifle ever made was .22 LR.
But ask me again tomorrow.
Best Rifle made is the one you have in your hands when the SHTF.
Another vote for the venerable "U.S. RIFLE CAL. .30 M1"
AND, here it is!
At least, according to that guy...
I don't have one, but my Son has shot almost every one of
North American big game with a Weatherby Mark 5 Stainless
in .340 Weatherby. He has the Grand Slam on sheep and has
shot all the bears except the Polar bear. Nothing has ever gotten
up and ran away on him.
The best rifle, eh?
Could be a long thread.
Shift it to the most influential cartridge, possibly the most pounds of game dropped and a few other categories, I'd have to go with the .22 rimfire. Not least of all as a 'trainer' for bigger things.
Shift it to the most influential rifle and I have to look to the Mauser bolt action, considering the impact on about anything that would become a bolt.
Perhaps the 'almost best rifle' as far as an incredible missed potential, not that I'm sorry about that, could be the Ferguson Rifle. I'll leave that one for some thought.
*gets more popcorn*
This is probably the 'best' I've ever seen, in at least several categories;
-Among the best styling/workmanship/materials
-Among the strongest of actions
-Among the most powerful cartridges available to us civvies (50 bmg)
-Easily the best reproduction of a classical design I've seen
-Among the most difficult actions to manufacture (especially considering the addition of the swinging breech)
-Basically an anti-tank rifle fit for royalty
This is relevant.
I also am a fan of the Ma deuce. Used one in Vietnam 1969. At Dal Lat central highlands RVN. Also a fan of it's modern derivatives like the Barrett. As portable weapons go, the M60. A life saver for me. All the US military rifles M1 Garand, M14 and M16 are good to me. Had all three, used last two in service. My buddy featured in a couple books was issued a Luepold scoped armory built M-14 that is a special rifle. Pics in the books, "Black Horse Riders" and "Firebase Ellingsworth".
Civilian hunting rifles. My SS BDL 700 in 7 MM mag, followed by my Tikka T3 also SS in 7-08. But I have a crush on my buddies pe 64 Winchester Model 70 in 300 Holland and Holland. Now that is classy. A thing of beauty.
After 6 pages I think we can all agree that the topic of best ever is highly subjective.
Separate names with a comma.