What is the point of the 9mm carbine?

Status
Not open for further replies.
My RRA 9mm is hands down my favorite gun to shoot! It actually kicks a bit harder than my .223 AR. My CZ75 hasn't been out since I bought the AR, its getting lonely in the gun safe:p These things are just plain fun to shoot, hitting 4" spinners at 50yrds is a breeze.
 
Keeps the wife safe at night

I'm convinced the 9mm Storm Carbine was created to make my wife happy. Her first shoulder fired rifle shooting experience[pre meeting me] was a CAR 15, and the noise really turned her off. Last year she had a chance to demo a Beretta Storm, and instantly fell in love with the lightweight, ease of handling, low recoil, low NOISE, and serious fun factor:D

We now have a Storm in 9mm, with surefire attached and 20 round mag, in the by the bed for her, and she looks forward to every chance she gets to take it to the range.

That is plenty reason for it to exist as far as I'm concerned;)
 
Big 10/22

Yes, because you can. There is not pressing "need."

I've had a Marlin Camp9 for a decade, and it's a hoot to shoot. It's handy, reasonably accurate for what it its, and has a bit more 'oomph' than a .22 by a fair margin.

No, it's not a great Law Enforcement choice, it's not a long range varmint gun, it's absolutely not a deer hunter's rifle. But it IS fun to shoot, and anything in the "coyote-sized" class of varmints and such are in definite jeopardy when within 100 yards because you just might nail one.

Just like .22s we shoot for fun - no real need - but it is fun.
 
Generally, they're very fun to shoot. I have never used one for this purpose, but it would probably be a good home defense gun.
 
+1 on the SUB-2000's. I keep mine in my gear bag in the passenger seat. It is accurate, reliable, has a longer effective range than my sidearm and uses the same mags. I had no trouble qualifying on the patrol rifle course with it. If I need more than my pistol but can't get to my AR-15 it is a handy, quick to deploy option that is good for head shots at 50yds off hand.
 
What is the point of the 9mm carbine?
Why does there have to be a "point"? They're FUN, what more do you need? Not every gun has to have a combat or self-defense purpose. Go set up a couple hundred soda/beer cans full of water and start busting them with a 9mm carbine, I guarantee you'll be giggling like an idiot before you're done.:D
 
They (like the Hi Point 995) are good small, light, fast, cheap firearms for HD for people who don't have a pistol permit or live in areas where it is hard to get a pistol permit. Plus they are fun and cheap to feed.
 
My 995 shares ammo with my Taurus PT111 Mil-Pro but more than triples the effective range of a pistol with pinpoint accuracy, while at almost half the cost.

And the wife is comfortable shooting it...
 
I would love a reasonably priced 16" 9mm AR upper for my wife. She likes my M4 but does have some issues with the recoil and blast. Problem is by the time you get all set up (mags, upper, etc) the price is prohibitive. I am also wishing for a 7.62X25 version of the same thing. Probably won't happen for a while, I think the AR builders are a little busy right now.
 
This is the same question as "Do you need 5 shotguns, 10 rifles and a dozen pistols?".

Is it going to put dinner on the table or drop a deer? No, but it is a cheap plinker to take to the range when you can't feed your AR or 30-06.

Personally, I'd like a MP5 clone just for the sake of it.
 
For indoor use I'd much rather have something without the bark of a 8" or less barrelled rifle cartridge gun - the thought of firing my V51 indoors without a suppressor is something that makes me deaf just thinking about it. I have a .308 can but it adds weight and OAL to a point where it loses the pointability indoors I want in a HD gun.

I'm good with a pistol, but comparatively for accuracy and followup shots, I look like a drunken, half-blind conscript if I compare my pistol vs. carbine times and groups.

After 25m it gets even more pronounced.

The other point is there are times I'd like to bring something with a longer reach than a pistol but don't have room for a rifle, especially in ready to fire configuration. The K may be bigger than a pistol, but it's remarkably small for a carbine, and will fit in a laptop case or shoulder holster.

I also get to practice on a platform with the same manual of arms as my go-to carbine paying for 9mm vs .308, meaning far more practice time at a much cheaper cost.

It's also a hell of a lot more fun for me as a plinking gun than a .22 and about as cheap as can be had with a centerfire cartridge.

Of course, my taste in 9mm carbines runs to the extravagantly expensive. My old lady stole my Uzi, so I had to go one up and get a MP5-PDW clone made up:

mp5kpdw-right-open.jpg
 
X-Rap said ''while it doesn't replace the rifle it beats the handgun...''
that about sums it up.At one time I had a 469 S&W,and a Marlin Camp Carbine.Because I can be,at times,an idiot [like when I see a new gun I want,and have no money]I got rid of both.The chief advantage was that they shared magazines.
 
Well, if you think of it in terms of a rifle, you'll be disappointed. Think of it more as a "two-handed pistol."

The Kel-Tec probably has the biggest edge in this category. It's small enough to be carried just about anywhere, unlike other 9mm carbines which are almost as long as rifle-caliber carbines.
 
For fun?

The 9mm AR blow-back operation is some fun plinking.

I'm slightly underwhelmed with mine, I like it and all that but including a dozen mags and a Bushnell Red Dot, I spent over 1,200 on my Olympic setup.

It is fun to plink with but they eat ammo like candy! :uhoh:

You could blow through 500 rounds in an hour with great ease and still want to shoot it some more. :p

9mmARReceiver-1.jpg
 
I need a decent excuse.

Kind of in the same boat you are. I have two handguns ... one in 9mm and one in 45 Colt. I'm thinking that a rifle/carbine in one of the handgun rounds would make a nice addition to the collection and extend my "range" a bit.

Advantages:
1) limit the different types of ammo I have to buy/store/transport, make better use of bulk purchases
2) if the carbine uses Glock mags, so much the better, I already have them, including the 30+ round ones.
3) already mentioned ... extended range beyond normal pistol range. I really don't need to hit anything beyond 100 yards 'cause I don't have the visual acuity to sight targets much beyond that range anyway.

Now the dilemma is 9mm or 45 Colt. More punch with 45 Colt (possibly), but the ammo is harder to find and much more expensive. (reloads?) No semi-auto in 45 Colt. Some nice looking lever guns and short stroke pumps in 45 Colt.

9mm to be effective at range would probably have to be P+. Ammo easier to come by, and as stated I already have mags. Guns are, for the most part, butt ugly EBR's (but what the hell, so is my Glock :evil: ), but lighter than the 45 Colt entries, easier to transport. All semi-auto.

Decisions decisions ....
 
I want to buy one because they look cheap and fun to shoot, and I need a decent excuse.
You have your reason then. Seriously. They are a butt load of fun and cheap to shoot.

That said, I would feel very well armed with my 9MM AR, not as well armed as if I had my AR in 5.56, but I would be comfortable hitting fairly small targets at 100 yards and at least fending off an attack, if not stopping it instantly.

My Kel-Tec Sub-2000 in 9MM would be a close up proposition, 50 yards and on max.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top