What is your preferred first line of home defense?

What is your preferred first line of home defense?

  • Pistol

    Votes: 106 38.7%
  • Revolver

    Votes: 21 7.7%
  • PCC (Pistol Caliber Carbine)

    Votes: 3 1.1%
  • RCC (Rifle Caliber Carbine)

    Votes: 11 4.0%
  • Rifle

    Votes: 4 1.5%
  • Tactical Shotgun

    Votes: 33 12.0%
  • Field Shotgun

    Votes: 7 2.6%
  • Club (Baseball Bat, Frying Pan, etc.)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Edged weapon (Knife, Sword, Machete, etc.)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Big Dog

    Votes: 48 17.5%
  • Tell your spouse there is a prowler in the house AND they left the toilet seat up

    Votes: 6 2.2%
  • Other

    Votes: 35 12.8%

  • Total voters
    274
Status
Not open for further replies.
I live in the sticks. When my livestock guardian dog barks too long and too loud, I grab the Mossberg 500 ATP and investigate. Usually a false alarm. Sometimes a raccoon or the neighbors cows are loose. Nailed a bobcat near the turkey coop a couple years ago when my go-to was 20 GA 870 youth model.
 
Not surprising that most of the bad guys get their firearms from braking into houses. Since most break in's happen around 3pm when most folks are at work etc. the bedside firearms make a great score. Might want to think about it before walking into your own house knowing the bad guy is in the house and now armed with YOUR weapon.

For a lot of us (especially those with kids) a bedside gun is in a quick access safe.

I keep a lookout on CL and Armslist specifically for Ft. Knox and other Simplex lock pistol boxes, I'm up to 3 now. One in the bedroom, one in the living room, and one in the kitchen. All I need is another for the garage and I think I'm done.
 
Bought a Mossberg Flex Pistol grip in 20ga. At the time everything was sold out in 20. Starting shooting the pistol grip and realized it was actually very easy to use and quick, not to mention that I could shoot a whole lot of ammo through it with no problem. Later added a Tactical stock, then a hunting stock and then a Slug Barrel. Love this sweet little shooter and now use it for just about every thing, home protection and hunting. Love the ballistics of the 20ga. Very under rated.
 
Well, well ... I live not far from a fairly good-sized city but in a wooded, rural community with the houses sometimes a few hundred yards apart and everybody's got some acreage. Being as the greater Puget Sound area is pretty much the heroin and meth center of the PNW, we have the gang activity and the redneck criminals. Home invasions are not uncommon, and burglaries quite common. Oh, and we are apparently the sex offender capital of the country as well.

Move to a lower-crime area? Where exactly is that these days? Almost as insulting as telling life-long Californians that they need to move because of the gun laws.

I have a great alarm system (already responsible for the incarceration of a couple three-strikers) with a siren that'll wake the dead and a strobe that can be seen from passing airliners cruising at 35,000 feet; 360-degree outside IR and camera coverage, motion sensors and cameras indoors, every window and door alarmed plus motion sensor floodlights with over an acre of coverage.

Indoors and outside, a couple professionally trained, very territorial German Shepherd Dogs. Land-line phones in every room and a few cell phones.

Guns? We have a few ... But they are the last line of home defense. M-4 with SureFire Scout light and a laser; 590A1 with SureFire fore-end, and Mama with her SIG P-226/Streamlight TLR-1 HL are a few options. (Hey, I've got a sword, too ...)
 
Bazooka.

I voted "pistol", but boy would I love to have a bazooka for just that reason! :rofl:

I do keep a loaded AR-15 nearby with a couple of spare mags for "hit the fan" situations, but it is not first line of defense like my bedside pistol is.
 
My dogs will warn me if anyone comes near this house day or night. Don't ask me how they can hear people out front when I sleep in the back of the house but they can. If both dogs get up then I grab one of the guns I have hidden for bad company.
 
Not surprising that most of the bad guys get their firearms from braking into houses. Since most break in's happen around 3pm when most folks are at work etc. the bedside firearms make a great score. Might want to think about it before walking into your own house knowing the bad guy is in the house and now armed with YOUR weapon.

Yet another shot at me. Where do you get off, Stuart?

My guns go back in the safe EVERY morning after I wake up. I might be new here but I'm not stupid.
 
Security lights first, and cats, who seem to hear everything, including that which doesn't need investigating. Then......
My EDC, Kimber UCDP, 45 ACP, 230 gr Hydra-Shoks. But, I have both semi-auto SG, with 00 buck and RDB with XM-193, loaded in quick-opening safe for those high-stress nights, if they ever happen up here. Not like where I used to live.
 
Last edited:
Any discussion of "first line of defense" should be about fences, motion sensor lights, landscaping, good doors and locks, and alarms.

Jumping into weapons is missing the point of the first thing you should be doing to keep your home safe, which is motivating bad people to go elsewhere and keeping them from getting in or slowing them wayyyyy down in their efforts.

Define your boundaries. That doesn't require a 10ft wall with spikes. Simply establishing a border that someone has to make an effort to cross establishes a psychological barrier. You can do this with hedges or classic "picket" type fences. As uncomfortable as it might make us, motivating people to go to the neighbor down the street that just has a manicured lawn without a clear boundary helps us avoid dealing with intruders.

Remove concealment. If you want bushes and landscaping try to keep the types that people can hid behind well away from the house and force them to cross open ground where they risk being spotted. If you just have to have something "pretty" up against the house, make sure it has thorns that can't be avoided if you're putting it under windows or near entrances. Try to pick plants that are too short to hide an intruder or that are going to hurt to get between a wall and the plant.

Lights. Flood lights make it uncomfortable for people that don't want to be seen to get to the house at night. Add in motion sensor lights (remarkably cheap LED solar powered motion sensor lights are now available that just tack up to trees, posts, fences, and walls) as floods or spots to light someone moving around and put them "on notice" that they're not moving freely. A mix of hard wired floods on the house and buildings, hard wired motion sensor floods, with solar powered LEDs scattered around where people would approach the house makes it as close to impossible to approach without setting off a light or being seen.

Doors and windows. Most exterior doors are not a good barrier and windows are usually even worse. Doors should be hung with deck screws long enough to sink into the structural framing around the door. It is an easy retrofit for a home owner or renter to pull the old screws from hinges (one at a time) and strikers and replace them with 4 inch and longer deck screws. Replace your deadbolt with a long throw deadbolt so there's enough material in the striker to make those long screws work for you. Exterior doors with windows or "lights" need to be reinforced instead of easily broken glass. That can be retrofitted if you don't mind the decorative ironwork security bolt ons. If you can replace a door with steel or fiberglass and you mount it solidly into the framing it can make it very difficult for a would=be intruder to get in. Put a keyed on both sides deadbolt in place if you have any sort of window in the door so a reach in through a broken window won't allow the door to be easily opened. Add in a wired or wireless camera so you can see who is at the door before opening it (while they blink at the motion sensor light flooding them with photons) helps you know who's there. They're available with bluetooth so you can sync them with your phone to look at the vid from anywhere in the house and even communicate with your wifi to see the vid even when not at home. Windows become a more difficult problem since you want to be able to see out and let light in, but there are security films that resist breakage and there are locks even for your windows. Simply putting a nail through the frame of a double hung window can keep it from being slid open if you don't want to spend money on locks. Keep your ladders put up and out of sight so they aren't used to get to windows or balconies.

Alarms. There are endless options now in addition to the monitored alarm companies. Simple little screamers that you attach to doors and windows to wireless and wired systems sending information to your computer and phone. These allow you to put any number of exterior, perimeter, and interior sensors in place that tell you if someone is present and/or "tell" them they're detected. They can also "tell " the would-be intruder that they've been reported to the owner and authorities. People often forget that they can put sensors outside their house to tell them if someone has crossed the property boundary you established. Driveway sensors have been around for years that tell property owners that someone has pulled off the road and onto the driveway. Why not add sensors outside to tell you if someone is approaching before they get to the door/window? The same goes for interior spaces as well. Think about being able to monitor not just the doors and windows, but movement within the house using sensors communicating with phone/tablet/computer. It can also help you keep track of the kids.

Dogs. I have had pets as far back as I can remember. Some of them were protective of the house and wouldn't let anyone put a hand on the door and others would only demand affection, but we've always had one that makes noise if a stranger approached the house. "Attack" dogs can be a liability, but noise makers are organic alarm systems that have to added benefit of creating doubt in the mind of a would-be intruder about their safety (if the critter has a deep enough voice). My wife's family had a wiener dog that sounded like he was 100lbs of furry death that made strangers very nervous approaching their house, but even small "yappy" dogs are good alarms. If you want "guard" dogs you need to have the training, yes, You, not just the dog, to safely handle them. Another "dog" approach is to get a large dog house and place it so it is just visible from the street. Even if your pet weighs pounds instead of tons, the large dog house tells the bad guy driving by looking for easy targets that there just might be something monstrous at your house they don't want to deal with.

Interior. If everything has failed to keep an intruder out of the house understand that you can do things that make it difficult to get to you and your family. That also requires forethought and planning about where the most precious thing to you (family) can be separated from the threat of an intruder. Try to keep the kids rooms well away from the exterior doors and out of easy reach of windows from ground level. Try to put your bedroom between those exterior accesses and the kids. Put independent motion sensor lights between the exterior accesses and the kids and you so the intruder is triggering lights and you aren't. Understand that once inside an intruder is a real threat, but your best option is to "fort up" and hold the safest part of the house with your family in it against the intruder instead of searching in the dark for a bad guy. Make a plan and practice it with family members just like you should be making a plan and practicing it in the event of a fire. Monitor movement inside the house from your tablet/computer while you talk to 911 about the intruder. Never get off the phone with 911. They're your communication conduit to the responding authorities and you want the people responding to know you and your family are holed up in the house and that you aren't prowling the property. Put a house key on a light stick or some sort of flashing red light (plenty of cheap bike flashers) that you can toss out a window for the police to enter from their approach instead of hunting for the open door/window. As strange as this may sound, put on something distinctive that is easily recognized by the responders and give a good description to the 911 voice on the line. You don't want to be a victim of misidentification by armed responders. Something bright and easily seen at night when the flashlights are on you. Also, don't go rushing out to the responders like you're some "homesteader" shouting at Marshal Dillon to "They went thataway!". You're primary goal is keeping your and your family safe and that means making sure the LEOs know you're the home owner and not some shape in the night rushing at them they feel threatened by because YOU called them there over a threat. It goes without saying that you don't want a weapon in your hand when your encounter them, but think about a what the phone in your hand looks like to them as you wave your arms about so try using a headset and keep the phone in your pocket (it also keeps your hands free in the house while you're handling a weapon and talking to 911 while keeping your family holed up ).

Your first line of defense is keeping people off your property and out of your home.
 
Last edited:
I keep a 4" .38 revolver in a biometric safe on the nightstand.
I guess you would say my first line of defense is a small dog though.
We have an American Eskimo Spitz that barks like crazy anytime she hears a noise at the door. I figure that'll give me time to open the safe and get ready.
 
My house is protected by chihuahuas. The chihuahuas are protected by pit bulls. The pit bulls are protected by firearms (9mm pcc and .357mag.)
 
I think we have entered into a lot of common areas of agreement on what's been said here. The difference(s) of opinion comes from what labels/levels of what we all consider defense. When somebody asks about "first line of defense" I think immediately of physical attack; breaching and shooting, home invasion, and imminent risk of personal injury or death. Under those circumstances a firearm would be my first choice.
Physical locks, lights, motion detectors, cameras and landscaping, to include barriers and fences are all excellent ideas, and always need to be implemented. My only difference of opinion is where these items belong in classification. To me they are security measures through environmental design. Yes, they need to be in place, and I agree heartily with the suggestions and measures discussed here.

Based upon that discussion, how many of you are so secure in your physical preparations, that when the front door shatters, will be prepared to bring a firearm into play. You have five seconds; how prepared are you? Food for thought.
 
Not surprising that most of the bad guys get their firearms from braking into houses. Since most break in's happen around 3pm when most folks are at work etc. the bedside firearms make a great score. Might want to think about it before walking into your own house knowing the bad guy is in the house and now armed with YOUR weapon.
I would not leave any gun out when I'm not here, that's what I have a safe for.
 
@SUBJ: What is your preferred first line of home defense?
What it the first thing you rely on to keep you and your family safe? Assuming you are already keeping your doors and windows locked, etc.
Above I have quoted the title & full text of the OP ... lest some forget whilst reading the replies of others and formulating theirs. ;)
 
An American Eskimo Dog. 35 lbs of the loudest yapper you ever heard.

Does yours go from calm to psycho in a half a second, as soon as someone is at the door?

It annoys the heck out of me sometimes, but I sleep easy knowing that she will warn me if someone is trying to get in.
Ours is a female, so she's only about 12-14 pounds. Love that little yapper.
 
Unfortunately I'm in an apartment.
There are two ways in: the front door and a full-height window.
Both are in arm's reach from the entrance. The window leads into my bedroom. Aside from my work having me home at all hours, a combination of being on the second floor around neighbors and my light on is likely to discourage attempts.
If not, it's impossible to enter either without alerting me, and neither would be quiet or quick to get into. I have my choice of a bat or pistol, and plenty of warning to get either into someone's face to convince them otherwise.

Where there's space, I'm partial to a shotgun. The only one I have right now has a 28" barrel, though, so stays in the closet.
 
Unfortunately I'm allergic to dogs, and my cats don't make much noise when something is amiss.

In general I have very good hearing though and I am fairly light sleeper.

It's warm here in summer and I do not have air conditioning so I usually leave all my second floor windows wide open at night. Because I'm a light sleeper and have good hearing, I am confident I would hear someone trying to break in.

Unfortunately some genius decided to let someone use an empty warehouse to start hosting crappy cover bands for obnoxiously loud shows. Last week they were bellowing out music until 11:00 on a work night and it's only about 1/4 mile away.

I considered putting in earplugs but I'm uncomfortable not hearing what's going on in my home at night. It's also exactly the kind of racket someone could use to cover the sound of breaking and entering activities.

My point, sleeping with earplugs in is a bad idea IMO. I don't want to ruin people's fun, but I may be writing a letter to the city and seeking signatures from my neighbors.
 
My perimeter is lined with triple rows of concertina wire, backed by claymores, machine guns on the likely avenues of approach, and I've got pre-plotted grid coordinates for the indirect fire guys. I'll light it up with white phosphorous, then let the bodies hit the floor.

And if that doesn't work I'll use your idea about the intruder leaving the toilet seat up.
 
Like some other I live in the sticks with good neighbors who I all know up a trail that doesn’t even look like a road... and have have a pit/mastiff with a very intimidating bark. In 5 years I’ve only had one stranger come up my driveway.

But I’m going to assume that the spirit of the poll is more akin to “what weapon do you have staged for home defense?”
Revolvers. And loaded mags next to my ar-15’s. I carry m&ps or 1911s during the day but don’t keep track of which ones have loaded mags ready... so I use the autos for when I deliberately load up to carry but leave a couple revolvers loaded for something I know is always ready to grab... plus, I like no springs under tension for leaving loaded long term
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top