Who Makes The Best AR 15?

Who Makes The Best AR 15?

  • Colt

    Votes: 80 30.5%
  • Bushmaster

    Votes: 29 11.1%
  • Stag Arms

    Votes: 12 4.6%
  • Armalite

    Votes: 8 3.1%
  • DPMS

    Votes: 20 7.6%
  • Smith & Wesson

    Votes: 14 5.3%
  • Olympic

    Votes: 5 1.9%
  • Vulcan Arms

    Votes: 4 1.5%
  • Other

    Votes: 90 34.4%

  • Total voters
    262
Status
Not open for further replies.
For a factory M4 destined for "serious social purposes", the Colt 6920 is head and shoulders above the offerings of Bushmaster, Armalite, RRA, DPMS, et alia. Of the "boutique" brands, Noveske gets the nod, with Sabre Defense a close second. Les Baer and Wilson Combat offer no advantages for a fighting gun, though their target rifles are nice.

vanfunk
 
In a nutshell: They're all good.

It's pretty difficult to screw up building an AR 15. It's pretty much a matter of cosmetics, customer service and personal choice.
 
Most companies that sell AR15s don't make anything.They assemble guns from parts from outside vendors,the AR15 industry is a "house of leggo".They are buying alot of their parts from the same sources.

The AR15 by which all others are compared to is Colt.While Colt doesn't make as many components in house as they used to they use quality vendors like Continental Machine Tool,Creed Monarch,and others.

Lower forged receivers are primarily made by 4 manufacturers for the industry,CMT,LMT,LAR,MMS.The major difference between them is logos,markings and color,forge flashing.

If you don't want to pay prancing pony prices but want the quality build your own.

I recommend for Tier 1 parts:

BCM uppers
BCM bolts and bolt carrier groups.
BCM has CMT charging handles,same supplier to Colt.
BCM Colt M4 stocks
G&R tactical lower fire control parts set.

Forged lower of your choice,DPMS,Stag,RRA,Armalite,Bushmaster,Barrett,they are all the same.Choose the logo and markings you like and match for color.

Add BUIS of your choice from vendors like ARMS,GG&G,MWI,etc.

Stocks from MagPul,Vltor,etc with mil-spec receiver extensions.

The kits from the bigger AR15 vendors are fine for "hobby level" AR15s.

***Avoid anything Hesse,Vulcan,Blackthorne***


http://www.bravocompanyusa.com/

http://www.gandrtactical.com/
 
Who Makes The Best AR 15?
What do you think?

You can pretty much cut the list off after the first one. The rest of them aren't going to pass muster, except maybe the Smith & Wesson. I'm no colt fanboy, but they would be in my top 5. My other 4 didn't even make your list. When it comes to quality builders of AR-15's, I think you might need to broaden your horizons.

My other 4 would be:
Noveske
Bravo Company (BCM)
Daniel Defense
Lewis Machine & Tool (LMT)
 
Last edited:
Did anyone mentioned Knights Mfg Co? O yeah they not AR they SR :D
 
Most companies that sell AR15s don't make anything.They assemble guns from parts from outside vendors,the AR15 industry is a "house of leggo".They are buying alot of their parts from the same sources.
Yep, and that's especially true with lower receivers.
As an example, Continental Machine & Tool makes the lowers for the following, which is a huge segment of the AR market.

  • Stag
  • Rock River Arms
  • High Standard
  • Noveske
  • Century (New)
  • Global Tactical
  • CLE
  • S&W
  • MGI
  • Wilson Tactical
  • Grenadier Precision
  • Colt
 
Define best!

Actually with all the excellent parts available out there I am thinking you can build a best yourself, probably for less than a named brand. This way you can get exactly what you want, if no "manufacturer" makes exactly what you want.

I just completed my first, probably did not save anything, but then I used top quality parts, did not have to discard anything to "upgrade", and took my time to carefully fit the few critical items, barrel nut for gas tube clearance, gas block, aligned rail perfectly with upper receiver and gas block. Other things are just a matter of being careful, lubing parts as you assemble and being careful not to scratch or damage roll pins.
 
Colt
BCM (rep for being the best for the money)
Noveske (rep for having the best fit and finish)
LMT (though MIM gas key has tarnished their rep)

Although they make good guns, Rock River and S&W are NOT top tier ar's, period.
 
Steel is steel and aluminium is aluminium, as long as its all forged its good stuff.
 
I like POF...and am unbiased as I do not own any make of AR-15. Personally I favor a GP operated rifle over the DI system in any make. :)
 
Just build your own...
Use nice parts like (noveske, white oak, etc.)
get a nice barrel (krieger, lilja, WOA, etc.)

It'll be nice and just the way you want it from the beginning.
 
Mine is...

Mega Machine Gator Lower w/ CMT parts inside (waiting on a Timney 4#) and WOA 6.8SPC Midlength SS barrel, Troy MRF Rifle Length Hand guards attached to a Mega Machine Upper.

Very mil-spec parts, cheaper than Colt, and same quality. It's a 6.8SPC :)
 
A year old poll resurrected... hmmm. Nothing on the poll list would be my pick for best, and I'm quite amused at the Vulcan entry (would be on most lists of worst, though that's only hearsay for me).

Lots of companies make good ARs these days. From what I hear, only, I would guess that Colt, Noveske, Knight's, or Bravo Company would be the best. I don't own any of those or have current plans to.

The other "best" is one you assemble yourself from top quality parts...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top