Who makes the best hunting pistol ?

Status
Not open for further replies.

theboyscout

Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2012
Messages
397
Location
FL
I've been looking at auto loaders for hunting with pistol, I have found 10mm to be very popular . Dan wesson in particular. But i have also seen some revolvers out there. what else is out there that's reliable and holds multiple rounds? Used for defense or big game dangers, as well, hunting big game within 70ish yds max shot.

Name you caliber and firearm of choice.
 
Last edited:
70 yards with a handgun is a tall order for most anyone. I'm not a revolver guy or a handgun hunter myself. To me handguns are more of a defensive tool, whether we are concerned with 2 legged or 4 legged threats. I carry a Glock 23 (40) in hog country, and a Glock 21 (45) if there is a chance black bears are about. Ideally, I'd have a Glock 20 (10 mm) but can't justify such a purchase as its not something I would use or carry for any other purpose.
 
How big a game animal do you expect to hunt?

As near as I can tell, the majority of deer hunters' cartridges are in the power range of .357 Mag to .44 Mag. For elk, probably .44 Mag or more.

Big game danger? .44 Mag would deal with black bears. For Grizzly or the big brownies, all bets are off. :) You can find multitudes of squabbles on that.

Brand name? Too many to count.
 
I have killed over 20 deer with pistols. They all killed quite well regardless of caliber from .250 Savage in an XP-100 to .44 magnum in a S&W model 29. I have also killed a hog and a deer with a black powder revolver, a Ruger Old Army.
I have killed several hogs from stands with one also but never any bigger game. No moose, elk, bear, etc.

Most any center-fire round will kill a deer if the shot is in the vitals.
 
I don't worry about big game danger around here. I hunt with a single shot TC pistol in .30-30. I've taken deer to 90 yards and can put 5 rounds into 3" at 200 yards with it. It shoots 3" high at 100 when sighted in at 200, very flat shooting pistol.

I really don't like autoloaders, especially striker guns, and carry a revolver for concealed carry most of the time. If I were forced to use an autoloader for your purposes, I'd probably get a Glock 20 in 10mm. They're quite accurate for a semi-auto. I'd carry it condition three and rack the slide before the shot. That might make a bit of unwanted noise, but I'm not real happy with the thought of Glock Leg.

The EEA Witness in 10mm has interested me, a CZ clone and double action hammer gun. I cannot attest to its accuracy, though. I've played with the Glock 20 and know it would be accurate enough, I just don't like the striker fired manual of operation. I'm a bit of a safety fanatic. I'm not sure one can be TOO safe and a firearm that has no safety and sits ready for anything that grabs the trigger to go off, well, I don't even carry a 1911 cocked and unlocked and it has a grip safety.

Perhaps if you were box blind hunting, you could jack a round into the Glock when you got there and set it away from you muzzle outward. Or, perhaps you could carry it in a safe, trigger covering bandoleer holster, that might work.
 
If I were seeking a handgun for whitetail deer from 0-70yrds:

Ruger Super Blackhawk Hunter or Super Redhawk in 44mag, or standard SBH with smithing fees to drill & tap it for a scope mount. Add either an Ultradot MatchDot, or a Leupold VX3 2-8x32mm. Find one of the remaining Bog Gear PSR's on the market and a Primos Trigger Stick tripod, or Bog Pod. Feed it 240 or 300grn XTP's, and be merry.

I've been hunting with handguns for over 25yrs, and have taken the vast majority of my game with them. Most whitetail seasons in KS, I don't even field a rifle. I've been hunting a 44mag SBH since 1998.

Specialty pistols are out there, and the TC Contender G2 is a great option to get into lower powered rifle cartridges with flatter trajectories, but despite owning Encore and Contender pistols, I prefer revolvers OR bolt action pistols for hunting. The Savage Striker is a bit more bulky than the Remington XP100, but at least Savage realized a right handed pistol needs a left hand bolt, AND theirs is a repeater. The Rem XP100R, rear grip, is a repeater, but it's more difficult to manage the rear grip pistols in the field than the mid grips (shooting off hand with a rear grip is DIFFICULT!).

10mm is capable, but for me, hunting is best done with larger capacity cases. The 357mag will peter out in your 70yrd window, so I recommend HIGHLY against it. Stepping up to the 44mag affords you easier-to-find ammunition than the 41mag, but with far more effective range than the 357mag. I'm not sure I'd trust myself with any 10mm pistol to 70yrds, even though I regularly shoot 50yrds with semiauto pistols, even my LCP.

I'd probably get a Glock 20 in 10mm. They're quite accurate for a semi-auto. I'd carry it condition three and rack the slide before the shot. That might make a bit of unwanted noise, but I'm not real happy with the thought of Glock Leg.

[...] I'm a bit of a safety fanatic. I'm not sure one can be TOO safe and a firearm that has no safety and sits ready for anything that grabs the trigger to go off, well, I don't even carry a 1911 cocked and unlocked and it has a grip safety.

A Glock has the same number of safeties as a cocked and LOCKED Series 80 1911. I don't assume to be able to turn your opinion, but rather would offer an opposing viewpoint for the readers of this thread. I carry a G19 on my hip in the field anywhere I'm not needing bear defense, and tucked into my waistband on most days as my CC piece.
 
Yes, safeties that can turn themselves off by an errant stick or article of clothing aren't safeties IMHO. All in all, revolvers are the safest platform and I much prefer them except where hunting. Oh, they're great for hunting, I just prefer the Contender. It's awesome accurate and I need no more'n one shot with it. I own DA and SA revolvers and I've taken a few hogs out to 60 yards with my .357 Blackhawk. I don't have it scoped, but it's very accurate. I can keep 180 XTPs over 13.8 grains AA#9 inside the center of a paper plate with it off a rest at 100 yards. I agree on the power, though. That load starts off at 785 ft lbs out of my 6.5" barrel which is marginal enough. Pushing it much past 50 yards isn't wise. I don't own a .44 mag revolver, do have a Blackhawk 4 5/8" .45 Colt, though, which runs 1100 ft lbs at the muzzle with a very accurate Hornady 300 grain XTP and L'il Gun. I worked that load up, but I've never shot anything with it. Mostly just plink with a 255 grain cast bullet with that revolver. I love that thing, though, very accurate with about any load.

I really think a .41 mag would be way cool to load for and hunt with. For the non-handloader, though, the .44 mag is just hard to argue against. 10mm is close to .357 magnum in performance. .44 mag walks all over it.
 
Hands-down: TC Arms’ Contender, G2 or Encore.

I have hunted large game with a 1911, a G21, a Contender and an Encore.

As to caliber, take your pick.

Geno
 
I'm pretty sure that Remington quit making them but the XP-100 is the most accurate hunting pistol. It was made in several calibers. I had my 7mmBR rechambered to 7-08 and my .35 Remington rechambered to Win. .358. However, my go to gun for hunting is my custom XP-100 in .250 Savage. I've taken 22 deer with it.
 
Actually, the TC Arms is still the world record holder for accuracy.

A Contender was used (with iron sights) to fire a 10-shot group at 500 yards. The group measured 0.75” horizontal by 3.5” vértical. That record has stood for over 30 years. I believe the details are still available at TC’s homepage.

Geno
 
I'm pretty sure that Remington quit making them but the XP-100 is the most accurate hunting pistol.

Remington quit making them almost 20yrs ago. Hard to believe it's been that long.

Guys can still buy XP100 actions through PT&G, or other sources, but Remington hasn't made the XP's in a LONG time. Savage also quit making the Striker, but at least as of 4yrs ago they would custom build you one.

I have a G2 Contender and an Encore, and have had other TC's, but I really enjoy the bolt action specialty pistols the most. The XP100's are a lot more svelte than the Strikers, and of course, the rear grip XP100R's and custom 700's are a pretty different animal than either of the mid-grips.

Which, of course, a guy on our side of the fence has to recognize the specialty pistols are very different animals than the 6" belt gun most guys consider as a "hunting handgun." They all work, I've taken deer with a G19 in the past, and have killed a coyote with a PPK/S, but a 44mag wheelgun is a lot better suited to the task. Wanna take game at 250yrds? A supported specialty pistol makes it a very simple proposition. Wanna kill deer in Minnesota shotgun/handgun only zones? A 6.8spc AR pistol isn't a bad option... Horses for courses, as it were...
 
There is no "best" but there are a lot of options that work.

If I was going to hunt with a semi-auto with an empty chamber, I just would not bother.
 
What type of animal are you hunting? Whitetail-black bear 44mag, 454 cassule in a Ruger super Red hawk, scoped would be my #1 pic. I tried a super Red hawk with the cowboy grips, iron sights and like 8" barrel and was hitting a pie plate and 2ltr at 50yards. That's if your limited to strait walled cartridges. If your allowed bottle neck in a pistol i would go with TC contender. If the only big game your worried about attacking you is a black bear, coyote, etc a 6 shot revolver in 44-454 should be fine IMO. If in grizzly country id find something a little larger. TBH If im messing around in grizzly country id get something larger and also a revolver. Too many people don't have the training to clear a jammed semi auto and when you put a charging animal in the mix you might limp wrist it and it can lock up and your screwed. Revolver is more practical in that sense and hit a brown bear with any of those big pistol rounds and hes going to think twice about finishing his charge.
 
There is no best anything.
Like FL-NC says, 70 yards is a very long way with a handgun of any kind. Factory 10mm ammo has less than 500 ft-lbs of remaining energy with a 180 grain bullet too.
Dan Wesson pistols are 1911A1 clones. Specifically, Colt's Delta Elite. Wouldn't use one on anything but varmints myself. However, as mentioned, everything depends on what you're hunting and where. After that it's about using the hand gun you shoot best chambered in an adequate cartridge for the game.
 
The "best" is the one you'll actually shoot a lot and carry comfortably.

I started with a Blackhawk in .41mag, then tried a Super Redhawk in .44 mag with a scope.
Scope didn't work well with my long arms and that gun was heavy even in the bandolier holster.

Now I have a Blackhawk.45 convertible and that's the best for me,relatively cheap to pratice with carries easy and powerful.
 
A specific "watch-out" I'd offer to the OP, in this type of thread, the overwhelming majority of folks who offer advice have never actually done any handgun hunting. Handgun hunting isn't common, so relevant experience in handgun hunting isn't common. Lots of guys have opinions, but most guys posting in this type of thread are usually like NASCAR fans trying to offer throttle advance advice to Jimmy Johnson...

I was on the phone this morning with a buddy who rebuilt his G20 10mm with a 6" barrel, specifically for hunting pronghorn in WY. He runs a stalking decoy mounted to a bog gear bipod, crouching behind the decoy, firing from kneeling. I know he's using a frame mounted optic, and I know he had a Matchdot on top in the past, but we talked last year about putting an FX-II 4x on top, not sure if he did for this season or not. Getting it done with a pistol is more difficult than a revolver, but largely because you're talking about big, fat bullets with poor sectional density, and relatively small case capacities and low muzzle velocities. The 10mm kills about the same as the 357magnum - tapping out about 75yrds. But at 75 and under, it's serviceable.

Think about real world application for what you're asking - Autoloader preferred... Maybe 10mm... Maybe Dan Wesson... Maybe a revolver... big game hunting...70yrds... remaining applicable for bear defense...

I've been looking at auto loaders for hunting with pistol, I have found 10mm to be very popular . Dan wesson in particular. But i have also seen some revolvers out there. what else is out there that's reliable and holds multiple rounds? Used for defense or big game dangers, as well, hunting big game within 70ish yds max shot.

Name you caliber and firearm of choice.

If you're talking 70yrds, irons can work, but optics are uplifting. You'll benefit from either a red dot or a scope, and from either planning improvised field supports, or carrying one. A scope will be problematic for defensive application - but a guy can remove the scope when in bear country, or a guy can use a red dot, which will be more of a challenge at 70yrds, but faster for defensive use. So that's what you're facing - either some optic, or planning a lot of practice to be very proficient with the irons. A guy can remove a scope and replace the iron sights, or swap to a red dot easily enough. Lots and lots of options for mounting red dots or scopes on pistols or revolvers, so that's pretty easy.

Defensive application also precludes the use of a specialty pistol like an XP100, Striker, Contender, or Encore, or really any of the 8 3/8", 9.5", 7.5" revolvers... A lot of things can work, but the 5-6" revolvers & pistols do lend themselves to defensive use better than the longer pistols.

For 70yrds and under on whitetail sized game, the 357mag and the 10mm are really the basement level for power, but they'll get it done. I've taken whitetails with a G19 and with a 40 S&W Highpoint carbine - both as "prove the point" experiences, not "year in, year out" firearms - those both work if a guy is judicious with shot selection for range, angle, and placement.

So a G20 with a red dot would be a very serviceable option, especially given a field support resource in one flavor or another.

Whatever you buy, pick up a target style 22LR pistol like the Ruger Mark IV/S&W Victory/Browning Buckmark, mount your optic on it (or a duplicate) and shoot it at your max range as much as possible. Doing so is the easiest and cheapest way to cheat your way into a solid shooting skill at longer range shooting with pistols, and there's a distinct reality, if you can't hit it with that 22LR reliably, you're not going to do any better in the field with the "A game" pistol.
 
Maybe not the best but if i had the fund a les baer 10mm in auto or a 454 freedom arms for a revolver.
 
The mindset for hand gun hunting is different than rifle hunting, unless you are using the contender with rifle calibers. This is usually not mentioned, but should be considered by you, OP.

My mindset for hand gun hunting is that I will punch two drain holes in the animal, one in and one out. That's it. No energy dump. No mushrooming. Break shoulders if needed, but preferably not. I shoot a 335 grain .45 colt hard cast slug at 1275 fps.

With my mindset, I think it's hard to beat S&W N or X frames, Ruger Blackhawks and RedHawks, and Freedom Arms.
 
Freedom Arms in .454 with a spare .45acp cylinder is a great option.
Glock 40 (10mm long slide) is nice as it holds more than enough ammo for a herd of deer and comes ready for a red dot. May need to order hot 10mm ammo though.
Many .44 or .357 mag options out there if you like that path.
Contenders are also great but single shot.

In the end, lots of personal choice and depends on your game/hunting location. (METT-T for the Army guys :), left the C off here)
 
I guess I wouldn't count because I'd use a single shot and make that shot count. So for deer I'd go with a .50 caliber Bounty https://www.davide-pedersoli.com/sc...16/pistols-bounty-bounty-flintlock-model.html in flint, or for ease of calibers I might like a Kentucky in flint in .54 https://www.davide-pedersoli.com/sc...kentucky-pistol-kentucky-flintlock-model.html , of course for folks worried about the weather conditions or need more than one shot, one could go with a Howdah SxS caplock in .58 https://www.davide-pedersoli.com/sc...r_35/pistols-howdah-hunter-howdah-hunter.html. :thumbup:

LD
 
Lots of options. Problem with asking "what's best?" on a gun forum is, the answers you get are generally what the respondents own/use. You have your fanboys and your haters that want your opinion to be the same as theirs. In truth, any handgun gun that consistently puts the projectiles in a "minute of kill zone" at the range you feel comfortable at, will and does work. Pistol or revolver? Really doesn't matter, depends on which format you enjoy the most. Harder to find true hunting ammo for pistols than it is for revolvers, same goes for oddball and niche calibers. Actually ammo type is more important in handgun hunting than the platform. Another thing to consider is what range will you be hunting. Mostly what larger calibers and the super big bores give you for deer is more range. Adjustable sights, while not required, makes for better accuracy, especially at longer ranges. If you don't reload you'll want to stick with a popular caliber because hunting type ammo will be easier to find and less expensive. Unlike a long gun, it takes lots of shooting to become proficient enough to ethically hunt with a handgun and shooting regularly to keep proficient. Not like your deer rifle that you shoot a few times before season to make sure it's still sighted in. Shooting lots of ammo can be expensive for many folks and should not be the determining factor as to how proficient you become. I've hunted with and killed deer with .357s, 44s and the .460. All work well within their parameters and when used with the correct ammo. Biggest difference between them is effective range. Easier to get proficient with the limited 35-40 yard range of the .357 as compared to the 150+ yard range of the .460. For deer, within 70-80 yards, one would be well suited with any .44 mag or it's equivalent.
 
I've handgun hunted for 30 years now. 90 percent of it with the 44mag. My revolvers are S&W model 29 and Ruger Super Blackhawk and are open sighted. My contender is a scoped 7-30 waters. All have taken white tail deer cleanly with one shot. I don't shoot past 100 yards with any of them and that' from a solid rest. I takes a lot of practice to become proficient enough with a handgun to cleanly take game animals. Do yourself a favor, use a rifle this season so you've got at least a years practice under your belt. My humble opinion of course.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top