Your Most Valuable Gun

Status
Not open for further replies.
On his deathbed, my paternal grandfather told one of my uncles he wanted me to have his old .22 rifle.

I was 17, and I thought that was real cool of old grandad, even though I had never known him well. We lived in different states, and my own father, grandpa's youngest child, died when I was young. But I knew grandpa well enough to skip my senior prom and ride a Greyhound bus for 9 hours to be a pall bearer at the funeral.

One day years later I got curious, and looked up the gun. I knew it was kinda old, but I got a bit of an education. Turns out grandpa's "old .22 rifle" was a Winchester Model 61 pump take down made in 1948, valued anywhere from $900-$1,200.
upload_2021-5-24_6-17-6.jpeg
I was never going to sell it anyway (my uncle explicitly asked me not to, a request that wasn't even necessary) but it was cool to know it wasn't just pot metal grandpa gave me. That Winchester doesn't get shot too much, even though it works just fine...like a Swiss watch, actually. But every now and then I pull it out and just look at it, to remind me of what guns were like back when they were meant to be inherited. Even without the history that infuses it, that gun remains a thing of industrial beauty. It has an elegance of artfully blended form and function firearms rarely possess anymore.

R.I.P. Grandpa, 1908-1994.
 
Last edited:
I think I understand the concept of valuable in this thread. My most $ cost is a low end Shadow II I paid $1,100 for. My most sentimental gun would be my dad's Browning 12 gauge shotgun custom made for him by a gun smith in 1954. And the pistols I depend to save my life as an EDC is either a Sig P238 or Walther PPS.
 
My Dad’s Winchester 94 30-30 with a Redfield 1X scope. The serial number puts it the blank period during WWll when they didn’t keep track of them. He hunted deer in Wisconsin with it for more than 50 years.
 
I have a Winchester pre-`64 Model 70 built by Mel Smart. It features one of his early Accu-Bond laminated stocks and is chambered in .35 Whelen.

I don't know what it would sell for, but to replace it, I would have to go to the company that Mel founded and order one of their rifles. He's since passed. The closest rifle to mine is the Kilimanjaro and they start at $17,000.

UCRyiJr9R6W6EGXY2tBM0A.jpeg

IMG_20191222_182459612.jpg

IMG_20191222_182531648.jpg
 
I think the gun I paid the most for is a Springfield Armory M1A. The only reason I bought it was to have (as close as legally possible) the full set of US 20th century main battle rifles. My Krag is a real junker that came in a butchered sporterized stock. It’s the only rifle I own that I’ve never fired. I don’t even have ammo for it.

Most sentimental value would either be my dad’s Winchester 67a .22 or model 37 red letter 12 gauge with the stock ears broken on both sides.
 
My most sentimental gun is my late Father's 1895 Nagant. It's just fun. And I have found memories if him squirrel hunting with it.
Dollar wise would probably be my Krag.
Like one of the others said. I'd have to be looking to sell to know the value.
 
I’m not sure what my most valuable gun is. I’ve always liked guns and have been buying them for some time now. At one point I had just over 400, but now I’m down to a more manageable 375.
I’ve collected a good many surplus guns over the years. I have never tried to buy the ones in perfect shape. To me, they have very little history. I see them as the third string quarterback that never got to play. What I like are the Warhorses, the ones that were used and made history.
In handguns it would be one of these three.
1940 Tula Russian TT33. No import mark, most likely a bring back from Vietnam.
B0631BF6-7D23-4E46-88D5-B8E99DCD7E22.jpeg F345B682-A8C4-42ED-BE85-B41209C93A22.jpeg

My two Colt 1911s. Both built in 1918. One in May and the other in December.
2201B791-5D3F-4334-9C86-BBC34C16BE62.jpeg

Now for the store. The TT33 was sitting on the shelf in a pawn shop with a price tag of $219.95. At the time they were selling from $600 to $800. I got it for $182.00. The last one that I saw sold went for over $2000.
https://www.thehighroad.org/index.php?threads/russian-war-pony.634905/#post-7847643

The top Colt 1911 was at a pawn shop. It was covered in black spray paint and had a set of Googyears on it. I think I paid like $580 for it.
The second Colt 1911 I bought from a friend for $1300.
I have many more, and many have post here on the forum with the story that goes with them.
 
My 1892 Winchester in 44-40 made in 1895.
Thats pretty cool..

I just saw one of these posted recently at my local shop, It's in beautiful shape. I wondered if it was from 1800's and that may be why it commanded a $3K price tag. If it was made in the 1890's, I would think it would be more valuable than $3K, although idk values for these guns. IMG_20210529_214221.jpg
 
To me the value in a firearm is two fold: It's got to work properly and reliably. The other reason is sentimental. I have my dad's first and only shotgun that he bought in the 30's, a Ranger 20 ga double bbl and a Remington bolt action target rifle, tube feed in .22lr that he bought about the same time. I also have my FIL's Winchester lever action in .32 caliber that he bought in the 50's.
 
My most valuable firearm (by filthy lucre standards) is likely a Colt Government Model (.45 ACP). It has been worked to be a wadcutter target pistol.
The underside of the aft portion of slide is marked "J. M Clarke, Shreveport, Louisiana".

My most personally connected valuable firearm is hard to identify. Sort of like picking one's favorite child or grandchild. There are several.
 
Most expensive is a Browning Citori-----thing is, I have a bunch of others priced nearly the same.

Most sentimental would be a Savage single shot .22 my grandfather bought for me new in 1968 and my Sheridan Blue Streak given to me on my birthday in 1971---both are rarely shot but they aren't going anywhere either. Had both for over 50 years.
 
my most expensive is an 1885 winchester...
most sentimental... a sporterized 1917 Enfield with a 5 digit serial. my grandfather gave it to me, my youngest used it to kill his first deer. it will stay in the family.
 
I haven’t looked up what my guns are worth lately, but if I had to guess, it would be my HK P7 PSP.

As far as sentimental value, the JC Higgins model 30 I got from my Dad.
 
I have a few, but the 2 I am most proud of are the little Colt .25, engraved and gold inlaid with a set of matched, polished and Stabilized Giraffe Bone Grips...

20210222-181316.jpg

Colt-Junior-Engraved-4.jpg

Colt-Junior-Engraved-3.jpg

And my Browning Gold Line Medalist. Engraved and gold inlaid with the carved grips...

20210602-104138.jpg

I actually shoot a '63 standard model Medalist for indoor competition and taken many trophies, awards and ribbons with it over many years. I figure I have over 100,000 rounds thru it and it still shoots 'X''s all day long!
 
Last edited:
Monetarily? Fully transferable, registered Mac-10, with a pile of magazines to feed it.

Sentimentally? None really come to mind.
 
Sentimental value, mine would likely be my dads HR 22 revolver. Which may very well be my least valuable resale. Second and third would be his old Higgins branded flight king and my grandpas m1 carbine. Only the M1 is worth much money and then probably not a grand.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top