The issues: Safety, speed and "feel"
Naterater said:
I have an "in the press" primer now on my single stage press, but I'm thinking about getting a hand primer.
Could anyone give me some advantages/disadvantages of Hand Held Priming and Press Priming. I'm looking only for the Pros and Cons of each type--I'll probably decide on a model later if I decide to get one.
I prime on press. I use a Turret press and the speed advantage is significant.
On a single stage press the speed advantage of priming on the press is not too much. That is because of the nature of the batch process and the fact that you are removing the cartridge case. On a turret used in continuous mode (or progressive) not having to extract and reinsert the case makes for a substantial time savings. In batch mode, not so much.
Some people testify that the various hand priming tools (I know of the RCBS Bench primer, RCBS hand primer and the Lee Hand Primer) give a better "feel" when seating primers. With my RockChucker, I could feel with equal or greater sensitivity than the other tools. True, I had super-tremendous leverage, much more than I needed, but I could feel the primer seat just fine. Since I didn't have to squeeze really hard with my hand, but just push gently with my fingertips, I can feel the primers seat better on my press than with the hand primer tools.
Lee's priming systems (the hand primer and on-press, both) do not use tube systems. Lee states unequivocally that Lee will never use a tubular system. The chance of a chain detonation is a caution to them. Rarely happens, but when it does, I can imagine it is really scary and have no desire to experience it. I loaded for years with my RCBS in a primer tube and am not scared, but, "Why take chances?" My on-press system does not use a tube, but many others do. That is why many people choose to prime off-press; safety. Not me. The safety factor is a welcome bonus.
The speed advantage, the "feel" advantage and the safety advantage all point (for me) towards priming on-press, with the Lee "pez dispenser" system.
If you feel differently, good for you. Everybody has their own style and preferences and I will not fault yours if you don't fault mine. Heck, even if you do fault mine. I am happy, no matter what. I've got no downside or compromise to my choice.
Lost Sheep