I am considering a set of Lee Dies for a .44 Mag, I am not using a Progressive Press. What thoughts and opinions are out there on 3 die or 4 die set? The difference in price seems to be around $15. Cartridges will be reloaded for use in a Marlin 1894. I would appreciate your input.
Lee 3 Die or 4 Die set?
- Thread starter TC8500
- Start date
- Status
I have always separated crimping from seating.
However, you will be combining both operations, then the 3-die set is all you need.
If you are going to separate the two actions, I would get the 3-die set and a Redding Profile Crimp die for the roll crimp.
However, you will be combining both operations, then the 3-die set is all you need.
If you are going to separate the two actions, I would get the 3-die set and a Redding Profile Crimp die for the roll crimp.
I have the three die Lee set for 44 mag, which means I seat and crimp with one stroke and one die. Since I have not used a dedicated Factory Crimp Die, you will have to take my opinion with a grain of salt. I load for a SBH and a 1894.
I am completely content to not use the FCD. Using the seater die to lay on the crimp does mean that case length is very important. Cases that are longer or shorter will result in more or less crimp as the die will lay a heavier crimp to longer cases and a lighter crimp to shorter cases.
It takes some practice because there are two adjustments; one adjustment for bullet depth and another for the amount of crimp. Depth is set by the screw-on seater stem and the amount of crimp is determined by adjusting the height of the die in the press.
I am completely content to not use the FCD. Using the seater die to lay on the crimp does mean that case length is very important. Cases that are longer or shorter will result in more or less crimp as the die will lay a heavier crimp to longer cases and a lighter crimp to shorter cases.
It takes some practice because there are two adjustments; one adjustment for bullet depth and another for the amount of crimp. Depth is set by the screw-on seater stem and the amount of crimp is determined by adjusting the height of the die in the press.
Seedtick
Member
I use/would use the 3 die set for loading on a single stage press.
I use/would use the 3 die set for loading on a 3 station turret press.
I use/would use the 4 die set for loading on a 4 station turret press.
There now, did I make that confusing enough? :banghead:
And as they say YMMV.
Seedtick
I use/would use the 3 die set for loading on a 3 station turret press.
I use/would use the 4 die set for loading on a 4 station turret press.
There now, did I make that confusing enough? :banghead:
And as they say YMMV.
Seedtick
ArchAngelCD
Member.
I use a 4 hole turret press so I have room for the 4th die. I also like to crimp in a separate stage so I use the Lee FCD that's in the 4 die set.
Mike 27
Member
The 4th die is a second sizeing die. You run your loaded round through it and it resizes one last time. It is not needed however, I use it on my 45acp, and it feeds great. I only use 3 die sets for wheel guns, they have no issues and do not benefit from the 4th die. I really don't think the 45 needs it either but it makes a really nice looking round. I use the 3 die set on my 9mm's and have no issue either. I picked mine up on sale, and I do like them but as I said for a revolver I would not use the 4th.
Yep. RCBS seaters also roll crimp really well. (Sans the stem naturally)
The Lee FCD is not a sizing die. A sizing die would ruin the round. Just try it.
The FCD for pistols uses a carbide ring to slightly squeeze down any rounds that are over spec. (This is the theory anyway)
I am not a fan of them, but there is a good use for them. The IDPA guys like to use them to make sure they do not have any over sized rounds that would cause a failure in a match. It saves them the time of gauging all the rounds.
Reliability is more important to them than that last tiny bit of accuracy.
- Status
