opinions on home defense loads for a .357 mag revolver

[ArchAngelCD]

How can you start a caliber war when you are asking about only 1 caliber?? LOL

I would and do use the "FBI Load" in my HD revolver. I prefer the Remington 158gr LSWC/HP .38 Special +P ammo (Part #R38S12) in a 2" barrel but for a 4" barrel the Winchester and Federal offerings will work just as well as the Remington ammo.

 

[kmrcstintn]

thanks all very much for the feedback and information; here's what I decided...

1) my 6" GP100 is going to find a new home with one of the fellas from my hunting group (I have dad's 'handed down' S&W 686 PowerPort w/ 6" ported barrel) in a few weeks/months

2) my 4" GP100 balances nicely when shooting with one hand...even my weak hand; still need some trigger time to determine POA/POI with my weak hand

3) I've decided to go with the FBI load in .38 spl +p for better control and less 'stunning' of my senses inside the domicile

I will make the switch in @ 1 to 2 weeks when I rotate ammo out (currently using Winchester WWB Personal Protection 125gr sjhp .38 spl +p)

 

[Cactus Jack Arizona]

What about the 110 gr. Hornady Critical Defense with the XTP HP in .38 Spcl?

 

[ArchAngelCD]

kmrcstintn,
Since you decided to go with the FBI load take a look around the WEB. You can still find a box of 50 for under $24 sometimes which is just about what a box of 20 will cost you of the "new and better" ammo that's out there.

 

[wnycollector]

FBI load take a look around the WEB. You can still find a box of 50 for under $24 sometimes

If you find the Remi flavor of the FBI load for less than $24...stock up! I pay ~$28/50 and I'm down to my last 1/2 box. My new supply is on backorder until mid september.

I prefer the Remington 158gr LSWC/HP .38 Special +P ammo (Part #R38S12) in a 2" barrel but for a 4" barrel the Winchester and Federal offerings will work just as well as the Remington ammo.

Excellent advice!!! I would add that Georgia Arms ($28.50/100 rounds!!!) makes their own version of the FBI load also. Stephen Camp tested it a while back and it should be relegated to 4+" barrel revolvers!