Blue Brick
Member
The .45 Colt was designed by the U.S. army in 1871 to kill or stop charging horses during battle.
+ 1
The .45 Colt was designed by the U.S. army in 1871 to kill or stop charging horses during battle.
With comparable loads, it's a wash. Either one will do the job.
Comparing standard pressure .44Mag to Ruger only .45Colt the rule of thumb is: For a given bullet weight, the .44Mag will usually yield 100fps higher velocity. For a given sectional density, the .44 will deliver 200fps higher velocity. The .45 is slightly larger in diameter [/B]but the important dimension, when speaking of cast bullets, is the diameter of the meplat.[/B]
They also need a new faster twist barrel. The factory 1-38" is too slow for anything heavier than 300gr.A .44 Mag 330 gr Garret Hammerhead WILL NOT feed in a Marlin lever action with out major modification to the rifle.
The .44Mag is often misjudged by the old tech 240gr loads. It becomes a completely different critter when fed with quality cast bullets beginning with the 250gr Keith and ending with the 355gr Beartooth. Although the 330's are probably the best heavyweight.I watched the very same carbine make the very same shot on a similar boar with a 240 gr Remington factory soft point. We killed that hog about a year later and dug the remains of the soft point out of his shoulder where the bullet over expanded stopped in the cartilage and failed to penetrate.
They also need a new faster twist barrel. The factory 1-38" is too slow for anything heavier than 300gr.
It is expensive! It's a shame that Marlin won't do with the 1894 what they did with the .444, that is, install a 1-20" twist barrel.
They changed it to a 1-20" that will stabilize everything up to the 405gr Beartooth.
.
I watched the very same carbine make the very same shot on a similar boar with a 240 gr Remington factory soft point. We killed that hog about a year later and dug the remains of the soft point out of his shoulder where the bullet over expanded stopped in the cartilage and failed to penetrate.
As has been mentioned above and especially with hogs bullet choice matters.
.
Yep, hogs are a different animal...
I'd have zero qualms about using a 92 with 250-grain hard-cast bullets.
No idea, though, about pressure limitations on the Colt.