I have the 5star speedloaders and loading tray, for my 327 M&PR8.
They were the only 8 shot speedloaders I could find so it made the choice easy.
I am extremely happy with the quality and function.
not too excited about the price but I couldnt find anything else.
as said the quality and function is very good.
THey hold the rounds with very little wiggle.
I atually prefer these speedloaders to the moonclips I have and am faster with these. Not much difference though. Mainly because the moonclip and brass combination I have seem to be pretty wobbly and with the 8 shot, loaded with SWC, or worse BNWC, it can get tricky if you are rushing.
Although I can carry more clips on my belt and gear and they do keep the empties in one place. I dont really have any way of carrying the speedloaders except in a pocket. THey do make a leather pouch though I think.
Very simple twist action to them. The aluminum body of them is solid and the release mechanism is very simple so I am expecting these to last a long time.
Could they handle repeated dropping on a hard conrete floor?
When they are empty they are quite light and well built, so I would say yes there is close to zero chance that a drop would break them.
They might get scratched but I cant see them breaking.
I have one in my hand right now.
Honestly I think I could stamp on it and not hurt it.
Id imaging the 6 shot ones are even more solid.
SAve up and get them, Im glad I did.
moX