tackleberry45
Member
I want quality - not a safe queen. Looking to the SR556E Ruger.... Anything else I should consider? S&W M&P15?
Last edited:
yeah, search is the friend but that went back about 5 years.
+1 this, you might want to check to see if you really want a piston gun.....I have 6 and all of them are DI for a reason.Most of them are, IMHO, overpriced and underperform. If you want an AR15, I would get a quality DI gun (Colt, LMT, BCM, DD, Noveske); if you want a piston, I would get a SCAR-L.
But, if it has to be an AR15 with a forward piston, I would look most closely at the LMT, PWS, and Adams Arms options, all of which seem to be actually engineered and run well. (The Colt should be good too based on brand reputation, but I know nothing about it.) I have a factory Adams Arms midlength piston upper and it works well and seems to be a quality item. I got it more as a range toy, but I would put it up against standard AR15s from non-military-contractors. If you wanted to go that route, you could get the AA midlength upper for about $600, put it on your choice of AR lower ($300-600+ depending what you want), and have a nice setup for less than most other options.
The Ruger SR556E looks good in some ways but is handicapped by the nothing special, non-chrome-lined barrel (one of several cost saving measures).
A friend has two POFs, one each 5.56 and .308 flavors. They are heavy, unbalanced, and have been less reliable than any of my DI AR15s, and of course they cost more than twice as much. I can't see any reason to go that route.