ExAgoradzo
Member
This may or may not be the best place for this question, but here it goes:
This is what is listed on the box:
.30-06 Fed Prem Ammo 165 gr (Barnes Triple-Shock)
Muzzle 100 yards 200 yards
2870 ftlbs 2405 2000
.30-06 Fed Power shock 220 gr (Speer Hot Cor SP)
Muzzle 100 yards 200 yards
2815 2195 1690
Now, my understanding is that someone would buy the first because they wanted something to take down the little black tail deer we have out here or some hogs while someone would buy the second because they wanted to take down some elk or moose. But if you just go by 'energy' the smaller bullet has the larger beat. (I noticed BTW that this is also true when comparing the Corbon 460 gr 45-70 bullets against the smaller 325gr Hornady GMX.) Now, I understand that the faster the bullet goes the more energy it will have, but then why go with the bigger bullet that won't fly as fast (given the same cartridge)?
Why use the bigger bullet?
Why is the 220 gr bullet better to take down a elk than the 165gr? (Also, there must be more to the fact that 'bullet placement' is always key...but assuming a correctly placed bullet, why wouldn't I take the one with the higher energy (but smaller weight) to knock down whatever I'm hunting?)
Perhaps the answer will have to do with penetration, but again, my question will be, wouldn't the bullet with the better design and greater energy (but smaller weight) give better penetration?
Thanks for your help on this, you guys have been so helpful in helping me sort out many things...I appreciate your help.
Greg
This is what is listed on the box:
.30-06 Fed Prem Ammo 165 gr (Barnes Triple-Shock)
Muzzle 100 yards 200 yards
2870 ftlbs 2405 2000
.30-06 Fed Power shock 220 gr (Speer Hot Cor SP)
Muzzle 100 yards 200 yards
2815 2195 1690
Now, my understanding is that someone would buy the first because they wanted something to take down the little black tail deer we have out here or some hogs while someone would buy the second because they wanted to take down some elk or moose. But if you just go by 'energy' the smaller bullet has the larger beat. (I noticed BTW that this is also true when comparing the Corbon 460 gr 45-70 bullets against the smaller 325gr Hornady GMX.) Now, I understand that the faster the bullet goes the more energy it will have, but then why go with the bigger bullet that won't fly as fast (given the same cartridge)?
Why use the bigger bullet?
Why is the 220 gr bullet better to take down a elk than the 165gr? (Also, there must be more to the fact that 'bullet placement' is always key...but assuming a correctly placed bullet, why wouldn't I take the one with the higher energy (but smaller weight) to knock down whatever I'm hunting?)
Perhaps the answer will have to do with penetration, but again, my question will be, wouldn't the bullet with the better design and greater energy (but smaller weight) give better penetration?
Thanks for your help on this, you guys have been so helpful in helping me sort out many things...I appreciate your help.
Greg