Colt Agent, Learn me some knowledge an unfamiliar revolver

Status
Not open for further replies.
I went last week to pick up a beautiful nickel plated S&W Model 12. When I got there, it was hard to open and close. Also felt like the cylinder was dragging on the forcing code in places. Looking with a light, it appeared the forcing cone and cylinder were not square to each other. Pulled off the cylinder and there it was plain as day, cracked frame right under the forcing cone. It was not just a hairline crack either. This one was at leas 1/16" wide. The seller told me he had been shooting the gun that morning and several days prior. Not sure if he knew it was cracked and was just trying to pass it off or not, but a great actor if the surprise of the crack was not real. He did admit that almost all the rounds he had fired through it in the last year or so were +P. Did that cause it? Who knows and who knows how long it had been cracked. The +P certainly didn't help. Depending on the load, the +P can have a good deal more pressure from different data I've read. No matter what, I might would carry an alloy gun with +P but never practice with it. I bet in the last 30 years over half of the alloy frame Smith and Colt Revolvers I've seen have had a cracked frame. Its just not worth messing up a nice gun. But then again, how nice is a gun if you can't enjoy it like you want???
The model 12 besides aluminum frame has a slimmed down frame, hey are notorious for cracking.
 
Last edited:
Where can you get a 2017 Cobra for 400 bucks?
I've seen several used ones in the $400-450 range at gun shows with no buyers surprisingly. I just bought one from a dealer still sealed in box for $500 which I understand is right around cost. He had 4-5 and wanted to dump a few. I was able to flip it and make a few bucks but not what I thought. It seems there are nice ones that have smooth actions and others have gritty actions. I handled one in a shop that felt horrible. Maybe it go something in the action, I don't know but I put it down immediately. I had 2 brand new ones when they first came out and they both felt different. One was much smoother than the other, but I never shot either one, that's when people were paying stupid money for them.
 
Update: I decided to pass on the Agent due to its uncertainty with plus p ammo, exposed hammer, and out of production status.
 
The model 12 besides aluminum frame has a slimmed down frame, hey are notorious for cracking.

I did not know that, Gordon! Just in case I misunderstood, do you mean the Model 12 frame is actually slimmer in some areas than a Model 12 frame? Boy, if that's true, S&W went too far for weight savings. Although I guess way back in the 1950's or 1960's, when 38 Special +P wasn't as much of a thing, it may have made more sense.
 
yup it is thinner in some areas. I was issued a Model 10 as a Counter Intel agent in 70s and longed for a model 12. When I finally bought one, long after getting out, I was horrified to find regular model 10 grips did not fit . And the frame and throat cracking were pretty universal unless shot lightly and infrequently :( . The dimensions of a revolver are critical and monkeying with the success of the Model 10 was not a real success.Now another thought "I heard" from a long retired old school Colt employee is that the Agent in the unpolished format was amazingly found a slight bit more rugged from the metal left on and not removed compared to the Cobra of same years. Fits with my unaware abuse of two of them with low .357 mag pressured 110 +p+ loads. Some of the Agents how ever were very poorly assembled with little or no final fitting required on those old D frames.
 
Now another thought "I heard" from a long retired old school Colt employee is that the Agent in the unpolished format was amazingly found a slight bit more rugged from the metal left on and not removed compared to the Cobra of same years.

Not considering the last run of Cobras/Agents having shrouded ejectors (post-1972), the post-1966 Cobras had the same shorter grip frame as the Agent but came with longer wood stocks, otherwise the two revolvers were identical in every respect.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top