I’ve been debating whether or not to share this, because these sticks are not really meant and weren’t purchased as self defense tools. However the various discussions of materials and sticks other than shillelaghs and blackthorn walking sticks that have come out in this thread have been interesting. So why not?
My interest in my ancestry and the cultures that it evolved from gives me an interest in folklore and mythology. The notion of the “green man” has been ingrained in me for a few decades as well, which isn’t a surprise given my profession.
So in light of those factors I felt a fun urge to pick up some sticks of different materials.
This stick is 48” long, 720 grams, and is made from Rowan tree. Also known as mountain ash. I bought it from a seller on eBay, and I’m quite satisfied with it for hiking purposes. It is strong and light, and will support a human body no problem. It does have a little flex though and I don’t know that it’d survive a self defense incident. However, if it breaks during a successful use, and my life is saved, I think I could live with that. So if you’re thinking strictly in those terms of defense, I wouldn’t recommend it. I do like the aesthetic choice the stick maker made by moderately sanding this stick, and then using a clear seal so the bark comes through.
View attachment 890352 View attachment 890353
Next is a stick made of hazel. I didn’t even know hazel could be this large. It’s done in the knob stick style, is 37” in length, and if I remember correctly it weighs a little under 400 grams. I’m very impressed by how strong it feels given it’s weight, and I actually think it’d be a little better for thumping an aggressive dog or person than Rowan would. In any case, it’s a neat hiking companion and I enjoy it. I purchased this one from McCaffery as well.
View attachment 890354
View attachment 890355
On another note, I did have an issue with the second blackthorn I posted above. I noticed after about a week that a crack had formed at the center of the knob and started radiating down toward the shaft. It’s then started radiating around the base of the knob. I assume this one didn’t cure out properly. I contacted Mr McCaffery and asked for suggestions on repair, and he responded within perhaps an hour that he felt the crack was problematic and that he would send me a replacement. Now that’s great service. The man stands behind his product. Approximately 9 days later, this showed up.
View attachment 890357
View attachment 890356
So I have now ended up with three blackthorns as a result. I just consider the cracked one my beater/practice stick.
So one stick expanded to six. I am keeping an eye open for an oak shillelagh as well, because that’s what the originals were made from prior to Ireland being logged off, but I more or less have my needs met for years to come.