hard chambering

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jeff Flannery

Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2018
Messages
195
All... some of my 7mm/08 brass is making my bolt close with more force than i'd like. I used my redding comp shell holders and worked from .010 and settled on .04 when some of them chambered easily. Then again, some still closed tightly I checked headspace with my Hornady comparator and it they were with in sammi specs. I checked the length and they were within ax oal.. I full length sized them and they are still tight. Any thoughts?? This also happens with my 243's
 
Use a sharpie (black or blue works best for me) on a couple cartridges, marking them totally head to neck. After chambering and extraction, that should help you see where they're tight at.
 
Necks in bottle neck cartridges will thicken over time.
With a bullet seated the neck is being squeezed in that part of the chamber. If that’s the case the neck needs to be outside reamed.
 
Mixed brass? Same brass but different number of firings? Different spring back?

Do you have a way to measure shoulder position before and after sizing?

It can be home made and free, or very reasonable, or a bit pricey. I have some home made "gauges", but also have some pieces from the Sinclair system.
 

Attachments

  • Sinclair Comparator Body & Inserts.JPG
    Sinclair Comparator Body & Inserts.JPG
    39.3 KB · Views: 15
  • Sinclair 30 Degree Bump Gauge Insert @ 33%.JPG
    Sinclair 30 Degree Bump Gauge Insert @ 33%.JPG
    53.5 KB · Views: 78
  • 300 Blackout Shoulder Gauge Pic 5.JPG
    300 Blackout Shoulder Gauge Pic 5.JPG
    23.3 KB · Views: 16
  • 300 Blackout Shoulder Gauge Pic 7.JPG
    300 Blackout Shoulder Gauge Pic 7.JPG
    86.3 KB · Views: 119
My best guess is that they weren't full length sized even though you thought they were. If the shell holder doesn't touch the base of the die on the up stroke you haven't full lengh sized the case. The cause can be inadequate lubrication of the case.

A less likely possibility is that you need a small base die.

In loading thousands of rounds I've never had thickened necks be a cause of hard chambering. Likewise, I've never found work hardened brass to be a cause of hard chambering though it is a cause of split necks.
 
I would try sizing, rotating the brass 1/4 turn and sizing again. Just make sure the press is camming over with the brass in it to make sure it is an actual FL size operation. Then try the brass before loading it first.
 
Thanks all.... the cases have been fired maybe 3 times. if that. I always run the ram up to touch the shell holder then turn the die another 1/2 turn or so, so I get the "cam over". I also use the lanolin/ heet mixture to lubricate my cases.
 
I've never had thickened necks be a cause of hard chambering. Likewise, I've never found work hardened brass to be a cause of hard chambering
If the sizer was set up with soft new brass, and set to size minimally, then never adjusted again, and the cases are not annealed, it eventually can. Not likely the cause here, as I agree with you here.
My best guess is that they weren't full length sized even though you thought they were. If the shell holder doesn't touch the base of the die on the up stroke you haven't full lengh sized the case.
 
3 common causes for the feeling of hard closing bolts:

1) Jamming over-length seated bullets into the lands

2) Crush fitting an over-length shoulder for headspace

3) Wedge fitting an oversized case base

The first two are hard to mess up, easily diagnosed, and easily fixed - lowering your seater plug and your sizer body, respectively. The 3rd is more difficult to identify, and may only be remedied by replacing your die - especially in consideration of minimizing shoulder set-back while still sizing the base sufficiently.
 
No crud. I took my decapping assembly out of my Hornady FL sizing die. I had many primed cases that when chambered, the bolt was VERY hard to close. Again I tried my redding shell holders and at .002, all f them now chambered and the bolt closed easily.
 
i'm hoping! Do you know is it a mute point to use the redding shell holders in a full length die? If so, where are they to be used?
 
They are to be used like you used them, but you stopped too soon and some wouldn't chamber.

I would still suggest you get some way to measure where the shoulder is before and after sizing.
 
mute point to use the redding (competition) shell holders
SAAMI tolerances- A maximum (large) rifle chamber and a fl die that sizes the brass to the maximum (smallest) amount may leave a chambered cartridge with as much as .015" head clearance. Not good.

Most chambers and fl dies are cut some where between maximum & minimum specifications.

Your fl die is just a few thousandth smaller then the rifles chamber, because it almost works with the .002" competition shell holder. Almost a perfect march.

So this time, the competition shell holder may not be needed for this rifle?

The cam over difference between a hard vs a light cam over may make a thousandth difference in shoulder bump/set back when fl sizing.

As brass work hardens, it may require a standard shell holder? Time will tell.

Always see if 3 empty fl sized brass will allow the bolt to close easly.

Fired brass may take 3 or more firings to fully expand to the chamber. https://saami.org/
 
Last edited:
Thanks i'll try that. I have no idea what else to do to get them to chamber easily
Jeff
Lots of good input, and to be clear I’m NOT posting in contradiction to any other post,,,, if I may add that it sounds like your brass are now fully fire formed. You have a great opportunity to adjust your headspace by sizing a few more thousand and note exactly how much sizing is happening. When I first set a die to touch I find about .010 between the the top of the ram and the bottom of the shell holder, After recording the datum of a fully formed case I’ll size using a (full stroke )then record a base to datum number for comparison , if no difference I’ll change feeler gauges and adjustment the die down a couple thousand at a time until I record change then sneak up on the final number you seek. All I personally need is enough sizing to chamber freely.
A case gage I find to be a very useful tool as well.
Take your time and measure as you go.
J
 

Attachments

  • A0C37BA8-7BDF-418D-B17A-C7CE49E271DA.jpeg
    A0C37BA8-7BDF-418D-B17A-C7CE49E271DA.jpeg
    86.3 KB · Views: 17
  • BE474317-394D-442E-966D-20ACF2C2FFCB.jpeg
    BE474317-394D-442E-966D-20ACF2C2FFCB.jpeg
    115.6 KB · Views: 17
Last edited:
Thanks for the additional notes! Walkalong, I checked with my Hornady comparator both before and after sizing and was under the headspace length. South prairie, I've never measured the distance between the top of the ram and bottom of the shellholder. I guess since I have a good cam over, they are snug against each other. Not true?
 
Understanding that this thread is a dog whistle for Mr Guffey

I’ll say - Define good cam over in thousands ??:thumbdown:
 
Last edited:
I checked headspace with my Hornady comparator and it they were with in sammi specs.

The Hornady comparator that you are using does not necessarily measure headspace to the same datum that SAAMI measures to, so that isn't the number that you should use.

Instead, use the comparator to get a measurement from a case that chambers "snug" - but not using force. Check that measurement and record the number. Set your die to size THAT case .001 to .002 shorter using your gauge. If the bolt now closes easily, you have your number.

Again, because your measurement tool is not the same tool that they use, the SAAMI number does not rule - your chamber rules.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top