Who carries a 642?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Axis II

Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2015
Messages
7,179
Looking for suggestions on a holster with some sort of retention for my 642 hammerless. I have a serpa but it prints too bad.
 
Looking for suggestions on a holster with some sort of retention for my 642 hammerless.
Let me guess you have a LE background?

Most concealment holsters don't come with retention devices. Some are available, but usually not needed on a concealment holster. The typical revolver retention would be a thumb break, but that probably won't work with a hammerless revolver.

Bianchi has this CarryLok, though I don't know if it is available for your gun https://safariland.com/products/model-82-carrylok-auto-retention-belt-slide-holster-10870
 
Let me guess you have a LE background?

Most concealment holsters don't come with retention devices. Some are available, but usually not needed on a concealment holster. The typical revolver retention would be a thumb break, but that probably won't work with a hammerless revolver.

Bianchi has this CarryLok, though I don't know if it is available for your gun https://safariland.com/products/model-82-carrylok-auto-retention-belt-slide-holster-10870
Main reason is I carry it when hunting and hiking and afraid of taking a fall or something and have it fall out. Before I gain a ton of weight I wore it in a safariland IWB with a retention screw setup. Most the holster I see for it are just leather and slide in.
 
Just a data point, but in this video, the guy has a Kramer Belt Scabbard with an S&W 327. You can skip to about the 6:20 mark in the video where he gets around to talking about the retention of this holster without an active retention device.

 
Main reason is I carry it when hunting and hiking and afraid of taking a fall or something and have it fall out.
I have practically no use for a SERPA, but as a field holster would be where that holster has some use. If needed in that environment, I'd probably use a Safariland or the SERPA if you really thought you needed the retention and just accept the lack of conceal-ability.
 
Most the holster I see for it are just leather and slide in.
It's not gravity that keeps the gun in the well-made versions of those leather holsters. It is the shape of the holster that provides retention. There are threads all over this and other gun forums from folks with new leather holsters complaining they can't draw their gun from the holster because it is too tight. I refer to that as "wedgie level" of retention, where you're giving yourself a "wedgie" trying to draw your pistol.

You can often find these threads by searching for the "plastic bag trick" or "waxed paper trick" or "blocking a holster" or "breaking in a new holster".
 
Just a data point, but in this video, the guy has a Kramer Belt Scabbard with an S&W 327. You can skip to about the 6:20 mark in the video where he gets around to talking about the retention of this holster without an active retention device.


I’ve got two Kramer belt scabbards and I can attest to the awesomeness of retention. Imho there’s no finer gunleather. For my snub I use desantis pocket. Lotta folks love the Mika. If I ever get a fancy bodyguard I’ll get a Mika!
 
For pocket carry, which I did for 15 years, I am still a big fan of Robert Mika's custom pocket holsters. His work has been a favorite of THR 642 Club members for years. However, while pocket carry is great for concealment and comfort, it is terrible for rapid draw and presentation. Last spring I tried a relative unknown Kydex from Skydas and find it comfortable, sturdy and with good retention; I have used it for both strong side and appendix IWB carry. Only $34.00 on Amazon and really a good fit.
My EDC is now a double stack 9, but on some occasions the 642 is a good choice.
 
Looking for suggestions on a holster with some sort of retention for my 642 hammerless. I have a serpa but it prints too bad.
I carry one. I have a uncle mikes pocket holster, a high riding nice leather OWB one which is concealable during winter. I have a cheap IWB faux leather type one I never use for the 642.
 
For pocket carry, which I did for 15 years, I am still a big fan of Robert Mika's custom pocket holsters. His work has been a favorite of THR 642 Club members for years. However, while pocket carry is great for concealment and comfort, it is terrible for rapid draw and presentation. Last spring I tried a relative unknown Kydex from Skydas and find it comfortable, sturdy and with good retention; I have used it for both strong side and appendix IWB carry. Only $34.00 on Amazon and really a good fit.
My EDC is now a double stack 9, but on some occasions the 642 is a good choice.
I didn’t know there was a 642 club.
 
A different option may be to put a lanyard on it. I like that for a woods gun which seems to be the way the OP is using his 642.

There were Hogue adapters made that did not require drilling the frame. Not sure if they were made for the J-frame or not though. Worth looking into if a lanyard would meet your needs.
 
Who carries a 642?
Looking for suggestions on a holster with some sort of retention. . .
I do, and in my opinion you have the wrong gun.

The only good reason to carry a gun that small is to put it in your pocket, in a pocket holster. If you're going to attach a holster to your belt, put a larger gun in it.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top