Trapdoor Springfield - How much breech block wobble is acceptable?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Dec 17, 2020
Messages
42
How much wobble is acceptable for a trapdoor when the breech block is closed?

I recently won an 1884 trapdoor in an auction, so I couldn't inspect in person.

When closed, there is a minor side-to-side wiggle ("yaw"). It's hard to measure (about less than 1mm or 0.040"), but you can rock the rear of breech block side to side and hear it "click" from the wiggle room. There is no forward-aft wiggle, nor any up or down wiggle.

When opened, there is a decent amount of side-to-side wobble on the hinge. I have read that looseness with the breechblock open is fine, because the hinge pin does not bear any load, and it is the cam latch that bears all the force of firing.

If I remove the breech block and examine the cam latch, the cam pin has a decent amount of angular play in the attachment in the breech block. Is this what is causing the looseness at lockup? And if I replace the cam latch ($50 part) will this fix the looseness?
 
It's sounds completely normal given the age and amount of use these irons have seen. Mine was an '73 rifle that was cut down to carbine length, wrist has been broken in multiple places and repaired with epoxy and brass screws, and it has a sewer pipe bore. In the closed position there is no discernable movement but when the breech block is lifted and after the ejector activates, I get about 1/16th to 3/32's side to side wobble. I normally shoot mine with 55 to 65 gr FFg under 400 grain bullets.

hRTHInknppBVkM9qarbHltE14rado8VkTqEgS8FRCYUb0BCW3ClcEnY1ffaR_UV5U4nqCIw=w1500-h844-no?authuser=0.jpg
 
In the closed position there is no discernable movement
See that's why I'm concerned. I've read a lot of posts by people saying even their trash mix-master guns have no breechblock movement at lockup, so any movement at lockup makes me worry something is not right.
So is movement at lockup normal or not?
 
See that's why I'm concerned. I've read a lot of posts by people saying even their trash mix-master guns have no breechblock movement at lockup, so any movement at lockup makes me worry something is not right.
So is movement at lockup normal or not?

I just threw my caliper on the lug at rear of the breech block, across the area that makes contact with the recess in the receiver (all bluing is missing at this spot) and it measures about .302". Of the spots I could measure at different ends of that part, it was .305" at its widest and .300 at the narrowest. You could check yours and see if it's noticeably undersized. Also, could it be possible the spring pressure on yours is light?
 
I checked both of mine. My rifle, made in 1884 hardly has any wobble, is quite tight. But, there is wobble. My carbine, made in 1876 has a lot of wobble. Both are good shooters, and I have shot both extensively. I shoot the normal rifle load in the carbine, 45-70-405, and a 45-80-400 load in the rifle. Neither has blown my face off yet, although it would be an improvement. I don't see where side to side play would pose any kind of safety issue. I too would check the spring, it could be quite weak, even though it's only over 100 years old. DSC01596.JPG
 
From what I’ve seen in all the trapdoor books I have side to side movement is normal. Now if you have front to back movement when closed then that’s not good.
My 1873 rifle has side to side and it is in very good condition.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top