Suggestions wanted for my first revolver!

Status
Not open for further replies.

storm shadow

Member
Joined
May 7, 2007
Messages
19
I am thinking of getting a Smith and Wesson revolver for my first handgun. I like the versatility of the .38/.357 lineup in that you can shoot .38, .38+p, and even .357 Magnum loads all through the same gun (target practice with the .38 and then later put .38+p or .357 in it for personal defense).

I intend to keep the gun under my car seat for personal defense and for taking it the range for target practice.

For a guy, I have very small hands, wrists and arms (think of a woman's small hands, wrists and arms and you are about right).

Still, the J frames (small) seem kind of too small. And the K and L frames (medium) seem kind of too big to me. Doesn't somebody manufacture a revolver frame in between these two extremes?

Maybe I should split the difference and go with one of the heavier J frames or a lighter K or L frame. I know shooting a .357 cartridge has a vicious recoil to it. If I do this, what will the differences be in kick if both guns have a 3" barrel? Will there be that much difference or will they be about the same? Should I just go ahead and bite the bullet (no pun intended) and get a heavier K or L frame in the hopes that it's heavier frame weight will dampen the recoil for me? Or should I go with the J frame since it might be closer to my hand and wrist size and fit my hands better for better overall control? Should I get a 2", 3" or 4" barrel?

Any and all suggestions welcome.
 
I also like S&W revolvers but in your case I think a 3 1/16" Ruger SP101 .357 Magnum might be just perfect for your needs. It is a little larger than a J frame but not as large as a K frame. It's also heavier than a J frame which will help you with recoil. I feel it would be a good choice for you. http://www.ruger-firearms.com/Firearms/FAProdView?model=5719&return=Y

EDIT:
LOL. I took too long to finish my post and The Undertoad beat me!!
 
Colt's Detective Special fell right in the middle between the J and K frames. Unfortunately, its no longer produced. And those who have them really aren't fond of giving them up. Colt did produce a Magnum Carry for a short time, and they demand a collector's premium to acquire.

I have J frames, K frames and now 2 Colt D frames. Of all, I like the Colts the most. Then again, that's just me and my preferences.
 
Great ideas so far. Thanks. The Ruger SP 101 is now in the running. I will have to go look at one.

What is the difference between the Ruger Security Six and the Ruger Police Service Six? Or are they the same guns? How much are these currently going for, any ideas?
 
quote by storm shadow : What is the difference between the Ruger Security Six and the Ruger Police Service Six? Or are they the same guns? How much are these currently going for, any ideas?


the Ruger Police Service Six is simply the Security Six with slightly modified grips and with a sighting groove in the backstrap instead of a separate rear sight, a modification intended for rapid combat firing at short range and avoid getting the sights deranged by careless insertion into the holster or other rough handling.It was widely adopted by L.E.O. in the past.
 
Try a Ruger Security Six. They are K frame size, but have thinner stocks.

How much are these currently going for, any ideas?

$200 to $250 for the standard Security Sixes. Usually a bit more for Speed Sixes or Service Sixes. Prices are going up.
 
Last edited:
I would go with a K or L frame Smith and swap the grips to fit your hand.
I agree. S&W has taken to shipping their Ks & Ls with big honkin Hogue monogrips of late. I find the Pachmayr Compac Professional to be a great grip that truly feels mid sized.
 
Ruger GP-100 in either 3" or 4" bbl. would be a fine choice.
MediumLarge Frame with 6-shots and a strong design.
.357 is a great choice, too.
Have fun!:)
 
For a first Revolver I'd get a Ruger GP100 or SP101 or S&W 686 all with a 4" or 5" barrel.
 
go find a gun dealer that will let you shoot the revolvers, thats the best way to know if it will work for you or not.
 
Get a Smith and then get grips that you feel more comfortable with. They are not expensive and you will get a FINE gun with a Smith!
 
I fully agree

I agree. S&W has taken to shipping their Ks & Ls with big honkin Hogue monogrips of late. I find the Pachmayr Compac Professional to be a great grip that truly feels mid sized.

The Pachmayr grips make a world of difference.

Also, check out the SP101.
 
Thanks for the pictures of that nice Police Service Six. I did some research and checked the dimensions on that gun. It seems like it was just made for my hand (smaller than the Smith K or L's but bigger than the J's). Perfect! That's just what I had in mind. Your pictures appears to be a 3" barrel blued model but every picture I've seen so far is of a 4" stainless steel model. For my application, a 3" barrel would be ideal if I could find it in stainless steel. Is there even such a thing? If not, I would have to settle on a 4" model.

What are some other makes and models in a police service revolvers that I can check and compare the dimensions on? The market seems to be chock full of these police turn-ins since every cop in the land foolishly traded in these fine He-Man revolvers for a small black plastic toy gun several years ago. ;)
 
weird suggestion

i know this is kind of weird but you mentioned that you have smaller hands and wrists than usual, if you like smith and wesson alot, you should go with a lady smith, they're lighter and smaller than the regular ones, just a suggestion, also look at taurus and rossi thay have some decent ones
 
storm shadow,
I figured the pictures would be better than trying to tell you the difference in size compared to a J and K/L frame.

Actually, Ruger made their short barrel revolver in 2.75", just long enough for a full length ejector rod. I think they did make the 2.75" in Stainless but I'm not totally sure. I wasn't looking for another revoilver when I found that one but couldn't resist. I know they made the Speed-Six in 2.75" Stainless and here is an example: http://www.gunbroker.com/Auction/ViewItem.asp?Item=71473855 That model happens to be a .38 Special, my revolver is a .357 Magnum. I'm sure if you look around you can find one in .357 Magnum.

The Speed-Six is the same exact gun as the Service-Six except it has a round butt where as the Service-Six has a square butt.
 
Originally posted by storm shadow:
And the K and L frames (medium) seem kind of too big to me. Doesn't somebody manufacture a revolver frame in between these two extremes?
No. When talking about K and L frames, the grip size and trigger reach is the same; only the frames, cylinders and barrels are different. Virtually all of these revolvers produced in about the last dozen years or so have the "round" butt. Select a grip that doesn't cover the backstrap of the frame (but does fill in the area of the front of the frame under the trigger guard) and you will have a comfortable reach to the trigger. Such grips include (but are not limited to) the Uncle Mike's/Butler Creek "boot grips," Pachmayr Compac Professional, etc.

Unless it is to be used strictly for training with nothing but 125-grain magnums, I would be happy with an adjustable sighted K-frame.
 
Base upon what you said about grip size, I would suggest that you see if you can handle a square butt J frame. You won't find a new gun with one, but there are some nice older ones out there. I picked up a mint square butt 37 a couple of years ago for $200, and it is just about perfect with the stock magna grips and a Tyler T-Grip.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top