tjj,
"If they cost as much as the real deal then why buy?"
3 simple word: Out of Stock.
I got some to try & was sort of a panic buy. I couldn't find other 168's at the time. I didn't know that Midway had the Noslers that cheap in the 1K qty. If the Widener's 168's have bad accuracy the savings is not worth it to me. All the rest of the cost is still there. Primer, Powder, Prep, Travel etc.
I'm in SE Louisiana also. My neighbor had good results with the Nosler & Honardy. It is pretty cool to have a neighbor to work with on reloading & shooting. He gave me some of the Noslers.