Between myself and 2 buddies we are shooting both. I have only owned red dots and used one for 20 years. About 3 months ago a bought a much better dot from burris, a 35mm with a 3 mil red dot. Works great on the 44 DW, My 2 hunting buddies both bought riger SRH's and EOtech Holographic sites and i set all of them up. Both types work very well at the range with the 512 EO haveing a 1: dot with a 60" circle and as real quick to get on target. Size of both are basicly the same as far as wieght, height and lenght with the Eotech is a different design. I like the EO just as well . DON"T buy junk and that is sometimes hard to tell good from junk. Just read up on reviews of products and any problems typicaly come to the surface. If range is limited to under ,say, your 60 to even 75 yards a 1X red dot sould be quicker on target. Both are adjustable for brightness. They also allows some cheating as far as haveing to look down the center of the site. More or less if the dot is on the target you got it,even if the dot is up near a corner at the shorter ranges you look to be hunting. With ether, a good 6 x 32 up to 8 x 40 bino's would be needed to watch those deer. Uncle Mikes has a low priced but good basic cross chest holster for a scoped handgun too. Abit slow to answer you.