Riddle me this

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Feb 5, 2012
Messages
333
So today I purchased everything necessary to reload .30 carbine (except a case trimmer) but I bought all new brass so shouldn't need it quite yet.
ANYWAYS...
I set up a dummy round with no primer or powder to make sure I have all of my dimensions correct here, I'll post some pics. (I read up on the data but point out if I have any errors)

Now I purchased the Lee 3 die set.. which doens't have a crimp, but I'm assuming that when the bullet is seated, the case tension is enough to keep the bullet in place??? I put alot of weight on the bullet and it didn't move in the case, so it felt pretty sturdy.

Also, I chambered this DUMMY round to ensure it went into battery, and ejected fine... No problems. So it seems as if I have everything in order, just need to get my powder down. I'm using h110 BTW.

So, let me know if anything stands out to you.. won't begin actual reloads till tomorrow. Also, let me in on some of your favorite loads with this powder.
I have Sierra 110 gr rn sp's.
Thanks guys
 

Attachments

  • .30 carbine reload 1.jpg
    .30 carbine reload 1.jpg
    105 KB · Views: 39
  • .30 carbine reload 4.jpg
    .30 carbine reload 4.jpg
    84 KB · Views: 35
  • .30 carbine reload 2.jpg
    .30 carbine reload 2.jpg
    42.2 KB · Views: 49
  • .30 carbine reload 3.jpg
    .30 carbine reload 3.jpg
    48.4 KB · Views: 38
Your die set DOES have a crimp... it's the standard bullet seating/crimping die. Turn it in if you want crimp, turn it out if you don't.

But IMO you don't need to crimp rifle rounds if case neck tension is correct.
 
Neck tension holds the bullet in place, not the "crimp". A taper crimp should be built into the seater die, but it is meant to remove the belling, or just a hair more, not hold the bullet. Use calipers to make sure you remove the bell but don't "crimp" more than .001ish.

Neck tension looks good, as does the round.
 
so your saying I need to make sure the very end of the brass is no shorter than .001 less then the rest of the case?
 
Check the brass for length, I have found many brand new cases that were too long right out of the bag.
 
so your saying I need to make sure the very end of the brass is no shorter than .001 less then the rest of the case?
Shorter? Don't have any more than about .001 inward movement at the case mouth from the "crimp".

attachment.php
 
You should check the length of the new brass. I have bought brass that needed trimming from the word go. I usually run mine through the sizing die just for good measure, but that may be my light case of OCD taking over.:)
 
Thanks guys. I did check to see that all of the brass was under the max length.

So then all i need to do is make sure the tip of the brass at the bullet is not more then .001 less then the rest of the casing? (and the crimp level will determine this?)
 
Looks like you were on a good start (I do suggest trimming to length, but you checked) and got side tracked. The best thing you can do with the crimping is ignore it until you get some handloads completed and shooting well. crimping canbe a huge pain to deal with, and offers nothing in gain in your situation.

When you crimp a bullet it sizes the diameter of the case mouth in towards the bullet...which is the case mouth only and will not have any effect on length to speak of when setting up your trim to length.

Trim length is important on new brass it's best to full length size each case or at least run the expander ball through the case neck, then trim all your brass to the length you desire. That will allow you to see how much your cases are stretching etc, also provides a good starting point for working up loads.

If you can put weight on the bullet as you have posted then you have done a really good job. I know your nervous on your first loads just be careful, measure everything twice, keep everything in order, only one powder on the table or around your work area. Keep us updated your starting a never ending habit handloading that you will love.
 
I know my measurements are pretty good.. I just need to check the width at the crimp to make sure its not too tight. Thats my only real question at this point.
 
Chamber your dummy round if it chambers well then your have no problem. If you sized your cases your will not have a problem, crimping is not part of sizing it's a feature more for the bullet than the case (adds a small amount of pressure on case mouth to bullet). Read over crimping in your handloading manual.. Crimping can remove a bell if one is there, I never crimp rifle rounds ever I see no need, and more times than not it will degrade accuracy and can cause other problems. Don't worry over crimping your rounds now, do read up on it studying in case you want to try it after you have become familiar with the basic reloading steps...

Again be careful, and patient check everything twice and only one powder where your reloading at one time.
 
I'm using h110.
So about the crimp, .... If i don't crimp, then will the case mouth remain flaired? Isn't the the whole idea behind the crimp (that and to tighten around the bullet)?
 
I'm using h110.
So about the crimp, .... If i don't crimp, then will the case mouth remain flaired? Isn't the the whole idea behind the crimp (that and to tighten around the bullet)?

Most manuals will recommend that you crimp semi auto rifles. Like the AR 15. There is a lot of discussion and controversy on this subject. There is not a lot of recoil in either so the bullets are not likely to move.

Yes, you can lightly taper crimp to remove any flair if you did flair the case. It is crimping like you would a 9mm or a 45 ACP. Not a heavy crimp like a revolver crimp. Neck tension holds the bullet. The "crimp" is just to remove any flair.
 
Your full length sizing die will size the brass to size for correct bullet seating, and bullet tension. The bullet diameter is bigger towards the base, this is where you get your bullet tension.

Do read over crimping in your loading manual it can explain it much better than I can, in your case as a new hand loader crimping can cause a lot of problems leading to reduced accuracy, and I can't see any reason to crimp as your full length die has prepared your brass for bullet seating. Does the bullets your using have a crimping cannula ?

Maybe rcmodel can touch on this subject when he replies as I may be doing a bad job of explaining it to you...

edit to add: what reloading manual are you using ? I had a junky Lee manual, but he explains crimping perfect and shows lots of research even coming up with a factory crimp die using a collet. If you have a Lee handloading manual check the info about crimping.
 
One more try on crimping....

If your loading lead bullets or pistol etc many people or die sets flare the case mouth a small amount to ease loading the bullet without damage (case mouth would scrape bullet) also in military and hunting ammo may be banged around loose or as a precaution to make sure the case mouth is not flared which can cause failure to feed. When I say flared I don't mean slightly larger I mean flared open easy to notice, however with military ammo you can imagine a small extra step with so much ammo and reliability as is with hunting ammo..this is done on mass loading machines

I don't crimp my hunting ammo or ar15 ammo I have not seen a need for it. I did try a small project using lee factory crimp on 223 ammo in ar15 and bolt guns best I could say is it didn't hurt accuracy, but more times than not it degraded accuracy.
 
Yes, on your first handloads I'm saying don't concentrate on crimp, I wouldn't crimp at all and I never do on rifle rounds.

My question to you have you tried adjusting the die for amount of crimp, also what reloading manual are you using ? Does your bullets have a cannula for crimping ? After all my post I do suggest after you learn to handload that you play with the crimping die on a couple of cases you can size and crimp adjusting the die to understand what is going on, and how much die adjustment it takes to apply a crimp etc...

Study the section on crimping, and try to find the article from Lee on crimping you may find it on net, I know it's in the Lee reloading manual
 
And from everythign I've gathered, 14.5 gr of h110 with 110 gr rn sp OR fmj duplicates the usgi military load.
 
Please get a manual, it is the single most important tool in a reloaders kit. I'm not just say this you can no depend on the net for reloading., you can use it as a source, but you should have at least 1 preferably 2 reloading manuals that teach the basic reloading steps necessary to load safe, dependable, accurate ammunition. It will also give you a standard to go by in your hands so to speak on both load data, and instructions.

Anyone can make a small mistake typing, or reading on the net.
 
so I could theoretically take the crimp out, use very little flair and call it a day?
The expander has two steps in it and does two things, it expands and flares the case. You can screw it down just enough to expand the case enough to accept a bullet more easily, but stop short of adjusting it down enough to flare the case. Then there would be no flare to remove. This should work OK with jacketed bullets. If it doesn't, you'll need to flare just a little.

A manual covers all of this, and is well worth the price of admission.
 
And from everythign I've gathered, 14.5 gr of h110 with 110 gr rn sp OR fmj duplicates the usgi military load.

I used 14.5gn as a start load for Hornady 100gn SJ bullets. You should start at 14.0gn for a 110gn bullet, this is straight from the Hodgdon website. Work up from there.
 
Nothing wrong with you using H110( W296). But with things being what they are today hope you have a good stash of it. I also get good results with 2400 & imr 4227 which may be easier to find. I would suggest not limiting yourself to just 1 powder. Standard loads, nice thing about the carbine (it ain't brain surgery) readily available in all manuals.
I also recommend using Hornady's old 100gr SJ. Good economical plinking bullet in the carbine. But it is my understanding that Hornady is not making them anymore. I still see them at shows and pick them up when I can. Speer has its own 100gr "plinker' and is still available. Fun gun to shoot.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top