My 1894c is my only centerfire rifle at present. It makes a lot of sense for me, and I love the thing. I got it basically because (well, because I wanted it of course, and because) I already reloaded for a couple of .357 revolvers. That being the case, it's been easy, inexpensive, and pleasant for me to work up loads that squeeze out all the accuracy and power this rifle (and the .357) has to offer. Not only is it fun and light to handle and shoot; using a lyman rear apeture sight (with the large 'hunting' aperture) and the standard front sight, I can hit a big grapefruit all day long at 100 yards--with a 158 gr. JSP moving over 1800 fps at the barrel. I haven't hunted, but I look forward to doing so in the next couple of years; and if the game I hunt is not larger than small deer, this will definitely be the rifle I hunt with. In the meantime, it's just a lot of fun--and dirt cheap--to load and shoot.
I like the Marlin so much I would think very hard about getting another, if I felt I eventually needed a larger rifle for hunting; probably a 1895 in 45-70 for the woodsy elk or black bear of Western Washington, where I anticipate being when I get to hunting.
The 1894c is a fun gun, and one you just feel good handling. And, of course, I wouldn't feel bad about it in the remote possibility that some situation arose where I wanted a home/neighborhood defense weapon with more range and/or capacity than a shotgun. It'd do that job just fine. I've bought guns I regretted--but the 1894 is surely not one of them, and never will be.
cg