Beretta92 versus S&W 5906 in terms of least recoil?

[slick6]

Beretta 92 versus s&W 5906 in terms of the least amount of recoil?:

1)How close do these two guns compare in the perceived recoil?

2)Does the extra weight(37.5 ozs.)of the S&W 5906, offset the lighter weight(34 ozs.)of the alloy framed Beretta 92 to make the recoil about equal-or?

3)Are these two guns, close in having a similarly low bore axis?

4)Add any other relative or subjective comments regarding the differences in recoil, between these two guns?

 

[Tecolote]

1)You'll get as many different answers as people posting. IMHO the Beretta 92 has less felt recoil because of the barrel/locking blow design.

2)It's not only weight but how the slide operates.

3)I find that the Beretta sits lower in the hand.

4)Recoil is mostly subjective. A guy at my range fires 41Magnum all day long while for first timers that 41Magnum is a beast.

Base your decision more on how each feels in your hand. Find a range with rantals and try them out before you buy.

 

[10-Ring]

Recoil is all w/ the beholder! But to address your question more directly, I prefer the 92fs because the grip fits me better and this distributes recoil in my hands better...YMMV!

 

[albanian]

I too prefer the Beretta for a number of reasons but I don't think recoil is much different between the two. The grip of the Beretta is better for me and the trigger seems smoother but I have seen S&W 5906s that had trigger jobs that were outstanding as well.

BTW, both of these guns have alloy frames.

 

[DMiculek]

The 5906 is all steel (stainless). Smith did offer an alloy frame (5904 IIRC)

 

[BerettaNut92]

Haven't shot the 5906. But I'll say that it depends on the ergonomics of the gun--if you can get your paws around the gun and clamp it down, it'll feel like it recoils less than the gun that doesn't feel just as good in your mitts.

 

[Aahzz]

I have both, and I perceive less recoil with the 5906 - by a fair amount. Yes, it's heavier, but it also fits my hand better, which I think is the real key here.

 

[pete f]

quite frankly i never thought a Nine in a full size frame recoils you get a little bounce but that is it. my son was shooting a model 39 smith at 9 or 10 years old.