I'll reply here to some PMs I received.
Lee Lapin's post is worth a re-read. He and I do converse and are on the same page, as are some others around here.
-I tested a lot of barrels, and chokes over the years with a slew of loads in 12, 20, 28 and .410 - using buckshot.
-I am old school in my thinking about Shotguns and loadings, I admit this. For too many years it was easier for me to buy local, a variety of loads to test. This also allowed me/others to run back to store and buy that same lot number that performed.
In addtion, this allowed me/others to :
(a)- know how alternate loadings performed. For instance having to stop at a local store, or a need arised and someone has various loadings to choose from, we/others knew from "that" selection what performed best (or the better of) from choices.
(b) -dissect loadings , take measurements to duplicate in reloading. Tweak to fit barrel/ choke, and now if supply lines are cut, we have a reload we can do.
-I am not personally fond of the Reduced Recoil loads in MY limited testing. I finally got around to testing some.
(a)-A "rubber ball" bouncing back at me, or anything/ anyone is not something I care for. Especially in load testing, or training/lessons.
(b) Scientific Mud/ Dirt Test. I am over 50, and when I was a brat folks tested all firearm loads by "shooting dirt". Ironic how loads tested, then removed from animals shot - were real darn close in appearance and depth of penetration.
Yeah, I shoot dirt and have with Reduced Recoil and for ME, not applicaple for MY perferences.
-Yes I prefer slugs, yes I have seen buckshot "not be effective". This gets into what a person needs to consider for THEM and all.
-Not impressed with .410 buckshot performance - I do prefer slugs in a .410.
-REAL impressed with 28 ga buckshot performance - see one of the aftermarket shot shell component providers.
Gun is easy to tote, for small folks, and for the elderly , or weaker due to physical limits as a result of injury or surgery. Recoil is mangageable, and has proven itself around farms, ranches and such. 28 ga slugs work REAL well too.
Not a 12 ga, Not a 20 ga, Still a tool for toolbox.
-Winchester Western Buckshot, in the white box with big blue "W" - yes I am quite familar with these "old loads". They should still be good if kept/ stored in a cool dry place.
I liked this loading and it worked in MY guns. I bought it in the 25 rd box, by the case. At that time it was issued ammo for some LEO agencies as well.
Yes it worked fine in the Wood Stocked 870 and Ithaca 37 Police guns.
Just test YOUR guns and see.
- 2 3/4" Shells only for me.
Truth is, never owned a shotgun with a chamber greater except in .410, until a few years ago, and never had a problem felling geese, ducks, deer or anything else with "short shells.
Serious Situation comes up all the time around here. Logistics, is another favorite subject.
2 3/4" shells work in a 3" or longer gun.
3" or 3 1/2 " shells are NOT going to fit in a 2 3/4" chamber, if matters go to serious and that is all is available.
Old school remember? So situation gets serious, say you are handed a used pump gun by a family member to assist with the serious nature of the situation while visiting...2 3/4" chambered old pump gun, and in keeping watch due to whatever, ammo gets lost, wet, or flood capsizes the johnboat.
Others "have ammo" ,maybe neighbors, or whomever and tosses a box of 3" shells.
Great, now what are you going to do? You have a 2 3/4" chamber, and 3" shells.
Same reason one can toss out .38spls and don't matter if the guns are dedicated .38spls or .357s...ammo is gonna work.
I toss you a box of 2 3/4" inch shells, you can use them in a 835 used for goose hunting and 3.5" chamber that newer 870 Express with 3" chamber and that 30 year old 2 3/4" chamber gun.
--
I know, for a fact Lee, Dave, PJR, Trapper, Gordon and some others around here if ( for whatever reason)
I toss out a old bone stock JC Higgins, fixed IC 26" barrel, and 20- 25 year old boxes of Federal , Western ,or Peters Slugs, 00 Buck, and #6 shot - that this guns shoots really really well- these folks are going to be able to use the gun, the ammo and take care of whatever needs taken care of.
I hope that answers the messages I rec'd and perhaps assists some others.
Steve