Decisions, decisions (trade my 5-shot 500 for a 8 shot 500?)

Status
Not open for further replies.

MacTech

Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2008
Messages
774
Location
Sector ZZ9 Plural Z Alpha
I have a Mossy 500C, had it for ages, it's the one gun that's evaded my "tradeitin-itis", 28" Mod. AccuChoke barrel, 5 shot tube, and some really nice wood furniture, I bought it at least 20+ years ago, it was used but in mint condition, I haven't shot it all that much, as I've been more into handguns and rifles, but I can feel myself leaning more towards the shotgun side now as well

It's a great gun, 100% reliable, so reliable in fact that I forget it's there, I know it'll work every time, I trust my life to it (thankfully, I live in a low-to-nonexistent crime area, the most I've "killed" with it are clay targets)

That said, there are a couple of minor annoyances with it;
it only holds 5 shells
the barrel is too long for HD
the pump has a lot of side to side "rickety-ness" to it

That said, the pump action is buttered-teflon-coated-ball-bearing smooth...

I had been planning to get an 18.5" barrel for it, as that would solve my biggest annoyance with it, so I stopped by my LGS to check out the used/new barrels, while I was there, I spied another 500 that had just been traded in, it had "carbon-fiber-look" poly furniture on it, an 18.5" barrel, and most importantly, what appeared to be a 8 round tube mag

I took a closer look at it, it pointed well, felt comfortable, and there was just the slightest amount of surface rust spotting on the barrel, 000 steel wool would easily remove it without harming the bluing, it also had a far less "rattly" pump action side-to-side, however, the pump action was less smooth than my 500

Thing is, I'm not a fan of the poly furniture, and the barrel is cylinder bore, however, it *does* have the 8-9 shot capacity I like

I'm a little tempted to trade, I'd get a tighter pump and ?3? more rounds in the tube, but I'd lose my nice wood furniture and the versatility of two barrels (for now, i could always buy a 28" barrel for the poly furniture 500), plus, I have no idea of the reliability of that 500, mine is utterly reliable

So, I have to ask myself, is it worth it to gain three rounds of capacity, but lose the wood furniture and utility of two barrels? plus, I kinda' like the fact that this 500 has been with me the longest, I'd feel bad trading out of a gun I've owned for 20+ years, even if I haven't shot it that much, then again, the 8 shot 500's seem hard to find, this is the first one I've seen in a long time

My options are;
1; get the 18.5" barrel for my wood-furniture 5 shot 500
2; trade my 500 for the 8 shot poly furniture 500

Ideally a third option would be to trade the 5 shot for the 8 shot, then swap the furniture, but I highly doubt the LGS would do that, plus, I'd still be down a barrel (no 28" hunting barrel)

Hmm, what to do, what to do, is the extra capacity worth the trade....
 
2 things

#1 - Good luck getting an even trade on yours versus the 8 shot model. I don't see that happening. The Home Defense guns are in higher demand. You will have to pay some money with your trade.

#2 - another barrel is cheap. You know the gun and trust it. Why get one that you don't know about? You will still have a more versatile set up.
 
That's the way I'm leaning right now, down the road if I *really* want the increased capacity, I can simply order a Persuader mag tube and barrel from Brownells

that way I'd have a wood-stocked 8 shot 500, do they make Persuader pattern barrels in longer lengths, or could I have my existing barrel re-lugged to Persuader length?
 
So how much is the short Mossy? Why not just buy it and swap out stocks? You can put the parts you don't like into another gun and sell it.
 
Well, I used up some store credit, and got the 18.5" barrel, and I love it, my old faithful 500 looks and feels like a new gun, it points and balances so much better with the short barrel, with the 28" it was barrel heavy, but with the 18.5, it balances and points perfectly

Now, to hit the range on Sunday and see how this new barrel patterns

I never realized how versatile the 500 is, oh sure, I knew about the shorter barrels and rifled slug barrels, but what I didn't expect was that Mossberg actually makes a muzzleloader kit for it, and I've been wanting to try black powder for a long time, the muzzleloader barrel kit looks to be a great way for me to get started
 
MacTech I'm about to take the plunge on an 18" barrel for my 870. Glad you turned out happy with your new barrel
 
MacTech;
Good for you! It is the kind of change that puts a dopey smile on your face, doesn't it? It really is a different gun now. BTW, the 500 will also hold 5 rounds of 3" American made MAGNUMS!

Just note: the 18 1/2" Open Cylinder is an ideal HD gun and so is optimally employed at 15 meters and 30 max with the right ammo...

Al
 
The more I handle my shorty 500, the more I like it, it's probably going to share HD duties with my Kimber Custom II .45ACP 1911, I just hope to Og that I'm never pressed ino using any of my firearms defensively, so far, so good, i've been a shooter for 30+ years, and not once have I encountered a situation where I would have needed a defensive weapon of any sort...

I'd also imagine if I *did* have to use "Shorty" defensively, the fact that it's a wood-stocked absolutely bone-stock (aside from the shorter barrel) gun with no "scary" tactic-cool crud on it to scare non-firearms-types (it looks like Grandpa's old hunting gun) is a point in it's favor

the 8 shot "Persuader" has "scary" looking poly furniture, a mag tube as long as the barrel, and a "scary" name (to NFT)

Of course *we* all know all this is meaningless....

How does a Cylinder choke work for trapshooting, or for rifled slugs?, I'd imagine I'd get better results with my original 28" vent-rib barrel, the 18.5 is mainly for HD/close up work, I'd imagine
 
Mac...;
U imagine correctly. It is useless for Trap. Skeet maybe -- that's about it in clay safe shooting sports. Rifled slugs? Yup, it'll work fine though Improved Cylinder tend to be a little more accurate. Forget the more modern bolt ons -- what you've got is the bee's knees. Now you want to practice with it...
Al
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top