Don't quite understand different frame sizes...

Status
Not open for further replies.

ANDROTAZ

Member
Joined
May 2, 2008
Messages
55
OK fellas, forgive my ignorance in this matter, but I just can't come to grasp what is meant by J, K, L, N, and X frame revolvers. I know that J is small, K and L are medium, N is large, and X is extra large, but just what exactly is referred to by "size of the frame?"

Sorry guys, I tried to figure it out through research, but I just didn't find much.
 
You pretty much summed it up yourself. They are just arbitrary S&W designations for the different frame sizes on their revolvers. The frame is the main part of the revolver, and the frame window is where the cylinder is located.
 
OK...a couple more things then. Is S&W really the only company that uses these designations, or do people use them regularly to designate wheel guns from other companies? And does it just refer to how big the overall frame is, or more the thickness or something else of the frame? Thanks a lot for the reply, man.
 
Those are Smith designations. Some people use them to identify other makers gun size. It refers to the overall size of the revolver's frame. Some makers just use small, medium, and large. Other makers can confuse you as they can use the same letters but have them mean something different. An example is the Smith's J frame is a small frame while the Colt's J frame is one of their medium frames.
 
OK. J-frame traditionally meant 5-shot 38Spl, more recently 5-shot 357, plus a lot were set up as six-shot .32 or up to 9-shot 22LR or 8-shot 22Magnum. Most shipped with 2" barrels.

K-frame was originally a six-shot 38Spl, later upgraded to a somewhat strength-marginal 357. Also shipped in .22 and the occasional oddity.

L-frame was meant as a tougher 357 than the K-frame, originally six-shot, later seven-shot.

N-frame was originally 44Spl, some shipped in 45LC or 45ACP, then the very first 357 shipped with it. It was then the platform for the 44Mag. Most recent setup is 8-shot 357.

X-Frame is the newest, for the 500S&WMagnum.

Now. If anything else from another vendor is able to eat from a speedloader similar to one of the above, we'll sometimes call it a "whatever-class". Taurus has a habit of very closely copying S&W sizes. Ruger often varies in terms of heft, but will often take the same speedloaders as an S&W. So the SP101 eats from J-frame speedloaders, the Redhawk and SuperRedhawk eat from N-frame loaders and I seem to recall the GP100 is more or less L-frame although not quite perfect. And the out-of-production Service/Security/Speed Six series were "k-class" (although a bit tougher).

And so on. Basically, the S&W sizes are a good starting point for judging anything else, while speedloader compatibility is an objective standard of comparison.
 
Jim March said:
OK. J-frame traditionally meant 5-shot 38Spl, more recently 5-shot 357, plus a lot were set up as six-shot .32 or up to 9-shot 22LR or 8-shot 22Magnum. Most shipped with 2" barrels.

Just one minor amendment to what Jim said (unless I'm mistaken, which is also quite possible), but the Smith J-frame topped out at 8 shots for the .22 Long Rifle also.
 
Just one minor amendment to what Jim said (unless I'm mistaken, which is also quite possible), but the Smith J-frame topped out at 8 shots for the .22 Long Rifle also.

Huh. That could be...I'm not the end-all in the more exotic S&Ws. I know that High Standard, Taurus and others managed to cram nine 22LRs into a "J-class" package, I guess I assumed that S&W did too.

22Magnum shells are fatter and those top out at eight for a J-sized critter. Pretty sure S&W made an 8-gun in 22Maggie.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top