Mr Ross and Mr Bracken...

Status
Not open for further replies.

thefitzvh

Member
Joined
Oct 9, 2003
Messages
989
Location
Austin, TX
I'd like to give a little response to both Mr. Ross' "Unintended Consequences" and Mr. Bracken's "Enemies Foreign and Domestic." I figure since they both post here, they'd probably read it.

The nature of my duty in Iraq means that abou 1% of my time is mayhem, and the other 99% is sheer boredom. I regretfully admit that boredom was my sole motivator for FINALLY picking up these two books and reading them. I'm ashamed now to admit that my only reason for reading them was that I ran out of guitar magazines, and a friend of mine had both books. I read some of EFAD about a year ago, but never finished.

I pray that your books will be remembered as mere fantasy... given history, however, including the handling of the Katrina fiasco, I have to admit that they may be remembered in an almost prophetic light.

Both books are wonderfully written, and a chilling reminder of the dangerous direction our Gub'mint is going. During Harry's rant in the middle of UC, I became so furious that my knuckles were white from being clenched so hard. Not because the book itself was angering me, but because it was all true, and all so damned horrible.

I hope that more people read your books, gentlemen, and truly take to heart what you've written.

You've both obviously put a lot of work into these books, and it shows. Again, i'm sorry I missed them for so long.

One thing I especially liked was the positive portrayal of many military members in EFAD, including the LTCDR who stood up at the FIST checkpoint to defend the man who was being assaulted by the agent. There are other examples in the book as well. You clearly conveyed an image of honorable military men, who sometimes had to do horrible things in order to defeat horrible people, and you also portrayed federal law enforcement adopting those same tactics. The difference, which you made apparent, is that those old SF vets had a war to fight, and the ATF goons were waging their own private war against our own...

I apologize if I'm rambling, but I read both books, almost nonstop, over the past 5 days. I couldn't put them down, and they've had quite an emotional response for me.

Thank you both for reminding me of things that no proper American should forget. I only pray that one day my kids (assuming i have them) can look back and laugh at their old paranoid dad for his crazy theories.

On a lighter note: I have a nicely bound hardcover copy of UC, but only a paperback of EFAD... And, to be quite honest, it fell apart rather quickly. I was wondering, Mr. Bracken, if you had any plans to release your book in hardcover? I'd love to own a handsome hardcover version to put on my shelf in the computer room when I get home. I also have a tendency to over-read books, and hardcovers tend to last better through my obsessive re-reads.

Thanks guys, I loved the books. I'm looking forward to reading the EFAD sequel.
 
I believe EFAD was all paperback, but maybe since you're in Iraq Matt will send you a signed copy. :D I love that book (and UC) and have to get Matt's new one.
 
Nah, I'd hate to have it ruined. The place I'm at is not very good for books. The dust and grime gets all over everything. LOL
 
I pray that your books will be remembered as mere fantasy... given history, however, including the handling of the Katrina fiasco, I have to admit that they may be remembered in an almost prophetic light.
Want prophetic? Try Vin Suprynowicz' Black Arrow...

A book in the same veign as UC and EFAD but set a bit further in the future.

Of the three I consider Black Arrow as having the best story, UC being the most riveting and EFAD to be the one with the situation most likely to occur.

All are excellent and worth every penny. UC ought to be required reading in every HS Civics class (is Civics even required to be a HS Grad any more? Some how I doubt it).
 
Werewolf, In my case civics was not a requirement for graduation, and I'm not even sure there was a civics/constitution class offered at my HS. :uhoh: :(

Wes
 
Not sure about now, but in 1970 civics was still a required course. I'd imagine that's not true anymore, it would get in the way of too much to have the citizens know their rights and history.
 
In my high school Civics is a required course for gradutation and I still wouldn't want some of the people in my class voting
 
Werewolf

I've just got done about a week ago reading Matt Bracken's EFAD: enemies domestic, and if you think #1 is most likely, you will sh*$ your pants reading the second book.

Matt Bracken sent me the second one hand signed, and responded to a letter sent with my payment. After reading the book, I'd have to say that because of the likelihood of the second book's scenario, I'm wondering how many people read this, because if you live in one of the states mentioned, I would make contingency plans for the scenario to happen.

As for UC, I have many criticisms. While I liked the message, and enjoyed the book, I thought the results were not at all likely. With all the power the fedgov has gathered, there is no easy way out of this mess for the people using the 2A. It would be far bloodier, and more horrible than John Ross makes it out using the methods he describes in the book. I still think this can be done without the cartridge box, but that won't exactly be easy either.
 
Howdy Fitz,
Thanks for the kind words about my first novel, it means a lot to me. As far as the book falling apart, I'm guessing you have a first edition, from the very first print run. It was made on fairly slick but stiff paper, which didn't want to bend and lay open. When pushed apart, sometimes it overstressed the binding and split. The last three edition have been made with a more supple and softer paper, and I haven't heard any more reports of split bindings.
 
That sounds about like what happened.

I'll get another one when I get back to the states... but i still say a handsome hardover edition is a good idea :) I like displaying books
 
As for UC, I have many criticisms. While I liked the message, and enjoyed the book, I thought the results were not at all likely. With all the power the fedgov has gathered, there is no easy way out of this mess for the people using the 2A. It would be far bloodier, and more horrible than John Ross makes it out using the methods he describes in the book. I still think this can be done without the cartridge box, but that won't exactly be easy either.

I think Mr. Ross agrees with you -- this can still be done without the cartridge box. That's exactly what he said in the section titled "Author's Note -- A Warning and Disclaimer." His point was that "stripping motivated people of their dignity and rubbing their noses in it is a very bad idea... Today in America, honest, successful, talented, productive, motivated people are once again being stripped of their freedom and dignity and having their noses rubbed in it. The conflict has been building for over half a century, and once again warning flags are frantically waving while the instigators rush headlong towards the abyss, and their doom."

I'm also going to respectfully disagree with you. I think much of what happens in Unintended Consequences is very possible, and the ending is possible IMO, depending on who is in the White House. I don't think the ending is likely if you picture GWB as the president in UC -- any action on the part of fed-up patriots would now be labeled as terrorism -- but I do think it's possible otherwise.

Respectfully,
Wes :)
 
If anybody lives in Colorado who can tune in Denver's KHOW 630, I'll be on the Peter Boyle Show Wednesday morning to discuss my books. Boyle is an anti-gun lib, but he's also strongly against the illegal alien invasion. So for my two books it's a split decision....should be interesting.
 
If anybody lives in Colorado who can tune in Denver's KHOW 630, I'll be on the Peter Boyle Show Wednesday morning to discuss my books. Boyle is an anti-gun lib, but he's also strongly against the illegal alien invasion. So for my two books it's a split decision....should be interesting.

KHOW streams over the internet; I just connected, so I don't know if Matt has been on yet or not...

EDIT: Stand down...He's already been on.

Sawdust
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top