Same or Different?

Status
Not open for further replies.

lizziedog1

Member
Joined
Dec 31, 2010
Messages
942
Location
The Silver State
I know that that there are many shooters that like carrying a handgun and a rifle chambered for the same round. One positive mentioned is that it simplifies ammo carry. No doubt.

On the other hand, doesn't that impose a limit on versatility?

If one is walking around the woods with a 357 magnum carbine and a 357 magnum six-gun, doesn't he have two guns that pretty much duplicate each other?

Yes, the long gun increases velocity and makes longer hits easier. But both are still roughly in the same use category.

Lets say the guy with the 357 magnum revolver changes his long gun to a 22 rimfire rifle. Now he does need to carry two different types of ammo. But, he has two guns that cover differrent applications. His rifle can be used for varmints, small game, even plinking. His revovler comes into play for more serious applications.

Or lets turn it around. A 357 magnum rifle teamed up with a rimfire pistol. The rifle can be used for things up to deer size at reasonble ranges. And if a self-defense against a humanoid arises, you have great weapon of discouragement. Now if the person sees a squirrel on a branch, he has a gun, the 22, to take a shot at it. Nothing wrong with using a 357, but if table fare is the goal, the 22 would be a better choice.

Sorry about the ramble.

But if I am going out and decide to take a long gun and a handgun, I try to make them different. Yes, I'll have to carry tow diffeent types of amm. But, I'll have two guns that will have more use.

Anyone on my side?
 
Yeah, I don't see the point of matched rifle/pistol rounds either. I don't hunt but, if I did, I'd carry a hunting rifle in an appropriate caliber for the game and a handgun appropriate for whatever self-defense needs may occur. E.G: I might carry a .30-30 rifle with SP ammo for whitetail deer and a .44 Mag revolver with heavy hard-cast LFN for defense against black bear... bear spray too.
 
If you want something better for HD, a carbine is not a bad choice over your pistol.

If it is for two very different applications, well, that's why we have pockets :D
 
It's just a cool factor and I don't mean that in a bad way. A 45 lever gun 45 on the hip on your horse( 4 wheeler for most) hunting whitetail is great.
 
For years I felt the same ammo for both was needed. Course, my eyes were great then and I could shoot a lever gun with open sights. I am almost 70 and I need glasses which means a scope. And sitting in a blind, weight is not a serious consideration. I have a Win. M70 in 30-06 which suits me to the ground. So for a side arm, a DA 44 special is my weapon of choice. For everything.

I have 3.

Charter Arms Bulldog, 3"
Taurus 441, 4"
S&W M21, 4".

Not to mention the Colt SAA's.

Now, I have the best of both worlds.
 
I've got four 1894 Marlins, Two carbines and two Cowboy action rifles. Both in two of my favorite pistol calibers .357mag and .41mag. I'm lucky the all four will chamber and feed reliably .38spl and .41spl. Also Marlin's stock design and size fit me like they were fitted.

In the ranges that I encounter in Tenn. They do quit well.

For the tactical guys I have a Colt AR in 9mm and an Oly in .45ACP.

I've been a fan of pairs since the first western book I read.

As the say, just my 2c

Cheers,

ts
 
I like that the carbine mags fit in the pistol.
dsc03164h.jpg
 
It depends on why you're in the woods.

If nothing is in season and it's not the EOTWAWKI, then does it matter?
 
Yeah, I don't see the point of matched rifle/pistol rounds either.
It made more sense in 1880, when you had to live out of your horses saddle bags for extended periods of time.

I have four "matched pairs" in .22, .22 WMR, 32-20 WCF, and .44 Spl/.44 Mag.

But other then the .22's, I seldom if ever carry both at the same time.
When I carry a centerfire rifle here in Kansas, it needs to be coyote accurate at several hundred yards.

rc
 
We won the west with that combination and there is not a lot of difference between living out of sadlebags and a rucksack. If your hunting, then bring a caliber in a rifle that corresponds to the game. I bought my carbine because it was an inexpensive way to practice rifle skills.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top