Maybe, maybe not. There are lots of other factors involved such as speed, jacket thickness, etc. The only real way to find out is to shoot them into something. For big tough anilmals like elk, I would prefer the slower expanding bullet.
I mentioned shape because some rifles will not function with all shapes. My AR10 is a good example of that. It was designed for pointed bullets and is almost guaranteed to jam with blunt shapes such as round nose or flat point.
That was my reasoning for choosing the spire point because I didn't want to mess with two different styles of 180 gr Partitions.
If I ever have lots of time on my hands, it might be fun to experiment with penetration of different shapes.