So I started a Youtube channel... any tips advice or criticism

Status
Not open for further replies.

lobo9er

Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2009
Messages
3,457
Location
Earth, Currently
So just finishing uploading my first youtube videos. I am going to do videos on stuff I like so naturally gun videos will be part of my channel. I just have a phone for making them so I can already tell audio will be an issue but what ever I had fun doing it I hope to make many more and any suggestion THR is always my go to when it comes to all that is gun stuff. So I thought this would be a good spot looking for help when making Gun videos and maybe there would be interest here in general.
thanks in advance.

Heres a link
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCwxXcYYdh1Vvpv9dDInQJvw
 
So just finishing uploading my first youtube videos. I am going to do videos on stuff I like so naturally gun videos will be part of my channel. I just have a phone for making them so I can already tell audio will be an issue but what ever I had fun doing it I hope to make many more and any suggestion THR is always my go to when it comes to all that is gun stuff. So I thought this would be a good spot looking for help when making Gun videos and maybe there would be interest here in general.
thanks in advance.

Heres a link
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCwxXcYYdh1Vvpv9dDInQJvw
Not so much just for my benefit, but for anyone in general, please clear the gun first thing on camera, set your phone down, and show us it's safe, don't just pull the trigger, I'm teaching my kids proper safety and if there's ever an accident because they decided this is acceptable, I'll be pissed to an immeasurable extent. Otherwise, you could offer a few more details, you say you shoot the pistol at 10-20 yds but you don't say what kind of accuracy you get, ammo brand pickiness? Your hand seems to be close to my size, does the slide ever "bite" you? I'm a chainsaw wd40 guy myself. I appreciate what you're doing, keep it up!
 
Not so much just for my benefit, but for anyone in general, please clear the gun first thing on camera, set your phone down, and show us it's safe, don't just pull the trigger, I'm teaching my kids proper safety and if there's ever an accident because they decided this is acceptable, I'll be pissed to an immeasurable extent. Otherwise, you could offer a few more details, you say you shoot the pistol at 10-20 yds but you don't say what kind of accuracy you get, ammo brand pickiness? Your hand seems to be close to my size, does the slide ever "bite" you? I'm a chainsaw wd40 guy myself. I appreciate what you're doing, keep it up!
thank you, all good points. thank you for watching and checking it out. I have watched countless gun related youtube videos but actually making one even a short one was little harder than I expected.
 
I've had a channel since about 2010. Put considerable effort and time into it. 2 million+ video views, roughly 2,000 subscribers. Which is nothing. Here are my tips.

1. Don't expect to make any money. If you like making videos and helping the community then go ahead. But you probably won't make a cent particularly since YouTube screwed over the gun community and removed google ads from any firearms related content.
2. Get a tripod for your camera. No matter how steady you are someone will always complain about handheld.
3. Be brief and specific and engaging.
4. Try to create unique content rather than just another me-too review of a popular gun.
5. People prefer to see your face rather than have you talking from behind the camera.

Good luck! :)
 
When you do clear a firearm on camera, make sure you state why you're doing it (for the benefit of habit-forming among young or otherwise-impressionable viewers.) Otherwise, be ready to handle snarky remarks in your comments section about how the viewer is happy you didn't risk shooting him through the camera. I can't count the number of such asinine comments I've seen on YouTube gun videos.
 
I like the Lucky Gunner Lounge. Why? Because he posts a transcript that I can read faster and with better comprehension than I can see and hear in amateur video.
 
I've had a channel since about 2010. Put considerable effort and time into it. 2 million+ video views, roughly 2,000 subscribers. Which is nothing. Here are my tips.

1. Don't expect to make any money. If you like making videos and helping the community then go ahead. But you probably won't make a cent particularly since YouTube screwed over the gun community and removed google ads from any firearms related content.
2. Get a tripod for your camera. No matter how steady you are someone will always complain about handheld.
3. Be brief and specific and engaging.
4. Try to create unique content rather than just another me-too review of a popular gun.
5. People prefer to see your face rather than have you talking from behind the camera.

Good luck! :)
Well your farther ahead than me by far. All points taken thank you. Revenue generating isn't my concern but I didn't know that about ads and gun related videos, is gun related videos or gun related channels? Just wondering. 2000 subscribers is pretty cool though you have 2000 people that want to hear what you have to say. Post a link I would like to check it out.
 
Not bad. 1KPerday has a lot of good points.

My only bit of advice is:
Don't tell us what video you were *going to make* just tell us about *this* video.

Might sound harsh, but audiences don't care about what was almost reality... They clicked on this vid because it interested them. Not the "was gonna make a vid about" stuff.

Also:
Excellent taste in knives.
I got my wife the 940 and I carry the 710.
 
Well your farther ahead than me by far. All points taken thank you. Revenue generating isn't my concern but I didn't know that about ads and gun related videos, is gun related videos or gun related channels? Just wondering. 2000 subscribers is pretty cool though you have 2000 people that want to hear what you have to say. Post a link I would like to check it out.
any video with firearms related content is now "restricted" content as of a couple of months ago. Restricted content can not contain google ads. They claim they were losing important advertisers who were upset that their ads and links were being featured on firearms related videos. YouTube did lose a grundle of money the past couple of years so they're scrambling to cowtow to advertisers.
My channel is jeffshootsstuff
I was only making about $40 a month but it bought a couple boxes of ammo. I spent much more on making videos than I ever made. Muuuuch more. I didn't start out intending to make revenue but after a while YouTube thought I was popular enough to monetize.
 
any video with firearms related content is now "restricted" content as of a couple of months ago. Restricted content can not contain google ads. They claim they were losing important advertisers who were upset that their ads and links were being featured on firearms related videos. YouTube did lose a grundle of money the past couple of years so they're scrambling to cowtow to advertisers.
My channel is jeffshootsstuff
I was only making about $40 a month but it bought a couple boxes of ammo. I spent much more on making videos than I ever made. Muuuuch more. I didn't start out intending to make revenue but after a while YouTube thought I was popular enough to monetize.
So YOU'RE jeffshootsstuff...

Cool. Nice to put a user name to a channel.

ETA: you were one of my earliest subscribers.
 
That's a good plan. Regular content uploads help boost viewership and YouTube rankings and recommendations. Weekly would be better if you can pull it off. I tried for a while but life gets busy. Mostly I do it because I'm a visual learner and I appreciate watching videos to learn disassembly or minor gunsmithing or shooting tips. A few of my videos are unique content wise and have quite a few views. Then some I thought would do better didn't get many views. You never know what's going to get popular. Just make videos you'd like to see and that might help someone out or be fun or interesting to watch. Then even if you don't get big on YouTube you'll still be a useful contributor to the firearms community in general. I've gotten many sincere thanks for a few of my how to videos as there is no other video resource out there for some content.
 
So just finishing uploading my first youtube videos. I am going to do videos on stuff I like so naturally gun videos will be part of my channel. I just have a phone for making them so I can already tell audio will be an issue but what ever I had fun doing it I hope to make many more and any suggestion THR is always my go to when it comes to all that is gun stuff. So I thought this would be a good spot looking for help when making Gun videos and maybe there would be interest here in general.
thanks in advance.

Heres a link
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCwxXcYYdh1Vvpv9dDInQJvw
1. Use "spell check" before posting.
2. Try and be different, state facts and sources, if stating opinions, try and explain the rational behind "why"*. Most "you-tubers" just regurgitate "stuff they heard".

________________________
* "...because I like it..." is a perfectly acceptable rational, just as long as you let people know it's your opinion.
 
Gotta work on improving your content. That's the kind of video I immediately skip if it comes up in a search or play list.

5. People prefer to see your face rather than have you talking from behind the camera.

Talking hands videos never do as well as talking heads - which is naturally something which either kills a channel, or makes one. You seem to have a marketable and relatable speaking style, so unless you're "hiding behind the camera," come out in front of it. If you ARE hiding behind the camera - which is fine - then a channel probably isn't for you. Some people want to be "famous," some people want to remain private. I've worked with folks on multiple channels, but I don't really care to have much content out there blasting my face (and potentially name), just on the off chance it may come up later on in life during job interviews, or maybe a self-defense shooting court case, or legal deposition or professional/expert testimonial. So I don't go in front of the camera, and have decided to only work behind the camera - not seen, not heard, and paid even less than the guys in front of the lens most of the time.

3. Be brief and specific and engaging.

I agree - and I'd say the video I watched was brief because you didn't have anything of any real substance to say. It wasn't particularly specific, and for me, wasn't at all engaging. What I saw was a dirty workbench (or kitchen cabinet with cardboard and a towel for protection?), so like I said - that's the kind of thing I skip. It might be one thing to show your workbench with one project over here, then move onto another more engaging topic, but the big red banner of a chainsaw in the background is distracting.

You also didn't ever cycle the pistol, didn't demonstrate any function of the manual safety, didn't visibly display the laser output (obligatory blast out of the sensor by pointing it at the camera)... What did you demonstrate of the pistol other than a moving picture and a couple trigger pulls?

4. Try to create unique content rather than just another me-too review of a popular gun.

This is something which always jumps out at me.

I've heard a common quip in different business communication and marketing courses/seminars/classes/etc which I believe is applicable for online social media content:

W.A.I.T.
Why Am I Talking?

Which is effectively followed by this type of flow chart:

Better-Meeting-Rules-FlowChart-WAIT-Why-Am-I-Talking.jpg


Since this is youtube, you can somewhat eliminate the "is it time to do that?" and "is it my turn?" decision blocks in the flow chart - somewhat... Sometimes the "is it time to do that?" question can be very important. I use a modified version of this flow chart for content discussions for the youtubers and social media "wanna be" stars with which I work - we put the "is it time to do that?" at the end, such we always consider the appropriate timing for the drop; most of the time, immediate release makes sense, sometimes it doesn't. "Is it my turn?" I replace with - "am I qualified to present this?" I worked with a guy a few years ago who fancied himself an expert bow tech - he'd owned two bows, and I had been his bowtech for any even minor issue for both of them. So when he came to me with a bunch of videos to review and edit of him doing bowtech tasks, it didn't take long for me to convince him he had to reshoot everything. People love the "couch to a 10k" or "my first marathon" type stories, so an underqualified person coming out HONESTLY and showing themselves learning is an easy sell. But a "let me teach you this thing I barely know myself" video tends not to make it very far. So don't disregard these decision blocks - is it the right time for this video? and am I the right person to make this video?

Why did you make the video? Why are you talking? There are a ton of S&W BG380 videos out there, the majority of them with better content and production quality - so if you find yourself on the righthand path, you would hit the "did someone make this contribution already?" and would have answered "yes," looping you back to a "stop talking" action. If you had a strong opinion or stance on the product, or had something really important to say (which hadn't been contributed already), as in taking the left hand path in the decision tree above, then sure - make a duplicate video on top of hundreds of others - but I don't hear that strong opinion or important information.

Alternatively - speaking about a comparison between the original laser and the CT replacement might have made a VERY interesting video - if you could have been specific enough and demonstrated both side by side, to make the video content more engaging.

Hard pass on the rest - keep trying, but I'd want you to up your game a long ways before I watched another one.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top