The Great Dryer Sheet Experiment

Status
Not open for further replies.

Mohave-Tec

Member
Joined
May 28, 2013
Messages
557
Location
Las Vegas
I use 70% crushed walnut and 30% corn cob in my tumbler. I use half a cap of Nu-Finish in a fresh batch of media. I buy my media at pet stores. It is ground to a size that easily vacates a 223 case mouth in a media/case separator after tumbling. OK, with modest variations, almost everybody who dry tumbles does this.
But I've never used dryer sheets. I think that long ago I used a new dryer sheet and decided dryer sheets were a mistake. I don't recall but for some reason I chose to not use dryer sheets.
Well, I collect range brass by the thousands and tumble about 100 maximum capacity loads a year. When I'm done tumbling and subsequently separating media from the tumbled cases, I place all that load in a lightly damp towel, grasp the two ends of the towel and rocked the two ends, suspended. up and down to "dust" the cases off. Works great. But the older my media is the more dust I collect on my white towel. Yesterday I noticed my towel was getting really dirty. It was raining so I did an experiment.
My walnut is brown and my corn cob is light green but the media mix was grey in my tumbler. Obviously it was saturated with spent case muck and pulverized walnut. I thought "what-the-heck" since this load of media was spent and needed replacing that I'd give the dryer sheet thing a chance. I had a bunch of spent sheets in a small waste basket beside the dryer. I tore 2 of them in half and dumped it in the tumbler and turned it on with the lid off. In two minutes the dryer sheet halves were filthy. I pulled then out as the surfaced and put two more sheets in. They too became filthy quickly. I repeated this 5 or 6 times in a half hours space and stood over the tumbler watching this the entire time. Most interesting. But I did not expect to see what I saw. First, the spent dryer sheets were less dirty as I progressed to a 5th or 6th new batch of spent sheets. Makes sense. But my media was no longer grey, rather the corn cob started turning green again and I was starting to better see individual walnut fragments again. The dryer sheets were actually mopping up the individual media pieces. I had no idea this would be so effective.
So, the media still wears out. The corn cob was roughly the same size as when I put it in the original mix but the walnut was markably smaller and obviously being ground down over time. But still, there was walnut abrasive left in the mix.
I brought home about 5 full load batches of brass Saturday. I tumbled 4 loads and it took 4 hours a load to clean them up. I tumbled a fifth load from the same batch of brass and it clean up in 1.5 hours. The difference between the dirty media and the still old but mopped up media and its ability to do work is as night and day.
I'm probably going to toss this batch of media anyway because the walnut pieces are so small, I've done maybe 30 full loads with it and I have many pounds of this cheap media but I am absolutely going to start using the dryer sheets in my process.
Just thought I'd report on what you guys already know but thought you might be interested in hearing about my absolutely gaugible results from this experiment.
Since I still have this old but cleaned up media batch, I think I'll do one more load before I switch to new media and see how much dust I get on my damp white towels. I didn't pay attention yesterday but I did clean out my media separator before my last load yesterday and after separating the last load I had virtually no dust in my case/media separator.
And there you have it in a nutshell!!!
 
We do not use dryer sheets in the laundry so I use the blue paper shop towels with a little spray wax on them. Accomplishes the same thing.

But I also buy media in 50 lb bags and spend the $.29 cents to actually change it when it's dirty and no longer sharp edges;)
 
Mohave-Tec,
You will find your media will stay cleaner and the dust will be all but eliminated if you use a dryer sheet in the mix each time you tumble a load. I cut 1 sheet into 4 pieces and use a cut up sheet in almost every batch. Works well for me...
 
This brings up a question I've been meaning to ask: does anyone know if there's a difference in performance between used and new dryer sheets? We don't use dryer sheets in our dryer, but I've been tossing a new, anti-static sheet in my corncob media for years now. I use the fine corncob from Drillspot, and I prefer new sheets for their anti-static properties (my tumbling area has very low humidity, and those little corncob particles tend to pick up a lot of static without the sheets).

So, why does everyone specify used dryer sheets for tumbling? Are new ones just as effective, or should I be running these things through the dryer first?
 
Because the used dryer sheets catch much more dust.
My wife doesn't use them either, but every once in a while I buy the cheapest box I can find and slip a couple in the dryer occasionally. I have a Folgers can pretty well full of them.
 
1. It's wasteful to use new dryer sheets. Fabric softener isn't doing anything for the brass or media but could be for you laundry.

2. More importantly, the pores or spaces between the fibers of the sheet are full of fabric softener on a new one & that's where the dust collects to get mopped up. With the fabric softener gone on a used sheet it can collect the dust.

3. The used sheet isn't as stiff and can move around more - potentially doing more 'wiping'
 
I've used odorless mineral spirits... A few drops into the walnut media while it is running. Then I let it run a little bit more to spread the mineral spirits around.

I've done all three at the same time: NuFinish, used dryer sheets, and mineral spirits.

It all helps keep the dust down.
 
I use 70% crushed walnut and 30% corn cob in my tumbler. I use half a cap of Nu-Finish in a fresh batch of media. I buy my media at pet stores. It is ground to a size that easily vacates a 223 case mouth in a media/case separator after tumbling. OK, with modest variations, almost everybody who dry tumbles does this.

Interesting post, confirming the worth of used dryer sheets!

One observation. I think you'd be better off with either 100% corncob, or 100% walnut. You can't polish to corn cob shininess as long as you rough them up with any amount of walnut. That's like sanding with 400 grit sandpaper, then adding some scratches with 240 grit.

On the other hand any less than 100% walnut is adulterated walnut...less efficient at cleaning and cutting, which is walnut's forte.

Now an hour or two with 100% walnut....to clean, followed by another 2 or 3 hours with 100% corncob, to polish the cleaned brass would work........or........ you could just polish with 100% corncob impregnated with metal polish for 8 hours while you are at work and be done with it. Just my opinion of course.

Another plus to corncob.....white smooth almost lubricating dust and less of it.
 
Last edited:
New dryer sheets put a weird film on the brass.
Personally, I don't like it, but that's just MHO.

YMMV
You got that right!:D I made the mistake of using a new one once. Whata mess. It leaves a sticky glop on the brass. It was hard to remove. Think I used mineral spirits and wiped every single one.:eek:
 
Guys, I think the "new" dryer sheet is why I never used dryer sheets. I think I did the new sheet the first time I put a sheet in my tumbler and now that I think of it, it contaminated my batch of media. It even mucked up the bowl. Just one of those miss-lead happenstances that stuck. I am a converted "used" dryer sheet guy now. LOL.
 
Great thread

...and well-documented test and results.

I've been using the used drier sheets since I started tumbling brass (about six years) but never did a test such as yours.

The whole drier sheet exercise is very satisfying because it takes an item that was formerly fit only for disposal and re-uses it. Something for nothing, and green-friendly too. A win-win. :)

Again, well done.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top