USAF_Vet
Member
My favorite LGS always has a nice supply and selection of low priced used scatter guns. Since 5.56/.223 and 9mm are still in short supply, I'm in the mood for a new (to me) shotgun, where I can always find ammo.
I've got single shot and pump action covered. So I'm looking into semi-auto and double barrels, just to cover my bases.
So, of these (sorry, no pics yet), help me decide which is the best for my money.
Semi Autos:
REMINGTON 40 12GA $199.50
REMINGTON 48 12GA $249.50
REMINGTON 11-48 12GA $199.50
WINCHESTER 1400 12GA $249.50
Side by Side:
STEVENS 5100 12GA $249.50
SYR CASTING GUN NEW BAKER 10GA $199.50
I can't find anything on the Remington model 40, so that may be a typo on behalf of the LGS. i'll find out when I get there, I suppose.
The Rem model 48 I don't know much about either.
I understand the 11-48 was an improved version of the model 11, and the predecessor of the 1100 and 11-87. I'm a big fan of the 1100, and the manual of arms on the 11-48 is pretty similar. This is really my top pick, depending on condition. Aftermarket items like magazine extensions should be easy enough to come by.
Looks like the Winchester 1400 is pretty much a clone of the Remington 1100, or close enough to be considered a top contender.
If I go with a semi auto, the 11-48 is my pick.
The Stevens 5100 I briefly glanced at last time I was in, before I decided I wanted a new shotgun. Nice looking, locks up tight, obviously got some wear that's been come by honestly. Would probably make for a good woods gun.
I tossed the 10 gauge on the list for S&G, knowing I probably won't buy it. I haven't seen it first hand, so I don't know anything about it. It's there as an option if someone wants to convince me to get into 10 gauge shooting.
After writing and considering this post, I've got it narrowed down to the 11-48 and the 5100, unless someone can tell me more about the Remington model 40, or a good reason to pick the 48 over the 11-48.
I know a semi auto and a side by side are completely different animals, and comparing them is like comparing apples to rabid wombats. I can foresee the 11-48 as another HD gun, if accessorized with an extended mag tube. Sure, I'd casually bust clays with it, and possibly hunt with it as well. The 5100 I see as more of a range toy that I'd occasionally bust clays and hunt with, and probably not consider for HD purposes.
Yes, I know I could get both, but I've also got a new Taurus 709 slim waiting for me at the LGS. The wife would be less than thrilled with me coming home with three new guns. Two guns, I'll still feel some heat for it, but it's not coming out of the family budget (collecting scrap copper and selling off old hobby items I've lost interest in) so I'm not worried about it. I'll end up getting something else for her, too, just to ease the pain
So, what does the THR community think? Semi-auto first, or Side by Side? (cuz I'll probably end up with both at some point, just a matter of time).
I've got single shot and pump action covered. So I'm looking into semi-auto and double barrels, just to cover my bases.
So, of these (sorry, no pics yet), help me decide which is the best for my money.
Semi Autos:
REMINGTON 40 12GA $199.50
REMINGTON 48 12GA $249.50
REMINGTON 11-48 12GA $199.50
WINCHESTER 1400 12GA $249.50
Side by Side:
STEVENS 5100 12GA $249.50
SYR CASTING GUN NEW BAKER 10GA $199.50
I can't find anything on the Remington model 40, so that may be a typo on behalf of the LGS. i'll find out when I get there, I suppose.
The Rem model 48 I don't know much about either.
I understand the 11-48 was an improved version of the model 11, and the predecessor of the 1100 and 11-87. I'm a big fan of the 1100, and the manual of arms on the 11-48 is pretty similar. This is really my top pick, depending on condition. Aftermarket items like magazine extensions should be easy enough to come by.
Looks like the Winchester 1400 is pretty much a clone of the Remington 1100, or close enough to be considered a top contender.
If I go with a semi auto, the 11-48 is my pick.
The Stevens 5100 I briefly glanced at last time I was in, before I decided I wanted a new shotgun. Nice looking, locks up tight, obviously got some wear that's been come by honestly. Would probably make for a good woods gun.
I tossed the 10 gauge on the list for S&G, knowing I probably won't buy it. I haven't seen it first hand, so I don't know anything about it. It's there as an option if someone wants to convince me to get into 10 gauge shooting.
After writing and considering this post, I've got it narrowed down to the 11-48 and the 5100, unless someone can tell me more about the Remington model 40, or a good reason to pick the 48 over the 11-48.
I know a semi auto and a side by side are completely different animals, and comparing them is like comparing apples to rabid wombats. I can foresee the 11-48 as another HD gun, if accessorized with an extended mag tube. Sure, I'd casually bust clays with it, and possibly hunt with it as well. The 5100 I see as more of a range toy that I'd occasionally bust clays and hunt with, and probably not consider for HD purposes.
Yes, I know I could get both, but I've also got a new Taurus 709 slim waiting for me at the LGS. The wife would be less than thrilled with me coming home with three new guns. Two guns, I'll still feel some heat for it, but it's not coming out of the family budget (collecting scrap copper and selling off old hobby items I've lost interest in) so I'm not worried about it. I'll end up getting something else for her, too, just to ease the pain
So, what does the THR community think? Semi-auto first, or Side by Side? (cuz I'll probably end up with both at some point, just a matter of time).
