Shawnee
member
Your first and last .45 should be the Colt 1911 - preferably a Series 70 Gold Cup.
I was going to suggest a Sig Sauer P220 but you want American so I'd suggest a 1911.
Are there any decent 4'' 1911s out there that go for around $500-$600 instead of $1000+?
If I get a 1911 I will get the commander size, sense I want to be able to conceal carry it also. That's another reason why I like the p345. It is a surprisingly compact 8 round .45.