Why is it that "pistol" is supposed to refer to a semi-auto handgun?

Status
Not open for further replies.

albanian

member
Joined
Nov 27, 2003
Messages
1,902
Location
Indiana
I have heard people on this forum tell other memebers that it is incorrect to use the term "pistol" unless you are specifically talking about a semi-auto handgun. Where does this info come from? I have researched it and I can find no definition of pistol where it must be a semi-auto. It seems like pistol is just another word for handgun. A revolver is a revolver but a pistol can be either a semi-auto handgun or a revolver.

Someone correct me if I am wrong.
 
Once upon a time, all hand guns were referred to as "pistols." The first revolvers were known as "revolving pistols," and eventually became known as "revolvers." Nowadays, lots of people like to distinguish between revolvers and pistols; that doesn't, however, simplify matters, since reserving the term "pistols" for non-revolvers still wouldn't explain whether we're talking about single-shot pistols, semi-automatic pistols, bolt action pistols, et cetera.

All hand guns may still be referred to as "pistols." It's always a good idea to consider how words used to be used before trying to tell people how they ought and ought not be used.
 
I was always thinking of anyhing handheld as a pistol.

attachment.php


"Are you going to pull those pistols, or whistle Dixie?"

:)
 
"Are you going to pull those pistols, or whistle Dixie?" Sorry, Josey, I don't have any pistols, just a revolver. Well, I gotta go. Bye now!

(Great movie! The Outlaw Josey Wales)
 
You're not incorrect to call a revolver a pistol, but rather a little too vague for the taste of some people. Flint-lock pistols were pistols, then revolvers were pistols, and now automatics are pistols. Off the top of my head, the thing they all have in common is that they were designed to be fired with one hand. It's just a big family, but specifying revolver or semi-auto can make it clearer what a person is talking about.
 
terms

Along the same lines people incorrectly refer to a self cocking lock as a "double action only". The term double action refers to a lock that has two modes of action, manually cocked and self cocking. Since self cocking only revolvers are not all that common and were generally referred to as self cocking in days past this wasn't too big an issue until double action pistols became popular followed by self cocking pistols.

The term "bore" and "caliber" are synonomous, referring to the diameter of the hole "bored" in the barrel or the diameter from land to land if rifled. When a barrel is rifled, metal is removed, and the diameter from groove to groove is larger larger than the caliber or bore. So for a 30-06 or a 308 the bore or caliber is .300 and the groove diameter is .308. (Don't even thinbk of going into the names for different cartridges, it can only lead to insanity.)
 
I agree on the term "pistol"; it is perfectly proper to refer to any gun intended to be fired from one hand as a pistol. Only nit-pickers and purists insist on distinguishing a revolver from a pistol (in general terms) or on the use of the term "handgun". In fact, the insistance that revolvers be distinguished from pistols did not occur until the 1950's. That unnecessary distinction left no general term for a firearm intended to be held in one hand, so the purists had to redefine the term "handgun" as a blanket term for both revolvers and pistols. In the very early days (14-17 Century) a "handgun" was a gun that could be held in the hands, as opposed to a cannon which was fired from a mount or wheels.

When the self-loading pistol was invented, it was routinely called an "automatic pistol", and that term was often marked on the pistol. This was often shortened to "automatic". But again, the purists (and some law writers) made it necessary to distinguish between "automatic" and "semi-automatic". The term "self-loading" (originally a British term) has now come into use in order to avoid the politically incorrect term "semi-automatic."

As to "double action", the term correctly applies to a trigger which can both cock and release the hammer (a "double action"), as opposed to a trigger that can only release an already cocked hammer (a "single action"). So it is correct to refer to a DAO pistol as "double action", since the trigger both cocks the hammer and releases it. Strictly speaking, double action is not self-cocking. There have been self-cocking revolvers (the Civil War Starr being one of the best known) in which the trigger cocked the hammer but did not release it; the hammer was then released by pressing a separate trigger.

Jim
 
Much like "Pop" or "Soda" are pretty generic terms for sweet, carbonated soft drinks - or a "Car" is anything from a Honda Civic to a Cadalliac El Dorado - "Pistol" is a generic term for a handgun.

It's probably more generational than anything. When muzzel loading handguns were invented the term "pistol" was applied. Revolvers came along and became the cutting edge in handgun technology - thus a way to distinguish them between single shot and multi shot technology. Then came autoloading handguns. Far removed by time from the original muzzel loading handguns - but a technology where the bullet was still put in line with the bore for every shot without human powered mechanical intervention for every shot - but it was done "automatically". Thus "Pistol" became the the term to distinguish the latest in handgun technology from the older "Revolver" technology.

The bottom line is - it doesn't really matter any more. Unless you really want to differentiate the difference between a Pepsi & a Coke - or a Hummer and a Geo Metro. Same basic linage & basic purpose - but much different configuration.
 
The word is derived from the name of the town, Pistoia, in Italy, near which handguns were made (and near which Beretta, the oldest firearms company in existence, was founded). It originally referred to all handguns of any description. Later, we began distinguishing "revolvers" from "pistols", and still later, "semi-auto" pistols.
 
ORIGINALLY a pistol was a HANDGUN whose chamber is integral with the barrel... hence a REVOLVER is a handgun BUT not a pistol...
 
When you do things like shop for a holster you'll notice a pistol is an autoloader and a revolver is, just that, a revolver. It does simplify things to an extent.

I certainly refer to a revolver as a pistol though.
 
Merriam Webster Dictionary:

Pistol: Date: circa 1570
: a handgun whose chamber is integral with the barrel

Revolver: a handgun with a cylinder of several chambers brought successively into line with the barrel and discharged with the same hammer.

But, above all things, always remember: This is my rifle, this is my gun...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top