Wow, Factory Crimp Die discussion again.
This is THR and I think we should put forth some "truth in reloading" for the benefit of new reloaders. Many posted good answers and I'll add:
- FCD is a taper crimp die with a carbide sizer ring that will "post-size" the case and the bullet. It really was meant to be used with smaller diameter jacketed bullets (.355", .400", .451", etc.).
- For optimal seal with the chamber during powder ignition, case neck should be taper crimped .020" (average as brass case wall thickness varies) over the diameter of the bullet. Any less, and you are post sizing the bullet (reducing the diameter of the bullet). FCD will post size especially the larger diameter lead bullet and will affect bullet to barrel fit and bullet base bump which will result in gas cutting and leading.
Examples of taper crimp:
.355" jacketed bullet - .375"
.356" lead bullet - .376"
.451" jacketed bullet - .471"
.452" lead bullet - .472"
Many will taper crimp below the .020" over the diameter of the bullet for more "reliable" feeding/chambering. If you want more consistent chamber pressure, accurate match grade loads, do not reduce the diameter of the bullet for better seal with the barrel as many factory barrels are over sized.
- Those claiming they want to ensure reliable feeding/chambering will do so at the price of accuracy and possibly increased leading.
- Those claiming they like to seat the bullet and taper crimp in separate steps are leaving out "post-sizing" of the bullet. If you want to seat and taper crimp in separate steps, tap out the carbide sizer ring or get a separate taper crimp die.
- Is FCD essential? No. Many reloaders and match shooters have loaded their consistent and accurate rounds that reliably feed/chamber without using the FCD for decades. If you are match shooting and want reliable rounds that will consistently feed/chamber, use bullets that are consistently sized and enhance your reloading practice. If you want to increase the accuracy advantage, do a comparison test with FCD loads and loads that were properly taper crimped .020" over the diameter of the bullet.
- So when is FCD useful? When you are using bullets that are not consistently/properly sized. When you want to correct sloppy reloading practice. When you want to sacrifice accuracy over reliable feeding/chambering of rounds. When you can't stand the FCD collecting dust when you paid for it.
<flame suit on>