jason41987
member
- Joined
- Apr 10, 2012
- Messages
- 1,293
ive read other threads here and on other forums where someone has asked a question reguarding a specific purpose, whether it be defense, hunting, target shooting, or in reguard to accuracy, recoil, etc... and i know how these two cartridges stack up...
357 has less recoil, excellent performance for defense, makes a very nice deer cartridge out of a lever action, and can fit in smaller, lighter, narrower framed pistols
you might ask why not 357 or 44 magnum?.. and well, i see it this way.. when hunting, you can only kill a deer once... in self defence, dead is dead, the 357... 44 magnum in my opinion goes way over the top in practicality and to handle the extra power required thicker cylinders and beefier frames adding more to the weight of it
looking at 44 special +P loads, im seeing loads like 250 grains at 1100fps... this would put the 44 special +P at about the energy level of 357 magnum (around 700ft/lbs) at lower pressure (roughly 27000 PSI)
so in your opinion.. would you personally like a hot 44 special over a 357 magnum if you had the choice between the two in only a slightly larger frame, would you just prefer the ammo availability of a more common 357 mag, or would you step it all the way up to 44 mag for the best all around performance at a variety of tasks? and why?
im just curious as to what you guys are most interest in, what you think works best, and what your opinions are about these?
357 has less recoil, excellent performance for defense, makes a very nice deer cartridge out of a lever action, and can fit in smaller, lighter, narrower framed pistols
you might ask why not 357 or 44 magnum?.. and well, i see it this way.. when hunting, you can only kill a deer once... in self defence, dead is dead, the 357... 44 magnum in my opinion goes way over the top in practicality and to handle the extra power required thicker cylinders and beefier frames adding more to the weight of it
looking at 44 special +P loads, im seeing loads like 250 grains at 1100fps... this would put the 44 special +P at about the energy level of 357 magnum (around 700ft/lbs) at lower pressure (roughly 27000 PSI)
so in your opinion.. would you personally like a hot 44 special over a 357 magnum if you had the choice between the two in only a slightly larger frame, would you just prefer the ammo availability of a more common 357 mag, or would you step it all the way up to 44 mag for the best all around performance at a variety of tasks? and why?
im just curious as to what you guys are most interest in, what you think works best, and what your opinions are about these?