When operating an ATV in rough or muddy conditions,... etc.
Tuner, you make a good point about situations where you might NOT want to carry in Cond.1, but some extended points I'd like to add are:
1. Those who argue against Cond.2 in the context of this forum are mostly discussing the pros and cons as related to concealed carry on the street. Carrying a Cond.2 on the street puts you at a disadvantage from if you carry a DA/SA semi-auto the same way.
In those cases where a person wants to carry Cond.2, they would be better off getting rid of their 1911 and getting a DA/SA or DOA pistol instead.
I just don't see ANY reason to carry Cond.2 while in "CCW mode" on the street if self-defense is the primary purpose of carrying in the first place.
2. In all of the examples you mention about being in the woods etc., you are not in a self-defense situation where a "quick" draw and fire might be necessary. For all the reasons you mention, I'd just have my loaded mag inserted but with NO round in the chamber at all (and with hammer down on that empty chamber).
3. As most people agree, the hazards associated with Cond.2 are not carrying that way, but
getting to Cond.2.
If you're careful and understand the risks and take precautions (stack of newspapers is good), you will get away with lowering a hammer onto a loaded chamber of a 1911 quite a few times.
But if you do it frequently, the odds are not in your favor over the long run. There are a good number of skydivers who have found out how those odds work even though skydiving is a "safe" sport.
I think the bigger picture is to educate people as to why Cond.1 is not only the best way to carry a 1911 for self-defense purposes, but is also a VERY safe way to carry it as well.
The only reason the Cond.2 subject keeps coming up is because people new to 1911's just don't understand the mechanics of the pistol or understand how the 1911 design incorporates safety features that make up a "system" of safety that makes it probably safer to carry in Cond.1 than a hammer-down, loaded revolver (the 1911 requires that 3 conditions be met
at the same time before firing and the revolver has to meet only one).
Carter