Yo Mama
Member
- Joined
- Jun 4, 2008
- Messages
- 3,230
Hello everyone. We are planning on going on an extended trip where black bears are known to frequent. I really only have two options to carry a handgun on the trip, so please do not suggest a larger caliber as of course I would love to have a 44 Magnum but it's not in the cards. My choices are strictly 45 ACP in a 1911, or a 357 revolver 6 shots.
I am planning on getting Buffalo Bore rounds, and yes the ballistics on the 357 look superior however I have a few concerns. First I have six shots in the 357 as opposed to 9 in the 1911. More of a concern of mine however is permanent hearing damage that would be caused by the 357 in close-quarters proximity with my family, as opposed to the temporary discomfort of the 45. Also I'm a much better shot with the 1911.
Not sure if I should also put ease of a mag chance in the equation of a charging bear....but there is the reloading speed.
So what gets the nod: revolver in 357 or 1911 in 45?
I am planning on getting Buffalo Bore rounds, and yes the ballistics on the 357 look superior however I have a few concerns. First I have six shots in the 357 as opposed to 9 in the 1911. More of a concern of mine however is permanent hearing damage that would be caused by the 357 in close-quarters proximity with my family, as opposed to the temporary discomfort of the 45. Also I'm a much better shot with the 1911.
Not sure if I should also put ease of a mag chance in the equation of a charging bear....but there is the reloading speed.
So what gets the nod: revolver in 357 or 1911 in 45?