chaplain tom
Member
Chaplain Tom,
I appreciate you sharing the account of your ordeal. But to put my armchair coroner hat on for a second: You said that the pellets penetrated very deeply into his throat. I'm guessing they didn't exit the assailant's throat's? If so, you're only getting at most 4-5" of penetration out of that loading, which means either through skill, luck or God's hand you put that shot in about the only place where it would cause such an immediate blood loss as to render your assailant incapacitated.
I think your situation speaks far greater praise for your quick reaction, diligence in practice and correct shot placement than it does for the weapon used.
I'm still amazed at how many people are intent on actually killing someone. I spent 13 months in South East Asia doing just that and frankly, I've had enough of that unless it's absolutely the ONLY way out. My intent at the moment of the attack WAS NOT necessarily to KILL, but to ESCAPE. I had my wife with me at the time and the last thing I wanted her to see was me KILLING someone. As it tunred out, that's what she saw anyway. I actually tried to shoot him in the face and drive him off so I could drive off. If he had not gone down I would have let the Silvertip JHP go from the bottom barrell directly into his center chest area. At the close distance (as I've stated before) of most self-defense shootings, this one included and being a prime example, that round WOULD have penetrated MUCH deeper. I've done the tests with this gun and that round would have done way more dammage. The reason I have the .410 loaded first is so I DON'T necessarily HAVE to kill the attacker. If that happens, so be it, he made that choice not me when he attacked me first. Dirty Bob talked about the muzzel blast from the .410 load as being a deterrent and OUTSIDE MY HOME that's more my intent than anything else. If this would have happened INSIDE MY HOME the attacker would have faced an XD four inch barrell also in the .45 cal. with a HydraShock load and yes I would have shot him several times.
Before anyone asks, the XD I spoke of is this modle as listed when I ordered it XD9611HCSP06 45ACP. At distances of 25 feet or less there is very little difference in my tests with these two .45's as far as penetration goes. I've shot wet paper, sand, wood, and even a cow that a friend of mine asked me to put down for him because it was old sick and about to die anyway. Both JHP's only penetrated MAYBE 10 inches into the cow from about 25 feet away shot through the ribs just back of the shoulder. I know that sounds sick, but the cow was first shot in the head right behind the ear with the XD to kill it first. My friend suggested we see for ourselves what the difference would be between the two guns. We tried to move back some feet for longer test shots but the derreinger just isn't accurate enough to do this test without shooting several times and we weren't going there. I will admit though that my little pocket cannon is NOT the gun I would want to use IF I knew I had to make a first or second shot kill at any distance over 20 feet. I don't trust the penetration at that distance even in the .45 colt. This gun is (and listen carefully) meant for a surprise blast into an attacker's face or upper chest with any .410 load and as a last means of escape by placing a .45 colt into a vital area AT VERY CLOSE RANGE. It's NOT a COMBAT weapon and no one ever said it was.
As for more details of the incident, even in a PM, I'll have to think about that. I never really intened for this to go as far as it has, but that's the nature of all of us. We are a curious people and maybe after a while I'll be able to give more detail. I'm only proud of ONE thing here...I was able to PROTECT MY WIFE FROM WHATEVER THE BG HAD ON HIS MIND. IMO NO ONE SHOULD EVER BE PROUD OF TAKEING A HUMAN LIFE TO THE POINT OF BRAGGING ON THE INTERNET OR ANYWHERE ELSE FOR THAT MATTER. I also understand the idea that maybe my story could help someone else who might be faced with something like this him or her self. But let me think about it for a while first. I am not upset with anyone on this forum who may be curious, but it didn't happen all that long ago and it still upsets the wife a little.
Last edited: