KahrKarrier
Member
I realize this subject has been kicked around for years and years but I have never seen a definitive answer to the question: Which round is the best IN CLOSE (inside of 7 to 10 feet) self defence JHP cartridge fired from a compact semi-auto with a 3.0" or a 3.5" barrel?
Let me preface this by saying that I pray I will never, ever have to shoot someone but God forbid I must, I want one that will do the job.
When reading various velocity charts, they never say how long the barrel was on the test piece, nor do they indicate how far from down range from the muzzle that the speed and energy was measured.
1. The 9mm launches fast from a short barrel but is considered by some to be anemic. I own a Kahr K9 and a Glock 26 and don't agree.
2. The .357Sig is very fast and some say too fast and creates over penetration and has limited bullet weights available. I own a Glock 33.
3. The .40S&W from all that I have read seems to be the ideal cartridge and as we all know is widely used by law enforcement. My daily carry piece is a Kahr K40 and I love it. I also have a Glock 23.
4. The .45acp is a relatively slow traveler some say when fired from a short barrel, JHP's won't gain enough velocity to expand.
5. Not much info to be found on 10mm and .38super compact semi-autos.
6. The .32acp and the .380acp are also considered by many to be anemic but are very popular in Europe and South America and seem to be the caliber of choice of many manufacturers of small, short barreled hand guns.
I realize there are dozens, perhaps hundreds of cartriges available for use in revos, ie. .357 magnum and other larger size revo rounds which are notorious man-killers.
I'm simply interested to know which popular modern caliber functions most efficiently for in close combat, 7 to 10 feet, when fired from a compact semi-auto with a 3.0" or 3.5" barrel. ----------Jed
Let me preface this by saying that I pray I will never, ever have to shoot someone but God forbid I must, I want one that will do the job.
When reading various velocity charts, they never say how long the barrel was on the test piece, nor do they indicate how far from down range from the muzzle that the speed and energy was measured.
1. The 9mm launches fast from a short barrel but is considered by some to be anemic. I own a Kahr K9 and a Glock 26 and don't agree.
2. The .357Sig is very fast and some say too fast and creates over penetration and has limited bullet weights available. I own a Glock 33.
3. The .40S&W from all that I have read seems to be the ideal cartridge and as we all know is widely used by law enforcement. My daily carry piece is a Kahr K40 and I love it. I also have a Glock 23.
4. The .45acp is a relatively slow traveler some say when fired from a short barrel, JHP's won't gain enough velocity to expand.
5. Not much info to be found on 10mm and .38super compact semi-autos.
6. The .32acp and the .380acp are also considered by many to be anemic but are very popular in Europe and South America and seem to be the caliber of choice of many manufacturers of small, short barreled hand guns.
I realize there are dozens, perhaps hundreds of cartriges available for use in revos, ie. .357 magnum and other larger size revo rounds which are notorious man-killers.
I'm simply interested to know which popular modern caliber functions most efficiently for in close combat, 7 to 10 feet, when fired from a compact semi-auto with a 3.0" or 3.5" barrel. ----------Jed