Colion Noir - NY Judge does not allow the 2nd Amendment in the courtroom?

[Poper]

NY Judge Convicts Man Over Gunsmith Hobby & Says 2nd Amendment Doesn't Exist In Her Courtroom

Dexter Taylor 2A Legal Fund:https://bit.ly/3vYlnLlA Brooklyn man, Dexter Taylor, has been convicted in New York City for building his own firearms that he ne...

youtu.be

A must watch for anyone more concerned about what is truly happening in some courtrooms in America today.

Colion Noir is a jewel and tells it like he sees it. Two thumbs up for Colion!!

 

[Insignificant bill]

Someone has do something about the these corrupt NY judges

 

[Cfish]

FUBAR

 

[Old Dog]

Well, the story didn't last long in the Legal sub-forum.

But I truly believe it's a worthy topic in any forum that professes to be about supporting the right to keep and bear arms.

The judge in question was actually recorded as saying such during the defense attorney's opening argument -- that the 2nd Amendment does not exist in her courtroom -- "this is New York."

If we can't have a discussion about this... I'll just stop here.

The fact that any sitting judge in a criminal court can feel free to spout these words should be of grave concern to us all.

 

[luv2safari]

It leaves any anti-gun decision in her court open to reversal. What an idiot! NY has lost it's collective mind.

 

[Twisted Chemist]

NY Judge Convicts Man Over Gunsmith Hobby & Says 2nd Amendment Doesn't Exist In Her Courtroom

Dexter Taylor 2A Legal Fund:https://bit.ly/3vYlnLlA Brooklyn man, Dexter Taylor, has been convicted in New York City for building his own firearms that he ne...

youtu.be

A must watch for anyone more concerned about what is truly happening in some courtrooms in America today.

Colion Noir is a jewel and tells it like he sees it. Two thumbs up for Colion!!

Unbelievable....

 

[rust collector]

The story didn't last long in legal because it has nothing to do with the law and everything to do with courtroom antics and folks misbehaving. The story sounds horrific and if it has been accurately related, someone who took an oath to support the constitution will likely be sanctioned by an ethics board and/or a reviewing court. Just don't imagine that you have all the relevant facts at this point.

I like Colion Noir, but he exists in a space in which outrage = money.

 

[22250Rem]

The judge only stated something that most folks have known for years. There really is no 2nd Amendment in NYC, as they are in their own little fiefdom world, where only the cops, the ruling elite, and a few select millionaires can even think about obtaining a carry permit. Even on a state wide basis, the governor of New York state (Cathy Hochul) has thumbed her nose at the U.S. Supreme Court and ignored decisions that are contrary to the agenda of hers and a small group of NYC power brokers, who would like nothing better than to impose the NYC no gun agenda upon the entire state.

 

[valnar]

I feel bad for our brothers in places like upstate NY, southern Illinois, western Oregon, rural California, etc. Some beautiful country destroyed by the lawmakers in the big cities.

 

[gifbohane]

NY has lost it's collective mind.

It happened back in the 80's when the "Good People" elected a tax grifter Mayor of New York City

 

[4v50 Gary]

What crime? Manufacturing for himself is no crime.

 

[Styx]

He did break New York law. He should have followed the law and fought to change it, and/or he should have moved.

 

[Styx]

What crime? Manufacturing for himself is no crime.

It is according to New York law as I understand it. I also believe that another issue is that his firearms weren't registered.

 

[Choctaw]

The story didn't last long in legal because it has nothing to do with the law and everything to do with courtroom antics and folks misbehaving. The story sounds horrific and if it has been accurately related, someone who took an oath to support the constitution will likely be sanctioned by an ethics board and/or a reviewing court. Just don't imagine that you have all the relevant facts at this point.

I like Colion Noir, but he exists in a space in which outrage = money.

He's also an attorney and knows what he's talking about.

 

[4v50 Gary]

Thanks Styx. I should have figured in was New York laws. ATF should not have been involved as they had no jurisdiction.

 

[Styx]

Thanks Styx. I should have figured in was New York laws. ATF should not have been involved as they had no jurisdiction.

Never miss an opportunity for a photo opt.

 

[4v50 Gary]

Justify the budget. We participated in _____ raids and assisted in ____ convictions. We could do better if you give us ____ more dollars.

 

[Styx]

Justify the budget. We participated in _____ raids and assisted in ____ convictions. We could do better if you give us ____ more dollars.

Yup exactly.

 

[tark]

New York reminds me of California, where I lived for 15 years, back in the 70s and 80s. The state is mostly red, except for a few concentrated liberal infestations ( L.A, the Bay Area and Sacratomato ) that poison the state. Same deal with New York and N.Y.City.

Now, I am living in Illinois. Same thing. Carve Chicago out from the rest of the state, float it out into lake Michigan and sink it, and you have a very red state.

And somebody tell Illinois to stop calling itself "The land of Lincoln" Lincoln never set foot in Illinois until he was a grown man in his early twenties. He was born in Kentucky and grew up in Indiana.

 

[tarosean]

He's also an attorney and knows what he's talking about.

That said, he practices here in TX where laws are far different than NY when it comes to firearms.

 

[Insignificant bill]

That said, he practices here in TX where laws are far different than NY when it comes to firearms.

Well when a judge says what she said it doesn't matter where you are from. She should no longer be a judge or an attorney.

 

[Gun-Reck]

Well, the story didn't last long in the Legal sub-forum.

But I truly believe it's a worthy topic in any forum that professes to be about supporting the right to keep and bear arms.

The judge in question was actually recorded as saying such during the defense attorney's opening argument -- that the 2nd Amendment does not exist in her courtroom -- "this is New York."

If we can't have a discussion about this... I'll just stop here.

The fact that any sitting judge in a criminal court can feel free to spout these words should be of grave concern to us all.

Treasonous Communist Malcontents... are.

​

 

[herrwalther]

The 2A (like the free states) hasn't existed in NY in decades. Mostly due to NYC. Big part of the reason I left and will never move back there. Colin is slow to the realization.

 

[DoubleMag]

...and friends wonder why I say, ''I will NOT conduct any commerce in NY, i will NOT drive through it''

Vid was a little long, but, thanks ATTORNEY Noir

 

[KyJim]

I’ve been an attorney for 41 years, most of those years prosecuting civil fraud at the trial court and appellate levels and then as an appellate criminal prosecutor for the government. Two points:

1. The judge should have called the attorney to the bench and told him not to get into the Second Amendment and then admonished the jury to ignore the remark.

2. Any claim of 2A protection should have been handled in pre-trial briefing. Application of the 2A is a legal issue for the judge to decide and not a factual issue for the jury to decide.

I think Coion Noir is a great spokesman for gun rights, but I have not been able to find any criminal law experience.