Crimped primers in nickel 9 mm cases?

I was planning to order some once-fired 9 mm brass. One source I see offers Ni-plated cases, cleaned but not decapped. Has anyone ever encountered crimped (or Berdan) primers in nickel cases? Wondering if that would be a way to reduce the risk of breaking a pin...
Interesting question but the risk of breaking a pin is exceptionally low with brass, no?
 
Last edited:
Should’ve asked how many pins have you broken with crimped brass? And how many crimped primers do you find?

I use only used range brass or buy only used and have never broken a pin on the relatively few crimped I find.
 
I too, have processed quite a few nickel plated 9mm cases. None that I can remember had crimped in primers. (But then I've never had a problem sizing/decapping any NATO 9mm brass with my old Lee dies)
 
  • Like
Reactions: CQB45ACP
Sizing and decanting isn't the issue. It is inserting a new primer that is the issue. If I see the little + sign they go in rainy day bag.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CQB45ACP
Has anyone ever encountered crimped (or Berdan) primers in nickel cases? Wondering if that would be a way to reduce the risk of breaking a pin
If you use Lee resizing/decapping die, you will never break the decapping pin.

I adjust the collet on the pin to where primer is barely pushed out. So when the pin encounters crimped primer pocket or Berdan primed case, instead of breaking, pin simply gets pushed up to let me know primer pocket is either crimped or case is Berdan primed.

And after I tap the pin down and tighten the collet, I am back to reloading.
 
If you use Lee resizing/decapping die, you will never break the decapping pin.

I adjust the collet on the pin to where primer is barely pushed out. So when the pin encounters crimped primer pocket or Berdan primed case, instead of breaking, pin simply gets pushed up to let me know primer pocket is either crimped or case is Berdan primed.

And after I tap the pin down and tighten the collet, I am back to reloading.
I thought so to but a rock had different ideas. I'm sure that's absolutely true if your not digging brass out of the dirt.....
 
Now it’s time to address the problems with nickel plated cases: 1) cases don’t last as long and 2) flaking plating will scratch dies.

Each of these topics have consumed lengthy threads of their own but that’s no reason to not repeat them here ad nauseam.
 
Now it’s time to address the problems with nickel plated cases: 1) cases don’t last as long and 2) flaking plating will scratch dies.

Each of these topics have consumed lengthy threads of their own but that’s no reason to not repeat them here ad nauseam.
I only load nickle for long term rounds to set back. They are also excellent for people who use cowboy leather belts or hunting in crap conditions seen often in the north west like the cascade range. I would not seek out nickle for regular use.
 
The higher risk is nickel plated steel. I don’t think you’ll break anything or damage anything - in fact quite a few folks reload them just like brass - but they don’t last long and don’t hold neck tension very well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CQB45ACP
Half my range pickup 9mm is crimped and about 90% of my range picked 223.
Breaking a decap pin isn't the problem.
I got a Dillon super swage.
Only berdan primed 9mm I have seen was steel case.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Kaldor
You are supposed to tap out dirt/rock if you dig brass out of dirt ... ;)

Less of an issue if you dig brass out of snow ... :D
Yep, that's what case inspection is for. Every case that is reloaded in my shop get inspected, one quicky when it is brought home and a good inspection when it's cleaned...

Primer crimps are cut out after sizing...
 
I was planning to order some once-fired 9 mm brass. One source I see offers Ni-plated cases, cleaned but not decapped. Has anyone ever encountered crimped (or Berdan) primers in nickel cases? Wondering if that would be a way to reduce the risk of breaking a pin...
I really like nickel plated anything. I had a lot of 9’s since the LE would shoot at our range and just leave all the duty ammo brass, but it was mostly Speer. It’s a bit easier to see in the grass and dirt and most everyone else uses brass so you know which cases are yours. I haven’t seen a berdan or crimped primer so far, but, I have an extra depriming pin on hand. Best defense against breaking one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Buck13 and CQB45ACP
I will use nickel plated cases often. One reason is they are easier to find in the dirt, rocks, trash, etc. at the local "range"...
I no longer use nickel in my normal rotation. Instead, as I shoot what’s already loaded, I clean and store them in a separate container. When I get enough (some arbitrary amount I haven’t determined yet) I’ll load them all together.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GeoDudeFlorida