DO NOT confuse reason with the actions of legislatures.
DO NOT confuse dictionary, popular, or your own definitions of a word with the intent of the law and the use of a word by the law.
If you have a question about whether these or any other device are legal or not for carry, look it up in the statutes of your state and federal law and any other governing body you live under.
Besidesides my comments about the personal protection course earlier I also had a setion in Florida Law for Police when I was getting my AA with centralization in Law Enforcement at a Florida COmmunity COllege that meantioned illegal weapons and there they were. The class was taught by the area's assistant states attourney that would be prosicuting such violations. Then it was covered in a class on Issues in Modern Law Enforcement when I was getting my BS in Criminology at FSU.
There were examples of saps and blackjacks on a board of illegal weapons at the Law Enforcement training academy "North" near Tallahassee at one point.
If you would like to explain to an Florida LEO and to a Florida judge what makes you special and what makes you an expert on what "really" is a slung shot or not.....don't say you weren't warned.
-kBob
I agree with what you're saying about knowing the law and not trusting an off the cuff analysis.