Sam1911
Moderator Emeritus
So, it would make a difference that I was active duty military resident of NY, stationed temporarily in Utah when I took possession
It might, unless you violated NY State law regarding transfer of a handgun.
A license to carry or posses a pistol or revolver is required to purchase a handgun. ...a person licensed to carry or possess a pistol or revolver may apply at any time to the licensing officer in the county of their residence for amendment of his or her license to include one or more such handguns or to cancel a handgun held under the license.
Your situation seems quite complicated. I'm sure what's done is done and it's unlikely that harm will come of it.
Kind of scary, though, how easy it is to run afould of the law, even for a Police Officer.
-Sam