Good Letter to the Editor from the Mother of a Survivor

Status
Not open for further replies.

nomadboi

Member
Joined
Sep 30, 2003
Messages
472
Location
Seattle
I imagine many of you have seen the headlines about this recent shooting here in Seattle, many of them focusing on the lifestyles of those involved, the array of weaponry owned by the perp, etc. This isn't the best writing in the world, but I thank her for saying it.

Posted in the Seattle Times:
http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/opinion/2002898210_capitolhill30.html

Shooting survivor's mother shares gratitude — and anger

By Danette M. Will

Special to The Times

Danette M. Will

My son survived the carnage of Capitol Hill on March 25, 2006, by the skin of his teeth. The first moment of saving grace came from his girlfriend, whom I will be indebted to for the rest of my life, whether they stay together or not. The next moment came from Officer Steve Leonard, who arrived in time to distract the killer from breaking into the bathroom where my son and his girlfriend were hiding. Again, one whom I will be extremely grateful to forever.

The first thing I find myself having trouble getting past is how very close I came to losing my son. I'm not sure I'll ever get over that. I know it can happen anywhere and anytime, and yet logic just doesn't seem to take the leading stance in this instance. Emotion is barreling to the forefront with speed and accuracy.

Then, I find my overwhelming concern for those who did lose their sons, daughters, boyfriends, girlfriends, sisters, brothers. My grief, and guilt, well up alongside my previous emotion. These are emotions I'm not sure will ever go away.

Thankfulness comes in next. Thankfulness to God for saving my son for the next moment, at least. Thankfulness to everyone whose actions came between him and death. Thankfulness to him for using his head and hiding.

The reason I'm writing this, though, is not to let people know about these three emotions, because everyone in the world can understand, if not relate to, my feeling them. Today, I want the world to know that I'm angry.

I'm not angry at the things everyone is talking about, though. I'm not angry at the guns; the guns did not shoot at my son and kill his friends. I'm not angry at the after-hours parties, because billions of people of all ages have survived them. I'm not angry at the raves, drugs, alcohol, teenage rebellion, knives, bats, cars, etc., etc., etc.

I'm angry with Kyle Huff. Kyle Huff decided he wanted to end my son's life. Kyle Huff decided to kill all of those kids. Not his arsenal, not his family, not alcohol, not drugs. Not anything or anyone except Kyle Huff. I'm angry with everyone who is trying to make themselves feel better about this by blaming anything or anyone except the person responsible.

When are we as human beings going to stop making excuses for our behavior and the behavior of others? Yes, I agree, there are always reasons. We are human after all and make mistakes and wrong decisions, but we make them.

I had a rough childhood. Both adults and other children abused me physically, mentally and sexually in my childhood, but I have never allowed myself to blame anyone or anything for my actions.

Guns do not whisper (please let me shoot that guy!). Alcohol doesn't jump into our hands in mass quantities. Drugs do not make, sell or buy themselves for or to you. Party invitations do not say, "Come on over and hurt a few people." These are just a few of the things I hear people blaming for this catastrophe, along with many other "excuses" for other catastrophes.

Wake up, America! Kyle Huff killed these kids and my prayers include his family and friends because I know everyone is going to have a heyday placing blame on them, too! You have my heartfelt word that I most certainly am not!

One more thing: In the past few days, I and many others involved have had so very few people walk up to us with concern, love and helpfulness.

Why would you ask within range of a father whose child was shot, "What would possess a parent to allow their 14-year-old daughter to be at that party?"

Why would you say to a mother, whose child had a gun pointed at him and who saw his girlfriend killed, words to the effect: "How could you let your son go to those nasty raves?"

Why would you walk up to a sister whose brother hid in the basement listening to someone shoot his friends, wondering if he was next, and then proceed to give her your opinion on gun control?

Are these really the things you think we want to hear? Have we become so involved with our own morals and political beliefs that we need to press them on people who really just need a hug? Have we become so numb to violence that we can't focus on the pain the families and surviving victims are feeling? Have we forgotten how much trouble we were to our own parents when we were 14 going on 21?

Too many people have made comments much like those I've mentioned; too few just walk up and give us a hug. We need hugs. We need to cry. We're not doing OK.

We could use someone to listen, care and pray with us, to help figure out how to get our children the best counseling when we can barely afford to feed ourselves or pay the bills. We want someone to tell us how we're going to sleep tonight, knowing our children and friends are not around for us to tell them we love them.

We need you to think before you speak.

Danette M. Will of Redmond is the mother of Garry Will, 20, who with his girlfriend hid in a bathtub during Kyle Huff's rampage at a Capitol Hill home early Saturday morning.

Copyright © 2006 The Seattle Times Company
 
Interesting letter, and written in the midst of severe stress. She did not lose her son, thankfully, but others did lose loved ones.

Nice to see her rational explanation about not blaming anyone (or any inanimate object) but the perp, but I wonder if parents of those killed would be able to see it that way right now.
 
Nice to see her rational explanation about not blaming anyone (or any inanimate object) but the perp, but I wonder if parents of those killed would be able to see it that way right now.

It seems there is a double standard when it comes to gun fatalities. If someone I cared about was run over by a reckless 18-year old driver, I wouldn't focus my anger at Ford, or the DMV. My anger would be focused on the driver, and making sure he got the maximum sentence. I would continue to drive, my kids would get their licenses at 16, etc...

But when there's a big, bad gun involved, all of the sudden the gun becomes the target of people's venom. Even when the people doing the shooting are hopped-up drug dealers shooting illegally obtained weapons in a school zone, it's still not their fault. "They're victims of society themselves, and are only behaving like anyone else would act that was dealt the same hand by life."
 
I wonder if her feelings would have been the same if she had lost her son. I agree with what she is saying but I almost feel it is in bad taste for her to speak up since she did not lose anything. She should allow the ones that actually lost people to feel their grief and anger in anyway they feel fit and not add her two cents to the mix so close to the actual event. All she stands to accomplish at this time is to add to the grief of those that actually lost a child if they disagree with her.
 
I think she's trying to help the grieving families, not antagonize them- much of the press has focused on the party, the lifestyle, the labels (Ravers, whatever), and as she says, that leaves loved ones open to self (or external) blame, from the 'how could you let your kid go to those things in the first place' camp.
 
I'm angry with Kyle Huff. Kyle Huff decided he wanted to end my son's life. Kyle Huff decided to kill all of those kids. Not his arsenal, not his family, not alcohol, not drugs. Not anything or anyone except Kyle Huff. I'm angry with everyone who is trying to make themselves feel better about this by blaming anything or anyone except the person responsible.

We don't often see letters to the editor written by adults.
 
And one of the other notable quotes from the article: Guns do not whisper (please let me shoot that guy!). Alcohol doesn't jump into our hands in mass quantities. Drugs do not make, sell or buy themselves for or to you. Party invitations do not say, "Come on over and hurt a few people."

I wish more people would think more about not blaming objects. It is the people. Knee jerk reactions to these things are to reduce the civil liberties of all the honest people. Australia is a good example.

If someone is killed in a drunk driving accident, there is never talk or debate that cars need to be outlawed.
 
We don't often see letters to the editor written by adults.

Nor do we often see newpapers print letters that actually make sense. It's almost too much to hope that the print media would allow such a rational thing to show up in it's pages.

Do we know for sure it really ran in the paper? Is John Lott pretending to be someone else again?
 
As to being verified- I posted the link to the newspaper it's in- I'd assume they wouldn't fabricate this letter, but you're welcome to do more searching if you like.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top