Hmmm, AK decisions

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
May 12, 2007
Messages
82
So I'm gonna take the plunge on a 7.62x39 AK this week, I'm up in the air between a Saiga at $250, a Romainian G-kit build that comes with 100 rds. of ammo and accessories for $400 or a Yugo M70B1, the fixed stock one for $430. All Prices would be plus shipping and a $20 transfer.

I figure the Saiga conversion should be within my abilities, I can build a desk and work on the guts of my computer or car just fine, following directions is no problem. Though I must admit there is an attraction to opening the box and being ready to rock in a few minutes with the Yugo or Romy options. Opinions? Experiences? Guidance?
 
the G kit will totally depend on who did the building, do ya have pics and on what receiver is it built? be VERY leary of private party builds as ya have no way of knowing the builders skill level or if he even used real rivets as there are ALOT of em commin from Arf.com members that are built with U-Drives which look exactly like rivets until it comes apart on you, for $400+ ammo I'd do some serious investigating first!!

The Yugo M70 is one of my personal favorites, Who are ya considering ordering it from? the current batch is a best buy deal where ya actually end up with MORE than what ya pay for, be sure mags lock in (all of em not just one) and that the sights are straight and ya can't go wrong...

The Saigas , Russian version of a WASR as far as I'm concerned onea those cases where ya get what ya pay for... my .02
 
G-kit is built on a Nodak receiver by some outfit called Heavy Metal Guns. That's the first time I've heard a Saiga lumped in with a WASR though, care to elaborate?
 
The King of Pants said:
I figure the Saiga conversion should be within my abilities, I can build a desk and work on the guts of my computer or car just fine, following directions is no problem. Though I must admit there is an attraction to opening the box and being ready to rock in a few minutes with the Yugo or Romy options.
Last I looked, the Saiga was "ready to rock" right out of the box, too.

The nice thing about the Saiga is that it's a brand new gun, and you're not changing anything major on it when you convert.
 
WASR10 7.62 x 39

I've got my eye on a Romainian WASR 10; 2x 30 round steel mags, a Tapco (USA) trigger and a chrome-lined barrel. SOG is the outfit I'm looking at; I understnand that Century Arms is the importer. Price is right around 380$, shipped. It would be a first, so nothing fancy required. :D

PS: A recent thread treating this very topic:

http://www.thehighroad.org/showthread.php?t=317136

Good luck.
 
Saiga's are well made rifles. I've owned one as well as owning a WASR...an other nicer AKs. The Saiga was definately put together better than the WASR was, but just be aware that they use non-standard (i.e. expensive) magazines unless you do the conversion work on them to accept standard AK mags. That's eventually why I sold mine...for commonality of magazines, since I didn't want to do the conversion. Rifle functioned fine...as does my WASR.

Yugo's aren't completely compatible with some other standard AK parts either...although in my experience they are rock solid, and still a relatively good deal. If you're planning on only owning one AK and aren't concerned with being able to swap parts between it and other AKs you own, I'd be tempted to go with the Yugo for it's durability. Just my .02
 
Saiga's are much nicer rifles than WASR's. IMO, they're a good middle of the road AK for a good price and it's not that hard to convert them. Some very well regarded gunsmiths build Saiga based rifles, Marc Krebs for example. If the Saiga were really the equivalent of a WASR, these people wouldn't be respected for long.
 
The Saigas , Russian version of a WASR as far as I'm concerned onea those cases where ya get what ya pay for... my .02

I've seen other posts from you regarding Saigas. I think you're the only one who has ever had anything bad to say about a Saiga. That I've read anyway. So what exactly is your gripe?
 
Not Broken--Needs No Fixin'

I advise choosing the Saiga as an AK-style rifle!Reasons---"NEW" AK-style rifle straight from the factory in Russia;Hammer-forged,chrome-lined barrel;AK-profile conversion(if desired) capabile with a few home-tools by you,yourself;Reputation as reliable,well-built(a fact be-woed by the "repairman");Easily an out-of-the-box and into-your-arms shooting experience! WARNING:Saigas are ADDICTIVE!
 
Hate to add to the pile-on, but.....

The saiga, properly converted is one of the best engineered, best built, best quality factory new AK available . You have every new development of the ak series along with being built in Russia, by Russians.

There is some work involved in making them correct, but it's well worth it.

The WASR is a Chevette, the Saiga is a Corvette. Both are cars built by Chevy but otherwise there's no comparison.

I'm not trashing WASRs, but they are what they are. Just because they are close in MSRP, doesn't make them close in quality.
 
Last edited:
O.K If ya go to Izvesh Russian arsenal ya will note I said it is the RUSSIAN version, in Russia the Saiga is made much the same as the WASR is made in Romania, those who work in the commercial factory are paid less than those who build the military guns, the Saiga receiver is a for commercial export only receiver the parts are "for commercial export only" they are not required to meet the same requirements as the military spec AK parts made for the military rifle so they don't... my reference is in regards to those who think simply adding a pistol grip and HICap mag capability turns a SAIGA into a Russian military grade AKMS it does not, just like a WASR is not a military grade AKMS nor is a Norinco for that matter what the SAIGA, WASR, NORINCO all have in common is that the quality requirements are lower than the requirements for the milspec guns made at the same arsenals/factories simply because they are being made from the very beginning "for export to USA only" if ya want the highest quality AKs ie; totally military spec components the only way to get it is to start with a parts set or get an Arsenal Bulgarian made AK (which actually are made with military grade components) however ya will pay more for that higher quality......

As far as Saiga if ya really know AKs (been buildin em for over 20 years) then the shortcommings in the components become very clear as soon as ya start looking them over, Another issue consistent with the lower paid labor force comparison to the WASR rifles is the canted sights etc.. as the workers simply are not paid enough to care..... the military spec Russian guns have a much higher standard they must meet......... ie; ya get what ya pay for, WASR = $389 SAIGA = $289 how do ya suppose Russia can make brand new SAIGAs and sell em for even less than a Romanian WASR? and this while the Russians are having to make special mags and stocksf ire control group parts etc.. too boot to even get em exported to the USA as opposed to just using "military" items like mags etc... as the WASR is able to use? because they cut every possible corner including paying the labor much less in order to do it, low paid employees don't care about the quality of work they are doing and its reflected in the product..... but if ya have never actually held a REAL Russian AKM etc... then sure ya might just assume they are all the same.... unfortunately we imported over 2000 REAL Russian AKMs some while back so I do know exactly how far the gap is between Russian military spec and Russian "for export to USA only" spec........... can't even look at a saiga anymore and delude myself that they are the same.........


in other words the comparison is;

Romanian WASR = NOT the same gun as Romanian AIM rifle

Chinese NORINCO = NOT the same as chinese Type 56 rifle

Russian SAIGA = NOT the same as Russian military AKM rifle

each are made at a lower quality requirement in order to make a cheap facsimile of a military grade rifle strictly for export to America.. myself I demand the highest quality available when it comes to my guns, and am not impressed with BIC Lighter grade guns to any extent

But hey if your happy carrying a BIC instead of a payin the extra $$ for a Zippo then thats fine Myself... got a whole collection of Zippo's don't ever have to buy any BIC lighters but their pens are pretty handy....... in this case ya can get the base model Zippo with no frills in a Rommy G kit build or get the next level up Zippo in the Yugo build......... so why even bother with the BIC when the price difference is so little???? sure ya can convert a SAIGA, then ya will have a BIC in a zippo case....... for some people disposable makes sense but for me... Zippo lighters, Military grade AKMs and 1911 pistols......


As far as the Rommy G kit build, I'd suspect they are cutting some serious corners someplace and would proceed with caution as no pro builder can build and sell a quality level Rommy G for under $500 let alone throw in 100 rnds of ammo as well, look for some refferances etc... try going to ak-files.com and ask about the company, I've never heard of em but somebody else might have...... and ya will get the info good or bad, find out what corners they are cutting and decided if you can live with that.
 
Last edited:
My friend has a Saiga in 7.62x39 and it jams quite a bit .. My WASR has never jammed .. The other day he goes "man I should have bought one of those" ..
 
okiewita40, a lil over reactive aren't ya? SAIGA isn't crap but it is what it is, a commercial grade made for export to the USA,, buyers are free to decided if they want the higher military level quality or are they happy with commercial quality..............

some people just don't seem to be capable of comprehending the concept behind AMERICA...... we are all free to make our own choices.. MY choice is the absolute highest quality components with zero cut corners...

I mean h#ll I ride a Harley, others ride a Honda and are perfectly happy with it, I don't go screaming Honda's are pieces of crap or put down those who buy one but they are what they are... My road truck is a Peterbilt that I've dumped alota extra $$ into my drivers are all in Freightliner XL Classics and perfectly happy with em, thats fine both get the same job done in the end one is just going to hold up better and have a higher resale than the other...... choices friend we all get to have choices its a matter of where your priorities are at, mine are for quality others its cost my Chevy Tahoe didn't cost as much as my best friends Hummer H2 but has the same interior etc.. and as I seldom drive a car my priority was $40K versus $65K........
 
My friend has a Saiga in 7.62x39 and it jams quite a bit .. My WASR has never jammed .. The other day he goes "man I should have bought one of those" ..

Your friend is hilarious:D. The chances of getting a lemon Saiga are FAR, FAR lower than getting a lemon WASR. Plus, I'll bet it's an easy fix with the Saiga. What kinda ammo was he running? Some people have reported having problems with certain ammo. Or maybe it was operator error.
 
dstorm,

I didn't mean to come off as negative but dollar for dollar the Saiga is the best AK based rifle on the market right now. Now I know that mil-spec parts and comm. parts don't meet the exacting standards. If people want to spend more money to feel better then so be it. It is their choice to do so.

I guess thats why I would take a stevens 200 over a Tikka T3. Both will get the job done if the shooter does their part. Just my choice to spend money on what I want as you do the same with yours.
 
dstorm1911: Thanks for the information and I see what you mean. I am curious though - Who in your opinion makes the best AK-variant out there? Cost be damned - are there any builders you feel are free from corner cutting? I don't know Jack about AK builds, but I love my Arsenal. Was wondering if you felt they were on the list of quality builders - you won't hurt my feelings. I love this rifle no matter what...
 
Well, since the Defense Department pays about $520 each for Colt M4's, I guess they must really suck compared to more expensive brands like Olympic or Vulcan. They're probably even produced on a separate assembly line than the much higher quality civilian models. And Romanian milspecs? Give me a break. American, British or Swiss milspecs are something I would have confidence in. Romanian milspecs are not. Remember the village in Borat? That was shot in a real village in Romania.
 
Elmerfudd, So wanna tell me how many years ya been visiting the arsenals in Russia, Romania (actually have family still living in Cugir), Bulgaria, China, Croatia, Bosnia? Up till I retired from it last year thats what I did for 14 years.... if ya really want some info on whats done regarding civilian versus milspec ya might wanna start by at least learning the basics of an AKM (I'm the one who reverse engineered the first receiver that was used to make all of the USA made receivers back in 1985 while working with Bud and his son's at B-west guns here in Tucson) ya really wanna start an AK related "discussion" then feel free to do it via PM and.......... start doin your homework partner...

If ya wanna attack my posts ya actually need to have some actual facts and information to substantiate your lame lil rant, as far as Romanian milspec versus WASR partner thats not even a lil bit of a secret, ya might start by actually learning a few things bout AKs here is a great place to start.........

akfiles.com

Chock full of information for the beginner, which very clearly ya are as ya've demonstrated in your post a total and complete lack of actual hands on experience with AKM type weapons, , people who actually have experience with BUILDING AKM type rifles (15K of em at the site mentioned) can easily outline the differences between civilian production and military production AKM rifles....... ITS VERY COMMON KNOWLEDGE

Massmark,

sorry bout that partner, ya run into these ain't got a clue types all over this place, As far as the absolute best..... that woulda been one of my custom Yugo's but....... after 23 years I just completed my very last commercial build, those rifles are what really got me my reputation for building AKs, but alas...... no more next Would actually be a commercial Arsenal SAM 7-A1 these are ALL USA made milled receiver rifles, extremally reliable and will set ya back about $900-$1000 well worth it. What do ya want it for? ie; just plinking, SHTF scenario? There are other options but the SAM 7 A1 is the best for a general use AK they are heavier than an AKM by almost a pound but this only adds to the more accurate fire when shot offhand as the rifle is more stable, if ya want to save a few $$ however the Century built Yugo's really are a great buy IF you can inspect to make sure the sights are not canted and that the mag latch was fitted properly that will set ya back half as much as the Arsenal, the arsenal will by far be the better finished of the two and all USA made so it skates right past any current legislation regarding imported rifles. I'm assuming you are into a traditional caliber ie; 7.62x39 but if your primary and only real use is going to be punching paper, well this is where the 5.56x45 really shines and that caliber in an arsenal AK is a great paper punch machine look at the SAM-5 it will really take advantage of the 5.56 for varmints or those charging paper plates out there at 500 yards (hate them paper plate attacks .... the paper cuts are h#ll to get healed) price range is a lil lower than the SAM-7-A1 around $800 Now if ya want an underfolder then look at the SAS-M7 its same milled receiver in 7.62x39 but they jump up to around $1200-$1400 depending on where ya buy. There are other models, those 3 are the ones I own, I really wish I woulda got the side optics rail on my SAM7 but they didn't offer a preban config with rail so I ended up adding rails to all 3 the UF however requires removing the optic to fold the stock, if I get time I'm going to make a Yugo M70AB2 style side rail and switch it out, they also make stamped versions but ya asked for the best ;) their AKM pattern rifles are all top of the line as well and have side folder stocks available, do a search for a dealer near you and try handling each. then again if ya put the same $$ into custom wood and have it refinished by Mac's shootin irons ya very likally will not notice much difference from the aforementione Century built Yugo's,

I was the only pro builder who specialized in Virgin kit built Yugo M70s but they weren't cheap as I started with a $450 virgin parts kit (never assembled into a gun, require all finish milling etc.. as trunions, trigger guards, barrel, gas block, sight blocks are all un-finished) I would then carefully true up every component, square the barrels to the trunion, the bolt to the chamber etc.. bolt rail slots were tig welded then re-milled to tight tolerances then lap fitted to the lower rails, same for bolt carrier and top rails, the standard recoil assembly got file 13ed and replaced with a fitted Milled style guide assembly, the barrels were setup with lasers to center everything, all was assembled on a fully heat treated receiver with customer supplied serial number engraved on each component including receiver (everyone always wants their B-Day for some reason!) The receivers are the same ones being used by Century for their Yugo's but theirs are etched on the side instead of the bottom like the "civilian" non-contract version, the entire gun was then rust blued with all the virgin wood finished in hand rubbed oil (average 15 coats of either tung or BLO) ontop of an 800 grit finish the lady who did my wood was so anal she would not stop working it until she had a particular "glow" from the Yugo wood.... My blueing guy was a machinist at the Polish factory 11 for his entire adult life, he is now 80 years old and restores military arms as a "hobby" even though folks pay him very well for his work he still calls it a hobby.....

I've got 2 crates of Bolo mausers I intend to restore as my "hobby" between occasionally takin my own truck out on the road to feed that addiction of lookin through a windshield, cept these days...... I'm not in as big of a hurry as I was before, put a load on my drop deck and point me at a coast I wanna actually SEE the country this time around ;)

As I mentioned ya can save ALOT of $$ with the Century built Yugo's, if ya don't like the basic maganese parkerizing then for a couple hundred bucks Mac can make it a work of art thats impervious to salt water etc..

see some of his work here

http://www.shootiniron.com/

he has a solid reputation as onea the best firearms finishers in the country, and used to do my standard builds for customer supplied kits, this is your next source for trully great wood, he as with all of us is an akfiles member

http://gripsnstocks.com/

And is acknowledged as onea the best in the country as well, in fact my very last build was for an AK Files member, it started as a standard Rommy G but Thanksgiving day I had a mild stroke which caused me to re-evaluate my life, result...... I retired from building guns, anyhow this Rommy G was in my shop when it happened, after I was on my feet again I decided it wasn't going to be just a basic build anymore..... it got the same treatment as my tricked out custom Yugo rifles, the owner had already had custom wood set done by Scott (beutiful quilted burl maple) and now MAC is doing the park/moly resin finish dark od green with light coyote brn side scope mount (low profile) 8x42 scope done to accent with combination of od and the CB for the rings, 5 Yugo BHO mags in CB selector lever (with BHO and finger activation lever) trigger in CB, the Phantom flash hider CB etc.. ya get the idea I was really glad the last build was a "basic Rommy G" insteada one of the fancy ones, this one I KNOW will be getting shot insteada bein a safe queen, The same jig I built in 1986 has been used for over 3,016 builds and.... it collapsed doing the TG rivets on this rifle and is now a paper weight on my desk so I guess it was Gods way of makin sure I understood I AM DONE LOL I don't need any more "hints" if ya need any help feel free to drop a line, use the pm and the system e-mails me


okiewita40,

the SAIGA would be the best deal IF ya didn't have to add $250-$300 to get it to an actual AK configuration, but since ya do its not imported as an AKM pattern rifle its imported as a Sporter, that would make the Yugo M70 series at $429 the best bang for the buck when it comes to quality/dollars in an AKM pattern rifle, the Yugo's severally over engineered the M70 series rifles, they are for all intents and purposes a short barreled RPK........ They use all milled components other than the receiver itself (1.5 mm full heat treated) The are the only AKM with factory tritium night sights, the greade sight can easily be modified to just an on/off gas valve allowing ya to go to manual operation for extreme accuracy from the hammer forged match grade barrel, no other AK period has the ability to be converted to a straight pull bolt action at the flip of a lever! go actually handle an M70AB1-AB2 and come back and tell me what ya've discovered bout the best bang for the buck....... ya will like it and.............. no conversion needed!! $429 and your done other than FFL transfer if it applies to you, ya can't convert that Saiga to a true AKM for the difference in price and still will only have a fraction of what ya get with the YUGO ;)

ya'll have a good night, I gotta clean some guns some lousy gremlin came an got dirty :) wish he'd leave my black powder stuff alone though!!
 
My Romey "G" Lancaster Arms AKM is a huge step up from a WASR that I had a few years back! US Made reciever, Tapco Trigger, etc...Quality is much better and you do get what you pay for.
 
I own a few versions of the AK, all the way from the Maadi to the VEPR, and given your three choices, I would also vote for the Yugo. I like the reinforced receiver and the heavier/stable feel of the rifle. IMHO, I have yet to find an AK that is better made and finished than my VEPR K, but they are getting harder to find and can be around double the price of the Yugo, so once again, go with the Yugo. Good luck and have fun with the AK bug!
 
Dstorm1911, I'm not going to say that your claims are false or not. The simple fact is that this is the internet and we have no real way of proving who we are and what we've done.

Due to this fact we all have to make our decisions based on real world information.

Is the Saiga as good a quality as an actually ak-101? Probably not.

The FACT remains that all the Saiga rifles are built in the Izhmash factory right next to actual Russian military rifles.

Another fact is that many Saigas have been imported having receiver markings matching those of military ak's. The consensus is that military receivers are on occasion used to build the Saigas.

I for one can't imagine that the Izhmash factory, when it already has the machinery and materials to make military ak's, would then waste even more money making new receivers that aren't up to military specs.

An ak receiver is not an expensive thing, even an actual ak-101 receiver.

Even in America you can build a Romy G kit on a quality receiver for around $200 once you have the tools. Considering what Russian workers are paid, and the fact that Izhmash has been setup to make ak's for 60 years, I think the total cost for them is closer to $100 US, maybe less.

Unfortunately, since none of us will ever hold an actual Russian ak-101, there is no way to compare it to a Saiga. I for one sincerely doubt that there would be much, if any, quality difference between the two rifles.
 
dstorm1911: Thank you so much for your post - I truly appreciate your insight and experience with these. I realize some don;t like to hear, (read) your opinion, but count me as one who appreciates your input. I have an AWB-era Arsenal SA-M7s with a Russian PO3 5x21p on deck. I'm not now, nor ever have been an "AK-Man" - they always felt too short for me, but I do love this SA-M7s. I paid $850.00 for it and feel it was money well spent. I'm still in occupied territory, (Massachusetts), but would love to have a custom built AK variant one day....Thanks again for your involved and informative posts....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top